[DYNASTY] - Top 25 Under 25 (1 Viewer)

[JayMan]

Assuming a 12 teams league;

FBG scoring;

1/2/3/1 starting roster;

Having the possibility to hold on to the players all long as you wish...

Using the "I wouldn't trade #13 for #14 approach"...

Only players that are in the NFL and are under 25 years old were ranked...

1. Larry Fitzgerald2. Steven Jackson3. Braylon Edwards4. Willis McGahee5. Ronnie Brown6. Reggie Bush7. Roy Williams8. Laurence Maroney9. Frank Gore10. Andre Johnson11. Matt Jones12. Matt Leinart13. Carnell Williams14. Greg Jennings15. Kevin Jones16. Kellen Winslow17. Mark Clayton18. Michael Turner19. Alex Smith20. Vince Young21. Lee Evans22. Vernon Davis23. Cedric Benson24. Jay Cutler25. Marques Colston

Let's discuss...

 

[broncofan13000]

Assuming a 12 teams league;

FBG scoring;

1/2/3/1 starting roster;

Having the possibility to hold on to the players all long as you wish...

Using the "I wouldn't trade #13 for #14 approach"...

Only players that are in the NFL and are under 25 years old were ranked...

1. Larry Fitzgerald2. Steven Jackson3. Braylon Edwards4. Willis McGahee5. Ronnie Brown6. Reggie Bush7. Roy Williams8. Laurence Maroney9. Frank Gore10. Andre Johnson11. Matt Jones12. Matt Leinart13. Carnell Williams14. Greg Jennings15. Kevin Jones16. Kellen Winslow17. Mark Clayton18. Michael Turner19. Alex Smith20. Vince Young21. Lee Evans22. Vernon Davis23. Cedric Benson24. Jay Cutler25. Marques ColstonLet's discuss...

If this list is based on fantasy imho.For starters, Braylon shouldn't be higher than Reggie or most of the RB's on the list, Deangelo should be on there ... too much to disagree with...

this is a fantasy list right?

eta: I might be missing the whole point of this exercise, if i am ignore my post.

 

[Colin Dowling]

You lost me at Ronnie Brown being that much higher than Turner...

 

[buccosfan]

Yeah, Michael Turner looks good ... but he's still a Charger, which means he's still behind LT2. Which means his only value is based on one of two big IFs happening. If LT2 gets hurt; if Turner winds up somewhere else.

Ronnie Brown is in a solid position in Miami.

 

[Colin Dowling]

Yeah, Michael Turner looks good ... but he's still a Charger, which means he's still behind LT2. Which means his only value is based on one of two big IFs happening. If LT2 gets hurt; if Turner winds up somewhere else.Ronnie Brown is in a solid position in Miami.

Ronnie Brown and the whole of the Miami offense looks terrible. I'm not sure howyou are defining "solid"

 

[buccosfan]

I define solid as someone who is in position now to have more of an opportunity next year.

 

[snarfsnarf]

I define solid as someone who is in position now to have more of an opportunity next year.

Seriously, Turners is a nice guy to stash on your roster but I think the chances are pretty good that you'll have to sit on him for another year before he gets a shot at a starters job.

 

[crush304]

#1 clinton portis

he just turned 25 but is younger than at least a few of the players listed

 

[-OZ-]

Going with Jayman's concept...

Only players that are in the NFL and are under 25 years old were ranked...

1. Reggie Bush2. Larry Fitzgerald3. Willis McGahee4. Steven Jackson5. Braylon Edwards6. Roy Williams7. Ronnie Brown8. Laurence Maroney9. Andre Johnson10. Matt Jones11. Carnell Williams12. Lee Evans13. Matt Leinart14. Greg Jennings15. Kevin Jones16. Michael Turner17. Kellen Winslow18. Mark Clayton19. Vernon Davis20. Vince Young21. Marques Colston22. Frank Gore23. Cedric Benson24. Jay Cutler25. Alex Smith

Pretty close anyway, some tough calls here.

 

[2112]

#1 clinton portis he just turned 25 but is younger than at least a few of the players listed

 

[aposulli]

Assuming a 12 teams league;

FBG scoring;

1/2/3/1 starting roster;

Having the possibility to hold on to the players all long as you wish...

Using the "I wouldn't trade #13 for #14 approach"...

Only players that are in the NFL and are under 25 years old were ranked...

1. Larry Fitzgerald2. Steven Jackson3. Braylon Edwards4. Willis McGahee5. Ronnie Brown6. Reggie Bush7. Roy Williams8. Laurence Maroney9. Frank Gore10. Andre Johnson11. Matt Jones12. Matt Leinart13. Carnell Williams14. Greg Jennings15. Kevin Jones16. Kellen Winslow17. Mark Clayton18. Michael Turner19. Alex Smith20. Vince Young21. Lee Evans22. Vernon Davis23. Cedric Benson24. Jay Cutler25. Marques Colston

Let's discuss...

Braylon Edwards should be about 6-10 slots lower. Solid list with the exception of the Portis omission. I know, I know... nothing that hasn't already been said.