Enough for Gurley? Awaits tomatoes being thrown (1 Viewer)

[JMoz]

14 team .5 ppr, 2 RB, 2Wr start, 1 flex

I have been offered 

1.05 (Chubb/Michel) 2.05 (Mayfield/LJackson), 2019 1st (mid-late), Allen Robinson, and Alex Collins. Those are just ideas for who I'd maybe draft with those picks

for my

Gurley and 2020 2nd. 

I have very little by means of draft picks in next couple years- I own 1.09, 1.13, 3.01 this season. My next first rounder is in 2022... 

Is this enough value back for the top RB? I know everyone's answer is mostly don't trade Gurley!! But it's a top 12 WR, a rb I really like in Collins, and a few decent picks. 

RB- Gurley, Crowell, Marshawn, Perine (TS)
WR- Keenan Allen, Marvin Jones, Funchess, Fitzgerald, Robby Anderson, Marquise Goodwin, Tyrell Williams
TE- Rudolph, Eifert
DEF- Jags, Vikings, Chargers

 

[beerbuff]

tomatoes and vinegar make ketchup and that is what you would have with this trade. Your WR's are good but after Gurley you have nothing at RB. I just don't see Collins and a rookie RB helping you out enough to make the trade worthwhile. If they could throw in another RB instead of the 2.05 pick I would revisit.

 

[fruity pebbles]

Not enough

 

[snoochieboochies]

You lose your edge at RB with this trade. replace the 2.05 and/or collins with a RB that has less competition or more of a set role than collins does. 

 

[Gally]

Not nearly enough for me.  Lots of questions with everything you would be getting back.  Could it turn out to be a trade in your favor?  Sure, but A-Rob would have to be back to his one year wonder form, Collins be the guy in Baltimore, and your two picks would have to both hit and be productive.  The likelihood of all that happening is very small. 

 

[ProfPoobah]

It's not a top 12 WR, but even if it were, I don't like the deal.  Not trying to GM your team, but you think a win-now team would give you something for Larry Fitz or Lynch?