Eli Manning v. Carson Palmer (1 Viewer)

[bocksheesh]

Can't really figure these two out. Eli has put up more numbers, but Palmer seems to rounding into form. Whereas Eli often looks fairly ugly playing his game, but he still manages to get his numbers.

Carson's schedule seems a bit stiff with Baltimore twice as well as San Diego and New Orleans. While the Giants' schedule looks soft by comparison.

My gut tells me it's Palmer. My brain tells me it's Manning.

Which is right?

 

[bocksheesh]

bumpski

 

[duckie1888]

bumpski

I am in the same boat

 

[bocksheesh]

Dangit. That's not helpful!

Yeah, it's a tough call. It seems like the obvious choice is Eli Manning. But my gut really tells me Carson is better the rest of the way - even with his stiffer schedule.

The Giants Defense is playing too well. And they're running the ball too well. Just have a feeling that Eli doens't light it up.

Could be wrong though. Hoping someone can convince of such.

 

[bocksheesh]

bump?

 

[nortobc]

bump?

Let me help you out their chief."BUMP"

 

[bocksheesh]

bump?

Let me help you out their chief."BUMP"

I had decided to throw my lot in with Carson Palmer. But as of this morning, I'm back to looking at Eli.FBG's matchups got me nervous.