Felix or Bradshaw (1 Viewer)

[3MTA3]

Both are backups but with Bradshaw's fumble last week, do we see his time diminish? Felix has performed decent when he is healthy but is in a 3-back situation.

Tough call here.

 

[towney]

I actually see Jacobs with his strong showing last week to gain more carries. He was busting up the middle with a purpose.

Healthy Felix is gold if Barber struggles with quad issue. HTH

Felix>Bradshaw if it were me.

 

[az_prof]

Felix is in a time share with three guys. Bradshaw with one. Other than last week, Bradshaw has been the better back all year. I would bet on Bradshaw and wouldn't trade him straight up for Felix. Who knows who well Felix will come back from his injury?

 

[Chaka]

Felix is in a time share with three guys. Bradshaw with one. Other than last week, Bradshaw has been the better back all year. I would bet on Bradshaw and wouldn't trade him straight up for Felix. Who knows who well Felix will come back from his injury?

"Felix is in a time share with two guys and Bradshaw with one." or "Felix is in a timeshare with three guys and Bradshaw with two."(sorry for some reason the wording in your first sentence bothered me).

 

[Grahamburn]

Felix is in a time share with three guys. Bradshaw with one. Other than last week, Bradshaw has been the better back all year. I would bet on Bradshaw and wouldn't trade him straight up for Felix. Who knows who well Felix will come back from his injury?

From footballguys.com game recap:Week 7 vs ATL - If Jones' knee is slowing him down, you couldn't tell on Sunday. He once again made someone miss completely in the open field, and makes it look way too easy, and Jones was generally slippery in one on one confrontations. Jones got a few snaps in a row in the first half and showed his electric initial burst on a few runs. He didn't get a chance to do anything on his receptions because they were low, but one of them came in the red zone. He'll be back to his big play ways any day now. I've also seen a couple posters mention that "Felix is in a time share with three guys," but it doesn't seem like Tashard Choice is getting many touches if Barber and Felix are in the lineup.Tashard Choice touches with all three backs healthy:4 against TB3 against NYG1 against ATLFelix should be a strong FLEX play if he averages 10-12 touches a game.

 

[todisco1]

[Felix should be a strong FLEX play if he averages 10-12 touches a game.

They both look like strong flex plays to me. If I had to choose I'd go with Bradshaw, though IMO they have similar value.

 

[jobarules]

Have a funny feeling Felix is gonna have a good game vs SEA

 

[joffer]

Felix is in a time share with three guys. Bradshaw with one. Other than last week, Bradshaw has been the better back all year. I would bet on Bradshaw and wouldn't trade him straight up for Felix. Who knows who well Felix will come back from his injury?

agree with this. i feel much more comfortable starting Bradshaw right now than I do starting Felix.

 

[FGITLOTR]

funny because I have to pick between Felix and Bradshaw this weekend--I'm leaning towards Felix because I see him making the most of his 10-12 touches..I fully expect a long TD on a screen or run play..He was close to breaking two runs this past weekend!

 

[switz]

Felix is in a time share with three guys. Bradshaw with one. Other than last week, Bradshaw has been the better back all year. I would bet on Bradshaw and wouldn't trade him straight up for Felix. Who knows who well Felix will come back from his injury?

First, Felix really isn't in a time share with three guys, as Choice barely plays when Felix and Barber are both healthy.Second, Felix apparently is already 100% back from his injury, he's not listed on the injury report, and looked like the best Dallas RB on the field last week.That all being said, if I owned Bradshaw, I wouldn't trade him straight up for Felix.I think both have potential to be very good RBs, Felix I think could be something special, but has had injury problems.

 

[Da Guru]

Fe-Jo is a great talent..the guy just can`t stay on the field.

 

[KellysHeroes]

Look at it this way

Bradshaw plays injuried, and plays well.

If BJ got hurt, Bradshaw would most likely get 70% of the touches, if MB3 gets hurt Jones would still have a 50/50 split w/ Choice IMO.

Jones is explosive and all that but I watched a lot of the G-Men since I live in the area and Bradshaw makes just as many open field moves as Jones. The difference is one was a high draft pick from a great Football school and has the love of the owner behind him and the other one stole a playstation and got dumped to the 7th round.

I'd take Bradshaw anyday

 

[towney]

Again, Felix by a mile

Ahmad Bradshaw missed practice Wednesday to visit renowned orthopedic specialist Dr. Robert Anderson about his foot/ankle injury.

The Giants have given no indication that they're worried about Bradshaw's injury, but this is a situation to monitor. Being cleared by Anderson to practice Thursday would be a positive sign. Bradshaw indicated after the club's Week 7 loss that he may have re-tweaked the injury on his lost fumble.

Source: Giants.com/Rotoworld

 

[Routilla]

Again, Felix by a mile

Ahmad Bradshaw missed practice Wednesday to visit renowned orthopedic specialist Dr. Robert Anderson about his foot/ankle injury.

The Giants have given no indication that they're worried about Bradshaw's injury, but this is a situation to monitor. Being cleared by Anderson to practice Thursday would be a positive sign. Bradshaw indicated after the club's Week 7 loss that he may have re-tweaked the injury on his lost fumble.

Source: Giants.com/Rotoworld

Who is behind Bradshaw at RB for the NYG?