Dynasty Rookie #1 (2008 REVISTED) (1 Viewer)

[comfortably numb]

Copying Jeter23's format, I would like to re-draft the 2008 class 1 year later to have an idea where everyone's value is after 1 season.

Go ahead and consider your league rules while casting a vote.

Also, for fun, if you had pick #1 please state who you took last year, and who you voted on this year.

Last year results thru 16 picks post NFL Draft, courtesy of Mr. Peterson

LINK

1. Darren McFadden, RB - Raiders

2. Jonathan Stewart, RB - Panthers

3. Rashard Mendenhall, RB - Steelers

4. Kevin Smith, RB - Lions

5. Matt Forte, RB - Bears

6. Felix Jones, RB - Cowboys

7. Chris Johnson, RB - Titans

8. Ray Rice, RB - Ravens

9. Matt Ryan, QB - Falcons

10a. Devin Thomas, WR - Redskins

10b. James Hardy, WR - Bills

12. Limas Sweed, WR - Steelers

13. Jamaal Charles, RB - Chiefs

14a. Donnie Avery, WR - Rams

14b. Malcom Kelly, WR - Redskins

16. Joe flacco, QB Ravens

It will be interesting to see how far a player has slid or jumped up.

 

[Anthony Borbely]

I had a 1.01 and took Stewart last year.

If I could do it over again, I would do the same thing.

Stewart looks like a stud when he plays and I'm more than willing to wait for him to start. I think he was the most talented player in last year's draft, with all due respect to Chris Johnson, who would be my second pick.

 

[Andy Dufresne]

Based on this year's results, I think the 1.1 should be Chris Johnson.

However, I hope McFadden can come back from those turf toe injuries because I think he showed he has the talent to be really good. Even though he plays for Oakland.

 

[MAC_32]

I had a 1.01 and took Stewart last year. If I could do it over again, I would do the same thing. Stewart looks like a stud when he plays and I'm more than willing to wait for him to start. I think he was the most talented player in last year's draft, with all due respect to Chris Johnson, who would be my second pick.

J Stew looks like he can do everything those who bought into him before last season thought he could. Injuries slowed development in year 1, but once healthy he looked the part.I maintain DMC is a great buy low if you can still get him cheap, I'm probably higher on him now than I was last offseason, when healthy he looked like a feature NFL back he just wasn't healthy that much.Forte's my easy #3 here, but long term I think DMC will outproduce him.1 J Stew2 Black Pearl3 Forte4 DMC

 

[-OZ-]

Chris Johnson, but I could easily see taking Forte, Stew or Matt Ryan. Any of the 4 would be a good pick.

 

[Crippler]

I voted Ryan with a 16 team league that gives 6 per TD and you can start 2 QB. But that wont fly in most leagues and were these polls are flawed in the end.

I will vote Flacco 2nd.

1st RB would be Forte.

 

[Pictus Cat]

Went with Chris Johnson.

We draft before the NFL draft. Always a risk because the best talent might go to a team that is poorly run an not clicking.

The #1 in our league was McFadden.

 

[EBF]

I had a 1.01 and took Stewart last year. If I could do it over again, I would do the same thing. Stewart looks like a stud when he plays and I'm more than willing to wait for him to start. I think he was the most talented player in last year's draft, with all due respect to Chris Johnson, who would be my second pick.

This is pretty much how I feel. It's gotta be Johnson or Stewart. I favor Stewart because I think he has the better overall game. Forte and Slaton deserve kudos for their great rookie seasons, but I think they're less likely than CJ to maintain their success.

 

[big country]

Forte please