Interesting how everyone is saying the Cards went too conservative. Here,
TMQ argues that the Cardinals didn't go conservative enough.
Yet it's not enough to say that mere Cardinal-ness cost Arizona this game. Blowing a late 20-point lead is not easy: Dennis Green and his coaching staff worked hard to blow it. Consider the situation at the start of the fourth quarter. Arizona led 23-10 and had a first-and-10 on its 23. At this point, the clock -- not the Bears -- is the opponent; just keep those numerals on the scoreboard declining and victory is likely. Yet after the first play of the fourth quarter, Arizona called timeout. On the possession, Matt Leinart threw incomplete twice, stopping the clock twice more. On its next possession, still leading 23-10 and now with 10:53 remaining, Arizona went run, incompletion, incompletion, stopping the clock two more times before punting. TMQ's Immutable Law of Doing the Obvious holds: Sometimes all a team needs to do is run the ball up the middle for no gain, and everything will be fine. Had Arizona not called a timeout in a clock-killer situation, and had the team simply run up the middle for no gain on these four plays Leinart threw incomplete, probably there never would have been a winning 83-yard Chicago punt return with 2:58 to play. The clock would have expired and the contest would have ended with Arizona leading.
That's a very interesting read Chase but I think kevjones22 makes a good point and he might have got the ax for the teams offensive play calling in the first half rather than the second;GROSSMAN 1st INT
1-10-CHI25 (2:26) E.James left tackle to CHI 23 for 2 yards (L.Briggs, A.Boone).
2-8-CHI23 (1:45) E.James left tackle to CHI 26 for -3 yards (M.Brown, L.Briggs).
3-11-CHI26 (1:02) (Shotgun) M.Leinart pass short middle to A.Boldin for 26 yards, TOUCHDOWN.
N.Rackers extra point is GOOD, Center-N.Hodel, Holder-S.Player.
CHI 0 ARI 14, Plays: 3 Yards: 25 Possession: 1:32.
Conservative, but Leinart is able to convert on his one attempt 3rd and long. Get out of this kids way.
GROSSMAN 2nd INT
1-10-CHI29 (13:00) PENALTY on ARZ-C.Liwienski, False Start, 5 yards, enforced at CHI 29 - No Play.
1-15-CHI34 (12:59) E.James up the middle to CHI 32 for 2 yards (T.Harris, B.Urlacher).
2-13-CHI32 (12:15) (Shotgun)
PENALTY on ARZ-R.Wells, False Start, 5 yards, enforced at CHI 32 - No Play.
2-18-CHI37 (12:05) E.James left tackle to CHI 34 for 3 yards (A.Brown).
3-15-CHI34 (11:27) (Shotgun) M.Leinart pass incomplete deep left to A.Boldin.
4-15-CHI34 (11:21) N.Rackers 52 yard field goal is No Good, Wide Left, Center-N.Hodel, Holder-S.Player.
Conservative and too many penalties. You get the ball on the 29 with all the momentum in the world... and you end up going BACKWARDS 5 yards forcing a 52yrd FG by Rackers???? The only pass was on 3rd and 15 despite the fact Leinart had a hot hand, CHI secondary reeling and James only contributions of the night was pass blocking. Just awful playcalling combined with even poore execution.
GROSSMAN 1st FUM LOST
1-10-CHI33 (8:05) E.James right end to CHI 30 for 3 yards (H.Hillenmeyer, B.Urlacher).
2-7-CHI30 (7:24) E.James right end to CHI 30 for no gain (L.Briggs).
3-7-CHI30 (6:45) (Shotgun) M.Leinart pass short left to J.Arrington to CHI 18 for 12 yards (B.Urlacher, M.Brown).
1-10-CHI18 (6:04) E.James left tackle to CHI 14 for 4 yards (L.Briggs).
2-6-CHI14 (5:29) E.James up the middle to CHI 13 for 1 yard (L.Briggs, C.Tillman).
3-5-CHI13 (4:50) E.James left end to CHI 11 for 2 yards (L.Briggs, M.Brown).
PENALTY on ARZ-A.Boldin, Offensive Holding, 10 yards, enforced at CHI 13 - No Play.
3-15-CHI23 (4:25) (Shotgun) M.Leinart pass incomplete short middle to C.Holiday.
4-15-CHI23 (4:25) N.Rackers 41 yard field goal is GOOD, Center-N.Hodel, Holder-S.Player.
CHI 0 ARI 17, Plays: 7 Yards: 10 Possession: 3:50.
Again, Leinart comes through when the down/distance is managable but the playcalling and execution is so putrid they get a gift on the CHI 33 and can only muster 10 yards despite the fact they actually made a first down(thanks to Leinart).
GROSSMAN 2nd FUM LOST
1-10-CHI32 (2:10) M.Leinart pass short right to A.Boldin to CHI 13 for 19 yards (C.Tillman).
1-10-CHI13 (2:00) E.James up the middle to CHI 13 for no gain (I.Idonije, L.Briggs).
2-10-CHI13 (1:19) E.James up the middle to CHI 13 for no gain (L.Briggs, C.Tillman).
3-10-CHI13

46) (Shotgun) M.Leinart pass short middle to O.Ayanbadejo to CHI 10 for 3 yards (L.Briggs).
4-7-CHI10

02) N.Rackers 28 yard field goal is GOOD, Center-N.Hodel, Holder-S.Player.
CHI 0 ARI 20, Plays: 5 Yards: 22 Possession: 2:10.
Surprise, surprise they don't wait for 3rd and long before allowing Leinart to pass and right off the bat he connects for 19 yards and gets ARZ down to the 13.... then go back to the turtle.
So all in all that was 13 points and some would say at least they scored one touchdown against a very good defense. But I think they are missing the point. Leinart was firing on all cylinders and James was getting stuffed repeatedly. ARZ isn't being conservative back around their own 30 yard line, afraid to make a mistake and give CHI easy opportunities. ARZ was taking over at the CHI 25, 29, 33 and 32 yard lines. That's FG range right there, that's the time to take your shots. Especially with all the momentum in that building at the time. IMO you have to come away from that situation with a minimum of 16 points(1 TD/3 FG) but if they would have let Leinart loose there's a good chance they could have gotten 20 points. Even if they only get 16 points in that situation we're all applauding ARZ for a great victory. That's what Barkley was eluding too, if your opponent is giving you back-to-back-to-back-to-back opportunities near the redzone you can't settle for FG's. 1st and 10 on your opponents 25, 29, 33 and 32 should result in more than 13 points.
I dunno how much was Denny's playcalling and how much was the OC but from the bit you quoted it appears the play calling in the second half were quite a bid different than the play calling in the first half. The difference was the starting field position by ARZ in the second half. When/If Leinart had incompletions they couldn't just kick FG's like they could have in the first half, they had to punt.