Dynasty rookie #2 (1 Viewer)

[Multiple Scores]

If you owned the #2 rookie pick in a Dynasty (NON-PPR) draft who would you take?

Always feel free to ask for new additions to the poll choices.

Previous winners:

1. Knowshon Moreno, RB, Georgia

 

[FreeBaGeL]

I'll keep voting on Wells until he wins one. Hating on Wells is the "cool" thing to do right now, but when the dust settles I think he'll be the best back, with the most upside out of this class.

 

[Hersh]

"Beanie" will be force to be reckoned with!

 

[Duckboy]

Wells this time, but again it's a tossup for the 1st three in my mind until after the draft.

 

[jurb26]

Just too hard to pass up on the upside of Wells. Who knows, maybe he can put it all together in the NFL?

 

[SteevieG]

Went with Wells here. I do have 1.02 and am hoping Moreno falls to me but the more I think about it the less I think it's going to happen. So, with the 2nd pick I will take Wells and hope for the best.

 

[munchkin]

Crabtree will be putting up points long after "Beanie" has spent his last NFL paycheck.

 

[jojoh07]

where's greene ?????

 

[Holy Schneikes]

Interesting that Crabtree goes from the only can't-miss prospect in the draft, and clear #1 dynasty pick to a #3 over a couple of months.

Wells' pro-day sure did help his FBG stock, if not his real draft stock. Couple of months ago, he would be hard pressed to be in the top 4 or 5 consensus backs, let alone the consensus #2 overall.

Not necessarily disagreeing, just an observation.

 

[fruity pebbles]

Interesting that Crabtree goes from the only can't-miss prospect in the draft, and clear #1 dynasty pick to a #3 over a couple of months.Wells' pro-day sure did help his FBG stock, if not his real draft stock. Couple of months ago, he would be hard pressed to be in the top 4 or 5 consensus backs, let alone the consensus #2 overall.Not necessarily disagreeing, just an observation.

no ppr makes a big difference

 

[Holy Schneikes]

Interesting that Crabtree goes from the only can't-miss prospect in the draft, and clear #1 dynasty pick to a #3 over a couple of months.Wells' pro-day sure did help his FBG stock, if not his real draft stock. Couple of months ago, he would be hard pressed to be in the top 4 or 5 consensus backs, let alone the consensus #2 overall.Not necessarily disagreeing, just an observation.

no ppr makes a big difference

PPR or no, I think two months ago, Crabtree wins this poll, hands down. Just the impression I got. There would have been a few in the Moreno camp, but I think by and large, Crabtree was viewed as the clear prize of the draft (for fantasy purposes).Something soured along the way. No running and the "shrinkage" at the combine, the injury, etc. Again, I'm not really disputing anything, just pointing out that things change around here very quickly.

 

[Yitbos69]

Interesting that Crabtree goes from the only can't-miss prospect in the draft, and clear #1 dynasty pick to a #3 over a couple of months.Wells' pro-day sure did help his FBG stock, if not his real draft stock. Couple of months ago, he would be hard pressed to be in the top 4 or 5 consensus backs, let alone the consensus #2 overall.Not necessarily disagreeing, just an observation.

no ppr makes a big difference

PPR or no, I think two months ago, Crabtree wins this poll, hands down. Just the impression I got. There would have been a few in the Moreno camp, but I think by and large, Crabtree was viewed as the clear prize of the draft (for fantasy purposes).Something soured along the way. No running and the "shrinkage" at the combine, the injury, etc. Again, I'm not really disputing anything, just pointing out that things change around here very quickly.

In PPR leagues Crabtree is still #1...... I am not sure he ever was in non-PPR leagues...in my only non-PPR league Fitz was 24th overall... but in my PPR leagues he was 8th....WR's lose a ton of value in non-ppr leagues

 

[Cookiemonster]

where's greene ?????

+1Many of us have Greene and/or D.Brown rated over Wells. You can't put Britt & Nicks on this list yet without including all top 10 RBs if you're asking non-PPR.

 

[Multiple Scores]

where's greene ?????

+1Many of us have Greene and/or D.Brown rated over Wells. You can't put Britt & Nicks on this list yet without including all top 10 RBs if you're asking non-PPR.

I'll add Greene in the next poll, before his pro day yesterday he was free falling more than I thought was warranted. I think that Greene deserves his own pro day thread, his stock is going to soar.

 

[rzrback77]

Not a big fan, but Wells seems the obvious choice in non-ppr here. Next will be Crabtree and then it will get interesting.

 

[Chunky Soup]

The draft completely changes this. Can't you wait a few more weeks?

 

[Biabreakable]

The draft completely changes this. Can't you wait a few more weeks?

I think pre-NFL draft rankings are more based on player talent and more useful than post-NFL draft rankings which change because of situation.Both are important but I would not completely change your rankings because of the NFL draft. If you do you will miss out on talent that may look to be buried because of situation but are actually the highest value targets and what separates great owners from good ones in highly competitive leagues.

 

[BigTex]

The draft completely changes this. Can't you wait a few more weeks?

I think pre-NFL draft rankings are more based on player talent and more useful than post-NFL draft rankings which change because of situation.Both are important but I would not completely change your rankings because of the NFL draft. If you do you will miss out on talent that may look to be buried because of situation but are actually the highest value targets and what separates great owners from good ones in highly competitive leagues.

Dude