Dynasty vs. Redraft RBs (1 Viewer)

[Bayhawks]

I am in 3 different leagues, one is a dynasty league, and the other two are redraft leagues. I am having a tough time ranking RBs. Since their careers tend to be shorter than WRs or QBs, I feel that there is more of a difference in how they should be ranked in dynasty and redraft leagues. Obviously, the top guys are the top guys, redraft or dynasty, but when I get to around RB #10, I am having a hard time placing them. I honestly feel that for this year, Travis Henry and Edge should be #10 and #11, since I feel that they will have a better 2007 than the guys I have right after them-Laurence Maroney, MJD, and Reggie Bush. Obviously over the next 5 years, the 3 younger guys should outperform both Henry and Edge, but how do other FBGs value the current year vs "long term" in dynasty rankings?

 

[Driver]

I am in 3 different leagues, one is a dynasty league, and the other two are redraft leagues. I am having a tough time ranking RBs. Since their careers tend to be shorter than WRs or QBs, I feel that there is more of a difference in how they should be ranked in dynasty and redraft leagues. Obviously, the top guys are the top guys, redraft or dynasty, but when I get to around RB #10, I am having a hard time placing them. I honestly feel that for this year, Travis Henry and Edge should be #10 and #11, since I feel that they will have a better 2007 than the guys I have right after them-Laurence Maroney, MJD, and Reggie Bush. Obviously over the next 5 years, the 3 younger guys should outperform both Henry and Edge, but how do other FBGs value the current year vs "long term" in dynasty rankings?

Check out the "Dynasty Rankings" thread by Fear & Loathing (here in Shark Pool). Lots of good info there.

 

[m_sell31]

I am in 3 different leagues, one is a dynasty league, and the other two are redraft leagues. I am having a tough time ranking RBs. Since their careers tend to be shorter than WRs or QBs, I feel that there is more of a difference in how they should be ranked in dynasty and redraft leagues. Obviously, the top guys are the top guys, redraft or dynasty, but when I get to around RB #10, I am having a hard time placing them. I honestly feel that for this year, Travis Henry and Edge should be #10 and #11, since I feel that they will have a better 2007 than the guys I have right after them-Laurence Maroney, MJD, and Reggie Bush. Obviously over the next 5 years, the 3 younger guys should outperform both Henry and Edge, but how do other FBGs value the current year vs "long term" in dynasty rankings?

Check out the "Dynasty Rankings" thread by Fear & Loathing (here in Shark Pool). Lots of good info there.

link? Thanks in advance!

 

[Biabreakable]

Well this is the question isn't it?

http://forums.footballguys.com/forum/index...=296123&hl=

F&L's answers (he has a totaly different method than the ones discussed in above thread)

http://forums.footballguys.com/forum/index...howtopic=283290