Dynasty WR #17 (1 Viewer)

[jeter23]

For ranking purposes, I am assuming PPR.

If you vote other, please let me know who you would like added for the next poll.

1. Larry Fitzgerald 8/31/83 65% (Cal. Johnson, 23%)

2. Calvin Johnson 9/25/85 60% (A. Johnson, 30%)

3. Andre Johnson 7/11/81 73% (Marshall, 12%)

4. Brandon Marshall 3/23/84 33% (Smith, 13%)

5. Greg Jennings 9/21/83 61% runoff (Smith, 39%)

6. Steve Smith 5/12/79 25% (Colston, 17%)

7. Marques Colston 6/5/83 24% (White, 21%)

8. Roddy White 11/2/81 55% runoff (Wayne, 45%)

9. Randy Moss 2/13/77 30% (Wayne, 29%)

10. Reggie Wayne 11/17/78 45% (Boldin, 28%)

11. Anquan Boldin 10/3/80 52% (Bowe, 23%)

12. Dwayne Bowe 9/21/84 48% (Edwards, 22%)

13. Braylon Edwards 2/21/83 39% (Welker, 20%)

14. Wes Welker 5/1/81 30% (Royal, 28%)

15. Eddie Royal 5/21/86 40% (Holmes, 21%)

16. Santonio Holmes 3/3/84 28% (Crabtree, 28%)

 

[KellysHeroes]

I would be reaching for Anthony Gonzalez 9/18/84 all the way

 

[Yitbos69]

I would be reaching for Anthony Gonzalez 9/18/84 all the way

So you would trade Rookie pick 1.01 for Gonzalez?

 

[Burning Sensation]

I would be reaching for Anthony Gonzalez 9/18/84 all the way

So you would trade Rookie pick 1.01 for Gonzalez?

 

[Biabreakable]

I would be reaching for Anthony Gonzalez 9/18/84 all the way

So you would trade Rookie pick 1.01 for Gonzalez?

I think it is an interesting question.I think the 1.01 rookie pick is worth more than WR17 who is a WR2. Yet many people will take Crabtree 1st overall. So if you value Gonzalez more than Crabtree wouldn't you trade the pick for AG if Crabtree was going to be your pick?

 

[Burning Sensation]

I would be reaching for Anthony Gonzalez 9/18/84 all the way

So you would trade Rookie pick 1.01 for Gonzalez?

I think it is an interesting question.I think the 1.01 rookie pick is worth more than WR17 who is a WR2. Yet many people will take Crabtree 1st overall. So if you value Gonzalez more than Crabtree wouldn't you trade the pick for AG if Crabtree was going to be your pick?

By picking Gonzalez over Crabtree doesnt mean someone would prefer Gonzalez over the 1.1.For the record, i voted for Crabtree.

 

[Biabreakable]

I would be reaching for Anthony Gonzalez 9/18/84 all the way

So you would trade Rookie pick 1.01 for Gonzalez?

I think it is an interesting question.I think the 1.01 rookie pick is worth more than WR17 who is a WR2. Yet many people will take Crabtree 1st overall. So if you value Gonzalez more than Crabtree wouldn't you trade the pick for AG if Crabtree was going to be your pick?

By picking Gonzalez over Crabtree doesnt mean someone would prefer Gonzalez over the 1.1.For the record, i voted for Crabtree.

Oh I agree. Some one may be looking at a RB 1st overall that they value more than any WR#17It is just that if the person has Crabtree #1 then they should be voting for Crabtree at this point.

 

[Ariakis]

Went with Roy E. He will be coming very undervalued in dynasty leagues this offseason I think. Gonz makes sense here too or Chad but I think Crabtree is very overrated and is only living off of the Calvin Johnson hype.

 

[loose circuits]

went with Bryant here, but it was a tough one between him and Crabtree. Bryant made some amazing catches last year and I think he'll continue to build on that...

 

[LBH]

went with Bryant

 

[KellysHeroes]

I would be reaching for Anthony Gonzalez 9/18/84 all the way

So you would trade Rookie pick 1.01 for Gonzalez?

if I had 1.01, I wouldn't be picking Crab

 

[FUBAR]

put a fork in this one.

 

[billyjoe]

Little confused on Roy Williams.

TO is gone within 12 months at most, maybe less. Romo/Witten/Roy going forward. Seems pretty much a lock for 80/1000/8 for the next 5 years. With lots of upside. At this point, I look for WRs locked in with top QBs, young, talented, and Roy seems like the choice to me.

I mean TO? Ehhh. Housh? Ehhh. Crabtree maybe.

 

[Ron_Mexico]

Little confused on Roy Williams. TO is gone within 12 months at most, maybe less. Romo/Witten/Roy going forward. Seems pretty much a lock for 80/1000/8 for the next 5 years. With lots of upside. At this point, I look for WRs locked in with top QBs, young, talented, and Roy seems like the choice to me. I mean TO? Ehhh. Housh? Ehhh. Crabtree maybe.

ROY has been a disapointment to many owners,I think frustration is starting to set in with many regarding his FF value.

 

[gianmarco]

Little confused on Roy Williams. TO is gone within 12 months at most, maybe less. Romo/Witten/Roy going forward. Seems pretty much a lock for 80/1000/8 for the next 5 years. With lots of upside. At this point, I look for WRs locked in with top QBs, young, talented, and Roy seems like the choice to me. I mean TO? Ehhh. Housh? Ehhh. Crabtree maybe.

I could have sworn I read something similar to this back in 2004. Or wait, was it 2005? Maybe 2006? Nah, had to be 2007. No, no, scratch that, it was 2008.And now, in 2009, yet again......The only thing Roy Williams is a "lock" for is to be drafted too high (again).

 

[billyjoe]

Little confused on Roy Williams. TO is gone within 12 months at most, maybe less. Romo/Witten/Roy going forward. Seems pretty much a lock for 80/1000/8 for the next 5 years. With lots of upside. At this point, I look for WRs locked in with top QBs, young, talented, and Roy seems like the choice to me. I mean TO? Ehhh. Housh? Ehhh. Crabtree maybe.

I could have sworn I read something similar to this back in 2004. Or wait, was it 2005? Maybe 2006? Nah, had to be 2007. No, no, scratch that, it was 2008.And now, in 2009, yet again......The only thing Roy Williams is a "lock" for is to be drafted too high (again).

People said the same thing about Antonio Bryant. Past results are not a great indicator of future results. He's at least had a top 10 year, and he played for the Lions. I believe with Dallas there’s enough talent/system for him to be productive. And most dynasty leagues aren't drafting Roy Williams, so you don't have to worry about people reaching. Over the next 5 years I don't see why he's at the top of this list production wise. He'll kill Housh/CJ/TO, thats a given.

 

[gianmarco]

Little confused on Roy Williams. TO is gone within 12 months at most, maybe less. Romo/Witten/Roy going forward. Seems pretty much a lock for 80/1000/8 for the next 5 years. With lots of upside. At this point, I look for WRs locked in with top QBs, young, talented, and Roy seems like the choice to me. I mean TO? Ehhh. Housh? Ehhh. Crabtree maybe.

I could have sworn I read something similar to this back in 2004. Or wait, was it 2005? Maybe 2006? Nah, had to be 2007. No, no, scratch that, it was 2008.And now, in 2009, yet again......The only thing Roy Williams is a "lock" for is to be drafted too high (again).

People said the same thing about Antonio Bryant. Past results are not a great indicator of future results. He's at least had a top 10 year, and he played for the Lions. I believe with Dallas there’s enough talent/system for him to be productive. And most dynasty leagues aren't drafting Roy Williams, so you don't have to worry about people reaching. Over the next 5 years I don't see why he's at the top of this list production wise. He'll kill Housh/CJ/TO, thats a given.

Right, people said the same thing about A. Bryant. But at least there weren't people that were still clamoring to put him in the top 20 WR rankings like you're trying to do with Roy. If Roy falls in rankings to where AB was prior to last year, THEN he becomes a value. You, on the other hand, are wanting to rank him 17th overall. This is why he somehow remains one of the most overrated players in all of fantasy football. Every year there's some group of people ranking him way too high saying "ok, ok, now THIS is the year". Roy killing Housh/CJ/TO is FAR from a given. But knock yourself out.

 

[FUBAR]

Little confused on Roy Williams. TO is gone within 12 months at most, maybe less. Romo/Witten/Roy going forward. Seems pretty much a lock for 80/1000/8 for the next 5 years. With lots of upside. At this point, I look for WRs locked in with top QBs, young, talented, and Roy seems like the choice to me. I mean TO? Ehhh. Housh? Ehhh. Crabtree maybe.

I could have sworn I read something similar to this back in 2004. Or wait, was it 2005? Maybe 2006? Nah, had to be 2007. No, no, scratch that, it was 2008.And now, in 2009, yet again......The only thing Roy Williams is a "lock" for is to be drafted too high (again).

People said the same thing about Antonio Bryant. Past results are not a great indicator of future results. He's at least had a top 10 year, and he played for the Lions. I believe with Dallas there’s enough talent/system for him to be productive. And most dynasty leagues aren't drafting Roy Williams, so you don't have to worry about people reaching. Over the next 5 years I don't see why he's at the top of this list production wise. He'll kill Housh/CJ/TO, thats a given.

Right, people said the same thing about A. Bryant. But at least there weren't people that were still clamoring to put him in the top 20 WR rankings like you're trying to do with Roy. If Roy falls in rankings to where AB was prior to last year, THEN he becomes a value. You, on the other hand, are wanting to rank him 17th overall. This is why he somehow remains one of the most overrated players in all of fantasy football. Every year there's some group of people ranking him way too high saying "ok, ok, now THIS is the year". Roy killing Housh/CJ/TO is FAR from a given. But knock yourself out.

Yup. Right now the only person on this list I have below Roy is Cotchery - and a good chunk of that is simply QB concerns.