Dynasty who do you like more Hill or the Crow? (1 Viewer)

[Sabertooth]

I have both these players on my team and I value Crowell higher based on situation. Both are character flags. Both are obviously rookies on Orange teams in the AFC North. But I was wondering who people rank higher in terms or PPR dynasty production so I can move one of them.

 

[SameSongNDance]

I think you should move Hill for Shonn Greene. That or BGE because word is BGE is over his hip injury and will be signed soon. Yeah, definitely move Hill for BGE.

 

[Zyphros]

Is there a thread for Crowell vs everyone now? Jeez

 

[Sabertooth]

No just Hill.

 

[bmsarvis]

This is a good topic imo. I was surprised to see it split when I voted for hill. Crowell is a talented back as is hill. But imo their situations are pretty much the same. Crowell has west and tate to compete with and both are talented. Gio is a better rb then both of them for sure but they won't be riding the bench for Crowell unless it's due to injury . Also , as a Josh gordon owner I'm definitely good put some stock in the knucklehead factor especially because him gordon will probably be hangin around each other lol. In short that's why my vote went for hill

 

[Sabertooth]

Didn't even think about the Gordon factor.

 

[Sabertooth]

I voted Hill as well. I find it very interesting how much a player can fluctuate even in a dynasty league after only a couple weeks. Careers are long.

 

[shoecrew22]

You're very misleading on what type of answer you want but I'll do my best...

Poll asks who you like best as a prospect.

I think this is easily Crowell. While I think Hill is an exceptional back and will succeed in the NFL and be a great FF back if Gio goes down, starts playing bad, or if Hill or Gio get traded ever. However in the current setup Hill and Gio make a sick 2 headed beast...probably the best in the NFL.. (I live in cincy and listen to sports radio 12 hours a day...but am Broncos fan so im not bias..)

Today Hill is clearly the better FF Back and a decent Flex starter as you can expect a handful of touches and the Goalline punch you in the mouth TD. Gio has the finesse and speed, Hill has the power and speed. Gio is the better back right now and will continue to dominate the backfield but Hill is capable of handling 3down role if presented with opportunity.

Crowell has the oppertunity, Tate is injury prone, wont play the rest of the season as the starter. West has been outproduced by Crowell by 2+ YPC and once Tate gets injured again I fully expect Crowell to be the starting back. We were already seeing almost a 50/50 split in week 3 (This is from memory not 100% on numbers here).. Crowell is just as if not more talented than Hill...if it werent for getting booted from UGA he would of been a top draft pick and starting for a team right now - or at least splitting carries instead of being viewed as a pure backup.





SO - Right now...Hill
Tomorrrow...Crowell

 

[Tool]

This is a good topic imo. I was surprised to see it split when I voted for hill. Crowell is a talented back as is hill. But imo their situations are pretty much the same. Crowell has west and tate to compete with and both are talented. Gio is a better rb then both of them for sure but they won't be riding the bench for Crowell unless it's due to injury . Also , as a Josh gordon owner I'm definitely good put some stock in the knucklehead factor especially because him gordon will probably be hangin around each other lol. In short that's why my vote went for hill

i don't see their situations the same at all.

Crowell could be the #1 guy next year. Barring injury that will never happen with Hill. On the other hand, Hill is guaranteed to get a good share of the carries this year and going forward. Crowell is not. I like both guys. I think who you value higher could depend on the rest of your roster and whether you have room to stash someone like Crowell to see how it plays out.

 

[bmsarvis]

Very good points fellas. But yea I do like hill as a better prospect and in fact was my number 1 rb in the rookie draft last year. Situation doesn't really effect my rankings tho. In fairness I could see a day where hill is the lead back in cinci too as was mentioned with crowell. I'm not sayin that will happen just that I could see it happen.

 

[bmsarvis]

Also , I need to watch west and Crowell a little closer to see the pass protection and hands side of there game a little bit better. But I don't see west taking a back seat to crowell anytime soon same with gio n hill although I'm more familiar with there games

 

[LarryAllen'sJockstrap]

God this game is passing me by. I didn't know who the "Crow" is. Almost as bad as not realizing Baby Hawk" is obviously Andrew Hawkins.

 

[Sabertooth]

Isaiah Crowell

Vote is 30/30 right now