Dynasty Rookie #8 (1 Viewer)

[jeter23]

For those of you who own the 1.08 rookie pick in your dynasty league, or those that would like to own it, who are you taking?

Feel free to take your league rules and other details into account, as they are not specified. PPR, scarcity of RBs and obviously, team need would affect each vote.

1.01 Michael Crabtree, WR 38% (Moreno, 27%)

1.02 Knowshon Moreno, RB 62% (Wells, 17%)

1.03 Chris Wells, RB 45% (McCoy, 35%)

1.04 LeSean McCoy, RB 71% (Greene, 17%)

1.05 Shonn Greene, RB 52% (Maclin, 21%)

1.06 Jeremy Maclin, WR 58% (Harvin, 19%)

1.07 Percy Harvin, WR 44% (Brown, 17%)

 

[MAC_32]

Please add Nicks and Collie to the next poll.

I vote for Brown anyway, but I see those two and Britt very similarly, and all three ahead of Heyward Bey.

 

[Cover2]

time to consider adding Chase Coffman as well?

 

[Holland Freeze]

Has this thread spent itself already or just replaced w/ game day anticipation?

 

[jeter23]

Has this thread spent itself already or just replaced w/ game day anticipation?

Partly due to the dropoff in the big names. May not be the year to have a late 1st rounder.

 

[awesomeness]

Has this thread spent itself already or just replaced w/ game day anticipation?

Partly due to the dropoff in the big names. May not be the year to have a late 1st rounder.

After the first 7 there seems to be a significant drop off to me. I think i'd rather have an early 2nd, especially if i can get either Britt or Nicks there.

 

[Holland Freeze]

Has this thread spent itself already or just replaced w/ game day anticipation?

Partly due to the dropoff in the big names. May not be the year to have a late 1st rounder.

After the first 7 there seems to be a significant drop off to me. I think i'd rather have an early 2nd, especially if i can get either Britt or Nicks there.

That surprises me - it would seem to me that after the big names are gone this type of thread really becomes interesting. The Beanie v Moreno v McCoy conversation is interesting but regardless of what order you have them there is little doubt they are near the top of the list. I was hoping that as we moved on there would be more coverage/conversation... of why people are going in 1 direction rather than another because the players are not as obvious. I have voted Stafford the past couple times but that is more because the team that I am focusing on for responding this thread has a need at that position. If I was not approaching it from that perspective I would have focused more on the RB and WR positions like the majority. Even with the need, once Stafford is off the board though I would be holding off on voting for Sanchez until the end of the next tier of RB/WR's.

 

[awesomeness]

Has this thread spent itself already or just replaced w/ game day anticipation?

Partly due to the dropoff in the big names. May not be the year to have a late 1st rounder.

After the first 7 there seems to be a significant drop off to me. I think i'd rather have an early 2nd, especially if i can get either Britt or Nicks there.

That surprises me - it would seem to me that after the big names are gone this type of thread really becomes interesting. The Beanie v Moreno v McCoy conversation is interesting but regardless of what order you have them there is little doubt they are near the top of the list. I was hoping that as we moved on there would be more coverage/conversation... of why people are going in 1 direction rather than another because the players are not as obvious. I have voted Stafford the past couple times but that is more because the team that I am focusing on for responding this thread has a need at that position. If I was not approaching it from that perspective I would have focused more on the RB and WR positions like the majority. Even with the need, once Stafford is off the board though I would be holding off on voting for Sanchez until the end of the next tier of RB/WR's.

i voted for Kenny Britt, and by the looks of things i'm going to be voting for him for a while. I could understand a QB being taken about here for a team that needs one, but i'm not a big fan of either the QBs. Donald Brown is intriguing, but his talent level screams backup to me. He's going to have to be drafted pretty high in order to get a shot at being the workhorse back. Britt size is ideal, he's progressed well throught his college career, he catches the ball and has no problem going over the middle, can break tackles, good speed. If this guy has a good combine and goes to the Giants, i will definitely make moves to try and acquire this guy in many leagues.

 

[Holland Freeze]

i voted for Kenny Britt, and by the looks of things i'm going to be voting for him for a while. I could understand a QB being taken about here for a team that needs one, but i'm not a big fan of either the QBs. Donald Brown is intriguing, but his talent level screams backup to me. He's going to have to be drafted pretty high in order to get a shot at being the workhorse back. Britt size is ideal, he's progressed well throught his college career, he catches the ball and has no problem going over the middle, can break tackles, good speed. If this guy has a good combine and goes to the Giants, i will definitely make moves to try and acquire this guy in many leagues.

I have Britt in the middle of my next tier or WR's after those already taken and Hey-Bey and could see any of them moving up with a good combine or being drafted into a position where they won't be sitting on the bench for most of the first season or two.I was looking forward to Bradford coming out and sitting on him for a year. I had Stafford ranked just below Bradford though. I'm hoping he drops into the 2nd round because at this point my team did so poorly that I will be taking one of the players ranked ahead of him w/ my first pick. I share your opinion on Sanchez and am almost hoping someone else takes him before I am willing to so I can wait a little longer and take a low risk gamble w/ someone like Freeman.