Dynasty Rookie #2 (1 Viewer)

[jeter23]

So, for those of you who own the 1.02 rookie pick in your dynasrty league, or those that would like to own it, who are you taking?

Feel free to take your league rules and other details into account, as they are not specified. PPR, scarcity of RBs and obviously, team need would affect each vote.

1.01 Dez Bryant 45% (Spiller, 19%)

 

[finito]

For me it's between Spiller, Dwyer and Best but where they land will have a huge impact on which one I like.

Based on sheer talent I'd go Spiller.

 

[rzrback77]

Please remind me again whether this is ppr or not. Well, i read the first post better, but does that indicate it is not specifically either one?

Seems odd to not indicate one or the other.

 

[JohnnyU]

For me it's between Spiller, Dwyer and Best but where they land will have a huge impact on which one I like.Based on sheer talent I'd go Spiller.

Based on sheer talent I'd go Best.

 

[jeter23]

Please remind me again whether this is ppr or not. Well, i read the first post better, but does that indicate it is not specifically either one?Seems odd to not indicate one or the other.

Either one I guess. Almost all of my leagues are PPR, so that is how I am voting.

 

[BigTex]

I voted Spiller over Best only because Best small injury woes, over Dwyer because of the offense he played in is questionable as I agree with some of the latest college rankings and analysis I've recently read.

 

[BigTex]

Please remind me again whether this is ppr or not. Well, i read the first post better, but does that indicate it is not specifically either one?Seems odd to not indicate one or the other.

Either one I guess. Almost all of my leagues are PPR, so that is how I am voting.

I'm voting on pure talent

 

[Mainevent]

Voted for Bay-Bay Thomas... only vote for other to this point.

ETA: you should keep at least the 'top' player from each of the major skill positions in the vote.

 

[Romulan]

Voted for Bay-Bay Thomas... only vote for other to this point.ETA: you should keep at least the 'top' player from each of the major skill positions in the vote.

Make that 2 for Thomas.

 

[mikel2014]

It looks like the consensus is between Spiller and Dwyer. I voted for Dwyer because I'm far more confident in his ability to be an every down back. Spiller is electric, but he's a higher risk/reward than Dwyer. I can certainly see the case for both though.

 

[awesomeness]

My vote goes to Ryan Mathews.

Spiller is going to be a bust if he's a top 3 pick imo.

 

[inzanitee]

Voted for Bay-Bay Thomas... only vote for other to this point.ETA: you should keep at least the 'top' player from each of the major skill positions in the vote.

Make that 2 for Thomas.

I like him a lot as well. If I had the 2nd pick I'd probably trade down a few spots and hope to nab him a bit later (1.6ish)

 

[identikit]

My vote goes to Ryan Mathews. Spiller is going to be a bust if he's a top 3 pick imo.

And not a bust if he's a 1.4-1.6 pick?

 

[jeter23]

Closed- Spiller