I am a bit shocked to see all the Eli bashing here. Is it because of the San Diego mess or what? He played college ball on a undersized, slow, bad college team in one of the best conferences in the nation (even though i hate almost every single team in the SEC and partially loathe the rest barring LSU). He has superior physical skill than his brother. Locals here were saying that before Peyton was out of high school. I would give the mental edge to Peyton at this point, but I think Eli is a touch smarter than his brother. Eli is stepping into a nightmare of a team, but they do have really good talent. I think the Giants will be around the .500 mark at the end of the season. The giants have a good organization, and will surround Eli with the tools necessary to succede, eventually.IMO, Eli will be a very good QB for years to come. Will he be a hall of famer? I think he stands a good chance, but only time will tell of course. If I could pick him up in a keeper league, I think I would do everything in my power to do just that. (IE selling the farm).