Dynasty Rookie #10 (1 Viewer)

[jeter23]

For those of you who own the 1.09 rookie pick in your dynasty league, or those that would like to own it, who are you taking?

Feel free to take your league rules and other details into account, as they are not specified. PPR, scarcity of RBs and obviously, team need would affect each vote.

1.01 Michael Crabtree, WR 38% (Moreno, 27%)

1.02 Knowshon Moreno, RB 62% (Wells, 17%)

1.03 Chris Wells, RB 45% (McCoy, 35%)

1.04 LeSean McCoy, RB 71% (Greene, 17%)

1.05 Shonn Greene, RB 52% (Maclin, 21%)

1.06 Jeremy Maclin, WR 58% (Harvin, 19%)

1.07 Percy Harvin, WR 44% (Brown, 17%)

1.08 Donald Brown, RB 40% (Stafford, 29%)

1.09 Darius Heyward-Bey, WR 34% (Stafford, 32%)

 

[jeter23]

Stafford has a sizeable lead early, but I will leave it up a bit longer.

 

[Holland Freeze]

If Stafford is taken off the board I have to begin sorting through/organizing my next tier of WR's. Would appreciate any comments about who we need of add. A few that come to mind are:

Juaquin Iglesias

Derrick Williams

Louis Murphy

Brian Robiskie

Deon Butler and

Jarett Dillard.

 

[MAC_32]

If Stafford is taken off the board I have to begin sorting through/organizing my next tier of WR's. Would appreciate any comments about who we need of add. A few that come to mind are:Juaquin IglesiasDerrick WilliamsLouis MurphyBrian RobiskieDeon Butler andJarett Dillard.

I'd order themDillardWilliamsButlerRobiskie(several other players)MurphyIglesiasThat said, I'd have Britt, Nicks, and Collie above all of them.

 

[Holland Freeze]

If Stafford is taken off the board I have to begin sorting through/organizing my next tier of WR's. Would appreciate any comments about who we need of add. A few that come to mind are:Juaquin IglesiasDerrick WilliamsLouis MurphyBrian RobiskieDeon Butler andJarett Dillard.

I'd order themDillardWilliamsButlerRobiskie(several other players)MurphyIglesiasThat said, I'd have Britt, Nicks, and Collie above all of them.

I did not include Britt, Nicks and Collie since they are already options. Iglesias is moving down my list and appears to have been doing only mediocre during the Sr. Bowl practices. If not looking for immediate production I would still take Williams ahead of Dillard but both Dillard and Butler have been looking very promising and a good Bowl game/combine could easily bump them up.I realize it is still early for much serious discussion but where does someone like Pat White begin to garner consideration? Heis a good enough athlete for fairly early consideration but does not seem to have done much to establish himself as an NFL caliber QB. Is he shooting himself in the foot by not working out as a WR as well during the Sr. Bowl practices?

 

[Chachi]

Iglesias is moving down my list and appears to have been doing only mediocre during the Sr. Bowl practices.

Just my opinion but from watching all the practices (with the exception of today(day 4)) I have come away impressed with IglesiasI have been impressed with Iglesias, Gibson, Robiskie, Derrick Williams and also with Massaquoi before he got hurt. Have you watched the practices or going by what the scouts/commentators are saying? My opinion is to be taken with a grain of salt though since I am no scout and am probaly missing things that are important.

 

[FUBAR]

I realize it is still early for much serious discussion but where does someone like Pat White begin to garner consideration? Heis a good enough athlete for fairly early consideration but does not seem to have done much to establish himself as an NFL caliber QB. Is he shooting himself in the foot by not working out as a WR as well during the Sr. Bowl practices?

I might take a chance on him as a late round pick, but not before the 3rd at the earliest. I like the kid, but he doesn't strike me as a future Randle El / Bennett or anything special.

 

[Chachi]

I would like to see these guys in the next poll:

Devin Moore

Rashad Jennings

I would like these removed:

Brandon Pettigrew (He won't go for a long time)

Austin Collie (No clue why he's in the poll, I have a good 8 WR ahead of him who aren't in the poll)

For the next few picks I'd go:

Nicks

Britt

Sanchez

Jennings

Moore

Iglesias

Jeremiah Johnson

Robiskie

Here I'd consider Pettigrew and Collie would still be a ways down off my radar.

 

[Holland Freeze]

Iglesias is moving down my list and appears to have been doing only mediocre during the Sr. Bowl practices.

Just my opinion but from watching all the practices (with the exception of today(day 4)) I have come away impressed with IglesiasI have been impressed with Iglesias, Gibson, Robiskie, Derrick Williams and also with Massaquoi before he got hurt. Have you watched the practices or going by what the scouts/commentators are saying? My opinion is to be taken with a grain of salt though since I am no scout and am probaly missing things that are important.

Not being where the weather is even close to being warm I have read what reports I have been able to come across and it sounds as though the other WR's have done better which is disappointing because I originally had him above all of them.I am not claiming to be a scout or even anyone people should take to seriously, I definitely have more questions than answers at this point. I would be interested in reading what has impressed you?

 

[Holland Freeze]

I realize it is still early for much serious discussion but where does someone like Pat White begin to garner consideration? Heis a good enough athlete for fairly early consideration but does not seem to have done much to establish himself as an NFL caliber QB. Is he shooting himself in the foot by not working out as a WR as well during the Sr. Bowl practices?

I might take a chance on him as a late round pick, but not before the 3rd at the earliest. I like the kid, but he doesn't strike me as a future Randle El / Bennett or anything special.

Having had both Randle El and Bennett on my rosters I have been disappointed by both of them so the prospect of White not even reaching their level is disappointing. I can't help myself though the great athlete but not an NFL QB entices me every time.

 

[Chachi]

Iglesias is moving down my list and appears to have been doing only mediocre during the Sr. Bowl practices.

Just my opinion but from watching all the practices (with the exception of today(day 4)) I have come away impressed with IglesiasI have been impressed with Iglesias, Gibson, Robiskie, Derrick Williams and also with Massaquoi before he got hurt. Have you watched the practices or going by what the scouts/commentators are saying? My opinion is to be taken with a grain of salt though since I am no scout and am probaly missing things that are important.

Not being where the weather is even close to being warm I have read what reports I have been able to come across and it sounds as though the other WR's have done better which is disappointing because I originally had him above all of them.I am not claiming to be a scout or even anyone people should take to seriously, I definitely have more questions than answers at this point. I would be interested in reading what has impressed you?

I'm not there either, just watched on NFLN. Robiskie and Gibson actually have impressed me more than Iglesias but Iglesias is right there in the next group for me with Williams/Massaquoi. I'm not a scout either so take what I say with a grain of salt. I honestly haven't read much on Iglesias and how he's done, could you tell me where you read reports on him cause I haven't been able to find any myself.

 

[Holland Freeze]

I would like to see these guys in the next poll:Devin Moore: I have a handful of RB's ahead of him, why are you so high on him?

Rashad Jennings: He has been shooting up my board of late as well.

I would like these removed:

Brandon Pettigrew (He won't go for a long time): I would disagree since he will be the 1st TE taken and I would like to see when he begins garnering serious attention

Austin Collie (No clue why he's in the poll, I have a good 8 WR ahead of him who aren't in the poll): He is not this high on my list either - but that makes me think I better check him out further

For the next few picks I'd go:

Nicks:: He has been moving up my board but not as sold as others appear to be

Britt: He will be in the mix for next up after Stafford goes off the board

Sanchez: #2 QB but I suspect he will go well before I'm comfortable taking him so I'm already eyeing Freeman

Jennings: If he performs as well as I anticipate in the game he will be competing for my next vote as well

Moore: Why do you have him ahead of Davis, Ringer and Sutton?

Iglesias: I'm looking forward to seeing him in the actual game so I can evaluate his performance for myself

Jeremiah Johnson: He is right behind the other RB's I mentioned above

Robiskie: Seems about right but there are a handful of others that fit in nicely around this pick as well

quote]

 

[Holland Freeze]

I'm not there either, just watched on NFLN. Robiskie and Gibson actually have impressed me more than Iglesias but Iglesias is right there in the next group for me with Williams/Massaquoi. I'm not a scout either so take what I say with a grain of salt. I honestly haven't read much on Iglesias and how he's done, could you tell me where you read reports on him cause I haven't been able to find any myself.

I am definitely NOT putting Iglesias down and have him in the group. I just bumped him down in what I consider a pretty tight grouping, at least at this stage of the game.I think there was a thread on this board giving some sights but I have also had a little success entering "2009 Senior Bowl reports" into a search engine.

 

[Chachi]

Devin Moore = speed, I see him as a Felix Jones clone.

I actually would take Ringer over Moore but after Jennings, Ringer is the type of player who slips your mind since there is virtually no talk about him, I think I'm actually higher on Ringer than most here. As far as James Davis his stock is dwindling away, he really should have came out last year, he cost himself millions. James Davis has been very unimpressive at the Sr. practices, much in the same way as Ramses Barden, they have both really plummeted on my lists. Tyrell Sutton is a player I like too, I would put him more down with the Jeremiah Johnson area though. I really go back and forth on Sutton and might target him in rookie drafts as his ADP will likely be low enough to take him.

 

[Holland Freeze]

Pretty high praise for Moore, I'll keep my eye on him combine can't get here fast enough)

Why did Ringer back out of the Senior Bowl, is he still recuperating? Didn't he have post season surgery? A factor that will make the combine or his workout more important to accurately evaluate.

I agree Davis has been slipping down the chart as players like Jennings have moved up.

I currently have Sutton ranked just ahead of Johnson but behind the others mentioned.

 

[MAC_32]

I would like to see these guys in the next poll:

Devin Moore

Rashad Jennings

I would like these removed:

Brandon Pettigrew (He won't go for a long time)

Austin Collie (No clue why he's in the poll, I have a good 8 WR ahead of him who aren't in the poll)

For the next few picks I'd go:

Nicks

Britt

Sanchez

Jennings

Moore

Iglesias

Jeremiah Johnson

Robiskie

Here I'd consider Pettigrew and Collie would still be a ways down off my radar.

Because some of us don't share the same opinion as you? Is that ok? or is groupthink mode the norm around here?As I have said in the other threads I will be voting for Britt, then Nicks, then Collie and the only reason I have that order right now is due to popularity, I am torn between the three and think they're all potential late first rounders. I really like a few guys in the next group of WR's (notably both Penn St guys and Dillard) but they're a clear step below those three imo. I don't see much seperation between the top QB's (nor do I particularly want them before seeing where they'll go) and the RB's that are left.

I agree regarding Pettigrew, I will probably have Casey ranked above him when draft season comes around. Still, it'd be nice to see when they begin to garner some attention.

 

[Chachi]

I would like to see these guys in the next poll:

Devin Moore

Rashad Jennings

I would like these removed:

Brandon Pettigrew (He won't go for a long time)

Austin Collie (No clue why he's in the poll, I have a good 8 WR ahead of him who aren't in the poll)

For the next few picks I'd go:

Nicks

Britt

Sanchez

Jennings

Moore

Iglesias

Jeremiah Johnson

Robiskie

Here I'd consider Pettigrew and Collie would still be a ways down off my radar.

Because some of us don't share the same opinion as you? Is that ok? or is groupthink mode the norm around here?As I have said in the other threads I will be voting for Britt, then Nicks, then Collie and the only reason I have that order right now is due to popularity, I am torn between the three and think they're all potential late first rounders. I really like a few guys in the next group of WR's (notably both Penn St guys and Dillard) but they're a clear step below those three imo. I don't see much seperation between the top QB's (nor do I particularly want them before seeing where they'll go) and the RB's that are left.

I agree regarding Pettigrew, I will probably have Casey ranked above him when draft season comes around. Still, it'd be nice to see when they begin to garner some attention.

The only reason I brought it up was because he had no votes yet. I was only trying to add Jennings/Moore so I thought we'd take out 2 to make room. The best solution would be to have more options, keep Collie & Pettigrew, add Casey, Jennings, Moore, Iglesias and some more. I wasn't trying to step on anyones toes, the best resolution is to use more options.

 

[Chachi]

I would like to see these guys in the next poll:

Devin Moore

Rashad Jennings

I would like these removed:

Brandon Pettigrew (He won't go for a long time)

Austin Collie (No clue why he's in the poll, I have a good 8 WR ahead of him who aren't in the poll)

For the next few picks I'd go:

Nicks

Britt

Sanchez

Jennings

Moore

Iglesias

Jeremiah Johnson

Robiskie

Here I'd consider Pettigrew and Collie would still be a ways down off my radar.

Because some of us don't share the same opinion as you? Is that ok? or is groupthink mode the norm around here?As I have said in the other threads I will be voting for Britt, then Nicks, then Collie and the only reason I have that order right now is due to popularity, I am torn between the three and think they're all potential late first rounders. I really like a few guys in the next group of WR's (notably both Penn St guys and Dillard) but they're a clear step below those three imo. I don't see much seperation between the top QB's (nor do I particularly want them before seeing where they'll go) and the RB's that are left.

I agree regarding Pettigrew, I will probably have Casey ranked above him when draft season comes around. Still, it'd be nice to see when they begin to garner some attention.

I'd like to see Dilliard in the next poll too, I have a feeling he's going to go pretty high at FBG.

 

[MAC_32]

I would like to see these guys in the next poll:

Devin Moore

Rashad Jennings

I would like these removed:

Brandon Pettigrew (He won't go for a long time)

Austin Collie (No clue why he's in the poll, I have a good 8 WR ahead of him who aren't in the poll)

For the next few picks I'd go:

Nicks

Britt

Sanchez

Jennings

Moore

Iglesias

Jeremiah Johnson

Robiskie

Here I'd consider Pettigrew and Collie would still be a ways down off my radar.

Because some of us don't share the same opinion as you? Is that ok? or is groupthink mode the norm around here?As I have said in the other threads I will be voting for Britt, then Nicks, then Collie and the only reason I have that order right now is due to popularity, I am torn between the three and think they're all potential late first rounders. I really like a few guys in the next group of WR's (notably both Penn St guys and Dillard) but they're a clear step below those three imo. I don't see much seperation between the top QB's (nor do I particularly want them before seeing where they'll go) and the RB's that are left.

I agree regarding Pettigrew, I will probably have Casey ranked above him when draft season comes around. Still, it'd be nice to see when they begin to garner some attention.

I'd like to see Dilliard in the next poll too, I have a feeling he's going to go pretty high at FBG.

I like Collie more (and I really like Dillard), but I also recognize that Dillard's (correctly) developed quite the fanbase in here.