For Dynasty (1 Viewer)

[new-guru]

Rankings going forward into NEXT YEAR - DYNASTY

1 QB Aaron Rodgers, GB

2 QB Robert Griffin III, WAS

3 QB Andrew Luck, IND

tier 2

4 QB Drew Brees, NO

5 QB Tom Brady, NE

6 QB Cam Newton, CAR

7 QB Matthew Stafford, DET

8 QB Matt Ryan, ATL

9 QB Peyton Manning, DEN

tier 3

10 QB Eli Manning, NYG

11 QB Russell Wilson, SEA

12 QB Andy Dalton, CIN

13 QB Josh Freeman, TB

13 QB Colin Kaepernick, SF

15 QB Tony Romo, DAL

16 QB Ben Roethlisberger, PIT

tier 4

17 QB Jay Cutler, CHI

18 QB Philip Rivers, SD

19 QB Matt Schaub, HOU

20 QB Joe Flacco, BAL

21 QB Sam Bradford, STL

22 QB Ryan Tannehill, MIA

23 QB Jake Locker, TEN

24 QB Christian Ponder, MIN

25 QB Carson Palmer, OAK

1 RB Trent Richardson, CLE

1 RB Adrian Peterson, MIN

3 RB Arian Foster, HOU

4 RB Doug Martin, TB

5 RB Ray Rice, BAL

tier 2

6 RB David Wilson, NYG

7 RB Jamaal Charles, KC

8 RB Matt Forte, CHI

9 RB C.J. Spiller, BUF

10 RB Chris Johnson, TEN

11 RB LeSean McCoy, PHI

12 RB Marshawn Lynch, SEA

13 RB DeMarco Murray, DAL

14 RB Maurice Jones-Drew, JAX

15 RB Ryan Mathews, SD

16 RB Darren McFadden, OAK

tier 3

17 RB Stevan Ridley, NE

18 RB Alfred Morris, WAS

19 RB Frank Gore, SF

20 RB Mikel Leshoure, DET

21 RB Darren Sproles, NO

21 RB Steven Jackson, STL

23 RB Knowsawn Moreno, DEN

24 RB Ben Tate, HOU

25 RB Rashard Mendenhall, PIT

26 RB Fred Jackson, BUF

27 RB Reggie Bush, MIA

28 RB Jonathan Stewart, CAR

29 RB Ahmad Bradshaw, NYG

30 RB BenJarvus Green-Ellis, CIN

WR Calvin Johnson, DET

tier 2

WR A.J. Green, CIN

WR Brandon Marshall, CHI

WR Demaryius Thomas, DEN

WR Julio Jones, ATL

WR Dez Bryant, DAL

WR Hakeem Nicks, NYG

WR Percy Harvin, MIN

WR Victor Cruz, NYG

tier3

WR Larry Fitzgerald, ARI

WR Roddy White, ATL

WR Andre Johnson, HOU

WR Randall Cobb, GB

WR Vincent Jackson, TB

WR Wes Welker, NE

WR Mike Wallace, PIT

WR Jordy Nelson, GB

WR Greg Jennings, GB

WR Justin Blackmon, JAX

WR Pierre Garcon, WAS

WR Antonio Brown, PIT

WR Reggie Wayne, IND

tier 4

WR Steve Johnson, BUF

WR Marques Colston, NO

WR Eric Decker, DEN

WR Dwayne Bowe, KC

WR Torrey Smith, BAL

WR Steve Smith, CAR

WR Denarius Moore, OAK

WR Sidney Rice, SEA

WR DeSean Jackson, PHI

WR Brandon Lloyd, NE

WR Michael Crabtree, SF

WR Miles Austin, DAL

WR Kendall Wright, TEN

WR Kenny Britt, TEN

WR Michael Floyd, ARI

TE Jimmy Graham, NO

TE Rob Gronkowski, NE

tier 2

TE Owen Daniels, HOU

TE Jason Witten, DAL

TE Jermaine Gresham, CIN

TE Kyle Rudolph, MIN

TE Aaron Hernandez, NE

tier 3

TE Vernon Davis, SF

TE Brandon Pettigrew, DET

TE Antonio Gates, SD

TE Martellus Bennett, NYG

TE Tony Moeaki, KC

TE Jermichael Finley, GB

TE Greg Olsen, CAR

TE Heath Miller, PIT

TE Dennis Pitta, BAL

tier 4

TE Brent Celek, PHI

TE Dwayne Allen, IND

TE Coby Fleener, IND

TE Jared Cook, TEN

TE Scott Chandler, BUF

TE Tony Gonzalez, ATL

TE Jacob Tamme, DEN

TE Fred Davis, WAS

TE Marcedes Lewis, JAX

Anyone Else

I'm sure there is others who would enjoy looking at anyone else's Dynasty Lists

If we had several lists or critique this list, might help owners make decisions on making trades, establishing values, or evaluating ones team.

 

[voiceofunreason]

QBs looks decent. Put Wilson way down around Schaub and put Rivers up a bit.

David Wilson...whoa man, I'll have what you're having.

 

[I was in the pool]

Bravo, as you are the first person that i have seen to have David Wilson in the top-10.

 

[jeter23]

David Wilson, Owen Daniels and Tony Moeaki stand out to me. What do you like about each to rank them that high?

 

[lbouchard]

David Wilson way too high. AJ Green is same tier as Calvin. Don't have any idea why AHern is down that low in tier 2. Russell Wilson good call. Torrey Smith should be in tier 3 IMO. Mike Wallace is going to leave PIT so I'm not sure about that.

 

[mquinnjr]

This kind of stuff makes this forum great. And I agree with pretty much the entire list. I do have to say, I get where you're coming from for WR. But, I think there's room for AJ Green up with Megatron. I think talent and situation wise he can be that good. I'm not saying better than Megatron, but I think it's Megatron & Green #2, then Tier 2.

 

[Donnybrook]

Not sure why a 23 year old Torry Smith is ranked so low.

 

[new-guru]

David Wilson, Owen Daniels and Tony Moeaki stand out to me. What do you like about each to rank them that high?

David WilsonAbsolutely love his situation, o - line, his talent, if he can control the ball and pass protect he'll be amazingO Daniels and Moeaki both seem to me if they could just stay healthy then great would follow

 

[EBF]

1 RB Trent Richardson, CLE

1 RB Adrian Peterson, MIN

3 RB Arian Foster, HOU

4 RB Doug Martin, TB

5 RB Ray Rice, BAL

tier 2

6 RB David Wilson, NYG

I wouldn't put Peterson quite so high. I think people are letting his track record and his current production influence their evaluation of his dynasty outlook too much. He's getting old for a RB and he has a ton of mileage. If you use a top 10 pick on him, I think you'll regret it after about a year. I think it's fine to take him this high in a redraft league. But in dynasty I would pass at his current price. The David Wilson call is bold. If he lives up to his potential then maybe he can justify this kind of ranking eventually. I think he's a good buy low target, but I definitely wouldn't put him in the top 10 right now. He hasn't done much to earn that and is still just an upside guy.

19 RB Frank Gore, SF

20 RB Mikel Leshoure, DET

21 RB Darren Sproles, NO

21 RB Steven Jackson, STL

23 RB Knowsawn Moreno, DEN

24 RB Ben Tate, HOU

25 RB Rashard Mendenhall, PIT

I'd take Mendy over that whole lot. I think he's much more likely to give you 2-3 more seasons as a productive starter. Now is a good buy low window for him.

WR Calvin Johnson, DET

tier 2

WR A.J. Green, CIN

WR Brandon Marshall, CHI

WR Demaryius Thomas, DEN

WR Julio Jones, ATL

WR Dez Bryant, DAL

Marshall is one of the best of his generation, but with guys like Thomas and Bryant starting to put up similar stats, I'd be inclined to take them instead since they potentially have so much more left in the tank. As for the TE ranks, they looked okay on first glance. The only thing that stuck out to me was Moeaki being so high. He really hasn't done much and I'd rather take a chance on a guy like Fleener or Allen.

 

[new-guru]

Not sure why a 23 year old Torry Smith is ranked so low.

Primarily because of Qb

 

[new-guru]

You are right about A.J. I should have him with Calvin

 

[SSOG]

Not sure why a 23 year old Torry Smith is ranked so low.

Primarily because of Qb

Flacco's game is one-dimensional, but that one dimension happens to be Torrey's strength. For all his faults, Flacco is one of the top 5 deep ball passers in the league.

 

[Skeletore Eh]

Not sure why a 23 year old Torry Smith is ranked so low.

Primarily because of Qb

That doesn't seem to have affected fitz or blackmons ranking, and I'd say their qb situations are worseIf you like Wilson that is one thing, but I think it's crazy to rank him ahead of spiller and Mccoy for sure. Lynch, charles and a few others as well. Marshall way too high. As ebf said the guys ranked below him are putting up similar numbers and have at minimum 4 extra years of production. He's also always a candidate to end up in jail, the hospital, or some other thing you'd normally only see in the movies.I also have a hard time believing you would take Andre Johnson over Cobb given their age differential (9 years).

 

[fruity pebbles]

taking a 30 year old owen daniels at 3 is pretty bold.

 

[new-guru]

Not sure why a 23 year old Torry Smith is ranked so low.

Primarily because of Qb

Flacco's game is one-dimensional, but that one dimension happens to be Torrey's strength. For all his faults, Flacco is one of the top 5 deep ball passers in the league.

I'd be very very interested in what your top 25's look like. I have aLways enjoyed your posts in the Dynasty Rankings Blog

 

[SSOG]

Not sure why a 23 year old Torry Smith is ranked so low.

Primarily because of Qb

Flacco's game is one-dimensional, but that one dimension happens to be Torrey's strength. For all his faults, Flacco is one of the top 5 deep ball passers in the league.

I'd be very very interested in what your top 25's look like. I have aLways enjoyed your posts in the Dynasty Rankings Blog

Been sprinkling some rankings in that thread as the season progresses. Here are my most recent RB ranks (November 23rd):1. Rice2. Richardson3. Peterson4. McCoy5. Martin6. Charles7. Spiller8. Foster9. Forte10. Mathews11. Lynch12. Morris13. McFadden14. Stewart15. Ridley16. Murray17. Chris Johnson18. Bradshaw19. Wilson20. Leshoure21. Reginald Bush22. Hunter23. Ingram24. Mendenhall25. Hillman26. Ben Tate27. Gore28. Sproles29. Richardson30. Lamar Miller31. SJax32. Law Firm33. FJax34. Ivory35. Dwyer36. Pierre ThomasAnd QBs from October 23rd:1- Rodgers2- Griffin3- Newton4- Brees5- Ryan6- Luck7- Stafford8- Roethlisberger9- Brady10- Eli11- Peyton12- Tannehill13- Romo14- Dalton15- Vick16- Flacco17- Locker18- Freeman19- Ponder20- Wilson21- Schaub22- Rivers23- Cutler24- BradfordProbably roll out WRs in a week or two.

 

[new-guru]

Should Ty Hilton Make the top 30WR?

 

[Skeletore Eh]

Should Ty Hilton Make the top 30WR?

I'd take him over Lloyd and djax easily. A few others as well depending whether I was contending or not.

 

[thriftyrocker]

I would find somewhere to put Maclin and Gordon before going with Hilton. JMO

 

[Warrior]

You put waaaaay too much emphasis on youth. David Wilson doesn't belong anywhere close to the guys in his tier. Richardson, Russell Wilson, Kaepernick, heck...every rookie is way too high.

 

[Craig_MiamiFL]

Bryce Brown not on these lists?

Nice.

 

[DoubleG]

Not sure why a 23 year old Torry Smith is ranked so low.

Primarily because of Qb

Flacco's game is one-dimensional, but that one dimension happens to be Torrey's strength. For all his faults, Flacco is one of the top 5 deep ball passers in the league.

I'd be very very interested in what your top 25's look like. I have aLways enjoyed your posts in the Dynasty Rankings Blog

Been sprinkling some rankings in that thread as the season progresses. Here are my most recent RB ranks (November 23rd):1. Rice2. Richardson3. Peterson4. McCoy5. Martin6. Charles7. Spiller8. Foster9. Forte10. Mathews11. Lynch12. Morris13. McFadden14. Stewart15. Ridley16. Murray17. Chris Johnson18. Bradshaw19. Wilson20. Leshoure21. Reginald Bush22. Hunter23. Ingram24. Mendenhall25. Hillman26. Ben Tate27. Gore28. Sproles29. Richardson30. Lamar Miller31. SJax32. Law Firm33. FJax34. Ivory35. Dwyer36. Pierre ThomasAnd QBs from October 23rd:1- Rodgers2- Griffin3- Newton4- Brees5- Ryan6- Luck7- Stafford8- Roethlisberger9- Brady10- Eli11- Peyton12- Tannehill13- Romo14- Dalton15- Vick16- Flacco17- Locker18- Freeman19- Ponder20- Wilson21- Schaub22- Rivers23- Cutler24- BradfordProbably roll out WRs in a week or two.

Solid stuff - as always. I could nitpick a little - I'd have Mendenhall higher, as I think he might get a change of scenery which I actually think could move him closer to a borderline #1 RB (which he has been even with the horrible line the Steelers have had). I'd also tap R. Wilson a few notches at QB. Definately like him over Ponder - probably closer to 15 (Flacco, Freeman and Locker have failed to impress me). Looking forward to your thoughts on WR.ETA - I know you're a talent>situation guy (I am a disciple as well) - but McCoy's concussion issues and B. Brown's absolute amazing showing in Shady's absence is double cause for pause in terms of McCoy's ranking. Honestly, I'd probably have McCoy just outside the top 10 if for no other reason, then the possibility that this could be a Jahvid Best/Austin Collie situation - with a backup who has been simply eye-popping.

 

[Craig_MiamiFL]

I'd have Mendenhall higher, as I think he might get a change of scenery which I actually think could move him closer to a borderline #1 RB (which he has been even with the horrible line the Steelers have had).

Mendenhall's best place to be in 2013? Probably Pittsburgh with Tomlin where he has the most backing. (Was drafted by him/was given the job back post ACL) Demotion to inactive IMO is Tomlin trying to light a fire under him. Don't think we've heard the last of Mendenhall in Pittsburgh.JMO He may end up having to settle on a 1 year prove it deal. Unless he decides to take a deal something along the lines of Michael Bush. Just don't see a lucrative market for him after after a lost 2012. Really a crappy position for him as a soon to be 26 year old RB in the NFL.The grass isn't always greener. He's gonna have to fight for a starting job somewhere.

 

[asuterlowe]

Unless you anticipate Morris losing his job sometime soon, hes shown us he deserves more respect than where you have him. Your entire TE rankings seem off to me, Witten and Daniels so high, I think we see guys like Bennett, Fred Davis and maybe even Moeaki emerging faster than you think. Otherwise I really like these rankings

 

[ZWK]

Shorts? Keller?

 

[Acrobat7]

good read thank you!

I'm surprised that both of you (new-guru and SSOG) have Freeman so low. they will have a really good line next year, a very good RB and at least two good WRs.

 

[DoubleG]

I'd have Mendenhall higher, as I think he might get a change of scenery which I actually think could move him closer to a borderline #1 RB (which he has been even with the horrible line the Steelers have had).

Mendenhall's best place to be in 2013? Probably Pittsburgh with Tomlin where he has the most backing. (Was drafted by him/was given the job back post ACL) Demotion to inactive IMO is Tomlin trying to light a fire under him. Don't think we've heard the last of Mendenhall in Pittsburgh.JMO He may end up having to settle on a 1 year prove it deal. Unless he decides to take a deal something along the lines of Michael Bush. Just don't see a lucrative market for him after after a lost 2012. Really a crappy position for him as a soon to be 26 year old RB in the NFL.The grass isn't always greener. He's gonna have to fight for a starting job somewhere.

So this is all a ploy to motivate R. Mendenhall? Honestly, the guy is one season removed from a 1200+ yard 13 TD season. I don't think he'd have to much trouble finding a starting gig, given some of the RB situations around the league. Just off the top of my head (and as a Bears fan this scares the piss out of me), there's a team in Wisoncsin that could use a 25 year old RB who averages 1100+, 10 TD and 20+ receptions a year over the last 3 seasons. Arizona as well - or the Jets or possibly even Atlanta.

 

[Craig_MiamiFL]

I'd have Mendenhall higher, as I think he might get a change of scenery which I actually think could move him closer to a borderline #1 RB (which he has been even with the horrible line the Steelers have had).

Mendenhall's best place to be in 2013? Probably Pittsburgh with Tomlin where he has the most backing. (Was drafted by him/was given the job back post ACL) Demotion to inactive IMO is Tomlin trying to light a fire under him. Don't think we've heard the last of Mendenhall in Pittsburgh.JMO He may end up having to settle on a 1 year prove it deal. Unless he decides to take a deal something along the lines of Michael Bush. Just don't see a lucrative market for him after after a lost 2012. Really a crappy position for him as a soon to be 26 year old RB in the NFL.The grass isn't always greener. He's gonna have to fight for a starting job somewhere.

So this is all a ploy to motivate R. Mendenhall? Honestly, the guy is one season removed from a 1200+ yard 13 TD season. I don't think he'd have to much trouble finding a starting gig, given some of the RB situations around the league. Just off the top of my head (and as a Bears fan this scares the piss out of me), there's a team in Wisoncsin that could use a 25 year old RB who averages 1100+, 10 TD and 20+ receptions a year over the last 3 seasons. Arizona as well - or the Jets or possibly even Atlanta.

Yes, a ploy Like Mendenhall, they already made Dwyer inactive previously because of fumbles. (Want to say it was his game vs. the Raiders earlier this year) I think Mendenhall will still have a say in the Pitt backfield. I like Dwyer a lot. Even said he'd be the guy in Pittsburgh backfield over the summer, but he hasn't look that good the last 4 games, averaging 3.1 or less in 3 of the 4. I don't think he has firm enough grasp as the starter to continue at that rate)Mendenhall's in a tough spot. He's not going to get a big payday this offseason. He can either go the 1 year incentive laden prove it route or a longer term for Michael Bush like money. Certain that Mendenhall had visions of a much bigger payday than that. Going the 1 year route, in the heart of any RB's career, is risky.He's going to have to earn his pay a la Cedric Benson with the Bengals IMO. Let's remember in 2011, he wasn't on pace to get 1000 yards. He's a good, not great, RB.It'll depend what he looks for in free agency. Some teams would just as soon draft a younger, cheaper with less miles on their legs under their control for the next 4 years.

 

[BespokeJort]

Quite a few guys on that WR list that I would not trade Cecil Shorts for

 

[RavenLunatic]

Thanks for sharing. I'd like to see FBG create a "Wisdom of the Crowd" Dynasty Ranking, with a way for all to add their input.

 

[Sebowski]

Guessing this is the OP's dynasty team.

QB Russell Wilson, SEA

RB David Wilson, NYG

RB Knowsawn Moreno, DEN

WR Brandon Marshall, CHI

WR Randall Cobb, GB

WR Antonio Brown, PIT

TE Owen Daniels, HOU

 

[DoubleG]

Guessing this is the OP's dynasty team.

QB Russell Wilson, SEA

RB David Wilson, NYG

RB Knowsawn Moreno, DEN

WR Brandon Marshall, CHI

WR Randall Cobb, GB

WR Antonio Brown, PIT

TE Owen Daniels, HOU

And if it was, it would show...?? What exactly? That he's consistant?It is completely possible that you are correct - and if it's not, I would think he was crazy or an idiot. But your comment presupposes that his team reflects his rankings, when in point of fact, it is quite possible that he assembled his team based on those rankings. I don't understand why people rip owners who are high on guys that are on their teams(s) - of course they are - that's why they are on their team.

 

[thriftyrocker]

Guessing this is the OP's dynasty team.QB Russell Wilson, SEARB David Wilson, NYGRB Knowsawn Moreno, DENWR Brandon Marshall, CHIWR Randall Cobb, GBWR Antonio Brown, PITTE Owen Daniels, HOU

Cobb ranking is low IMO, assuming PPR.

 

[SSOG]

Not sure why a 23 year old Torry Smith is ranked so low.

Primarily because of Qb

Flacco's game is one-dimensional, but that one dimension happens to be Torrey's strength. For all his faults, Flacco is one of the top 5 deep ball passers in the league.

I'd be very very interested in what your top 25's look like. I have aLways enjoyed your posts in the Dynasty Rankings Blog

Been sprinkling some rankings in that thread as the season progresses. Here are my most recent RB ranks (November 23rd):1. Rice2. Richardson3. Peterson4. McCoy5. Martin6. Charles7. Spiller8. Foster9. Forte10. Mathews11. Lynch12. Morris13. McFadden14. Stewart15. Ridley16. Murray17. Chris Johnson18. Bradshaw19. Wilson20. Leshoure21. Reginald Bush22. Hunter23. Ingram24. Mendenhall25. Hillman26. Ben Tate27. Gore28. Sproles29. Richardson30. Lamar Miller31. SJax32. Law Firm33. FJax34. Ivory35. Dwyer36. Pierre ThomasAnd QBs from October 23rd:1- Rodgers2- Griffin3- Newton4- Brees5- Ryan6- Luck7- Stafford8- Roethlisberger9- Brady10- Eli11- Peyton12- Tannehill13- Romo14- Dalton15- Vick16- Flacco17- Locker18- Freeman19- Ponder20- Wilson21- Schaub22- Rivers23- Cutler24- BradfordProbably roll out WRs in a week or two.

Solid stuff - as always. I could nitpick a little - I'd have Mendenhall higher, as I think he might get a change of scenery which I actually think could move him closer to a borderline #1 RB (which he has been even with the horrible line the Steelers have had). I'd also tap R. Wilson a few notches at QB. Definately like him over Ponder - probably closer to 15 (Flacco, Freeman and Locker have failed to impress me). Looking forward to your thoughts on WR.ETA - I know you're a talent>situation guy (I am a disciple as well) - but McCoy's concussion issues and B. Brown's absolute amazing showing in Shady's absence is double cause for pause in terms of McCoy's ranking. Honestly, I'd probably have McCoy just outside the top 10 if for no other reason, then the possibility that this could be a Jahvid Best/Austin Collie situation - with a backup who has been simply eye-popping.

good read thank you!I'm surprised that both of you (new-guru and SSOG) have Freeman so low. they will have a really good line next year, a very good RB and at least two good WRs.

The answer to both of you is to remember the date those rankings are from. Freeman and Wilson have both been on fire since October. Shady's injury (and Brown's emergence) came since Thanksgiving, when those RB rankings were made. Today, I'd have both Freeman and Wilson in the top15, and Shady outside the top 5.Edit: slot Freeman and Wilson right behind Tannehill at 13/14. McCoy at 8 right behind Foster.

 

[DoubleG]

Not sure why a 23 year old Torry Smith is ranked so low.

Primarily because of Qb

Flacco's game is one-dimensional, but that one dimension happens to be Torrey's strength. For all his faults, Flacco is one of the top 5 deep ball passers in the league.

I'd be very very interested in what your top 25's look like. I have aLways enjoyed your posts in the Dynasty Rankings Blog

Been sprinkling some rankings in that thread as the season progresses. Here are my most recent RB ranks (November 23rd):1. Rice2. Richardson3. Peterson4. McCoy5. Martin6. Charles7. Spiller8. Foster9. Forte10. Mathews11. Lynch12. Morris13. McFadden14. Stewart15. Ridley16. Murray17. Chris Johnson18. Bradshaw19. Wilson20. Leshoure21. Reginald Bush22. Hunter23. Ingram24. Mendenhall25. Hillman26. Ben Tate27. Gore28. Sproles29. Richardson30. Lamar Miller31. SJax32. Law Firm33. FJax34. Ivory35. Dwyer36. Pierre ThomasAnd QBs from October 23rd:1- Rodgers2- Griffin3- Newton4- Brees5- Ryan6- Luck7- Stafford8- Roethlisberger9- Brady10- Eli11- Peyton12- Tannehill13- Romo14- Dalton15- Vick16- Flacco17- Locker18- Freeman19- Ponder20- Wilson21- Schaub22- Rivers23- Cutler24- BradfordProbably roll out WRs in a week or two.

Solid stuff - as always. I could nitpick a little - I'd have Mendenhall higher, as I think he might get a change of scenery which I actually think could move him closer to a borderline #1 RB (which he has been even with the horrible line the Steelers have had). I'd also tap R. Wilson a few notches at QB. Definately like him over Ponder - probably closer to 15 (Flacco, Freeman and Locker have failed to impress me). Looking forward to your thoughts on WR.ETA - I know you're a talent>situation guy (I am a disciple as well) - but McCoy's concussion issues and B. Brown's absolute amazing showing in Shady's absence is double cause for pause in terms of McCoy's ranking. Honestly, I'd probably have McCoy just outside the top 10 if for no other reason, then the possibility that this could be a Jahvid Best/Austin Collie situation - with a backup who has been simply eye-popping.

good read thank you!I'm surprised that both of you (new-guru and SSOG) have Freeman so low. they will have a really good line next year, a very good RB and at least two good WRs.

The answer to both of you is to remember the date those rankings are from. Freeman and Wilson have both been on fire since October. Shady's injury (and Brown's emergence) came since Thanksgiving, when those RB rankings were made. Today, I'd have both Freeman and Wilson in the top15, and Shady outside the top 5.Edit: slot Freeman and Wilson right behind Tannehill at 13/14. McCoy at 8 right behind Foster.

Even better. Yeah, McCoy being there certainly makes sense. Well in that case, my rankings would look so similar to yours, there no point in wasting space.

 

[new-guru]

Guessing this is the OP's dynasty team.QB Russell Wilson, SEARB David Wilson, NYGRB Knowsawn Moreno, DENWR Brandon Marshall, CHIWR Randall Cobb, GBWR Antonio Brown, PITTE Owen Daniels, HOU

Cobb ranking is low IMO, assuming PPR.

Cobb, and David Wilson, You guessed 2 out of 20 good job

 

[new-guru]

I put Moreno in there for several reasons

1st round pick

1st round talent

young

pass block

I was hoping to hear some feedback on who will lead the denver backfield. Hillman? Moreno? old man McGahee?

Whos the Future?

 

[new-guru]

I would find somewhere to put Maclin and Gordon before going with Hilton. JMO

I agree with you, Gordon has really impressed me. His QB trusts him and he's big and athletic. He has dropped some easy balls, but he'll fix that.

 

[new-guru]

Thanks for sharing. I'd like to see FBG create a "Wisdom of the Crowd" Dynasty Ranking, with a way for all to add their input.

 

[SSOG]

I put Moreno in there for several reasons1st round pick1st round talent youngpass blockI was hoping to hear some feedback on who will lead the denver backfield. Hillman? Moreno? old man McGahee?Whos the Future?

There's a reason Moreno spent two months on the inactive list. Fox knows he's not the answer. He's historically been leery of relying on young backs, and Hillman has some questions surrounding him still, but Moreno's not the answer.

 

[new-guru]

David Wilson, Owen Daniels and Tony Moeaki stand out to me. What do you like about each to rank them that high?

David WilsonAbsolutely love his situation, o - line, his talent, if he can control the ball and pass protect he'll be amazingO Daniels and Moeaki both seem to me if they could just stay healthy then great would follow

I know it was only one game. However David Wilson reassured me that he will be a stud!

 

[Concept Coop]

Andre Johnson is still high for me, at #12. He is only providing low end WR1 numbers. Why not go with younger options providing the same?

35 YO Brady over 23 YO Newton is off, compared to how I value them.

Jordy is too low.

Hernandez is low.

Wilson is crazy high.

McCoy, Morris, and Ridley are low.

Good list. Thanks for sharing.

 

[Two Deep]

IMO

Hakeem Nicks to high.

Include Housler in with TE

 

[matttyl]

37 WRs listed in the OP, and (in my league) the #30 overall WR who's a rookie isn't even listed?

Josh Gordon is on pace for 52/900/6 on fewer than 95 targets.....as a rookie with a rookie QB! That's better than the rookie season of Calvin, Jennings, and a load of others...and pretty comparable to Larry Fitz' or Bowe's rookie year when everyone immediately had them in their top 20 for dynasty.

 

[Warrior]

37 WRs listed in the OP, and (in my league) the #30 overall WR who's a rookie isn't even listed?Josh Gordon is on pace for 52/900/6 on fewer than 95 targets.....as a rookie with a rookie QB! That's better than the rookie season of Calvin, Jennings, and a load of others...and pretty comparable to Larry Fitz' or Bowe's rookie year when everyone immediately had them in their top 20 for dynasty.

Fitz >>>> Bowe >>> Gordon, even in their rookie years that was obvious. That's why.

 

[matttyl]

37 WRs listed in the OP, and (in my league) the #30 overall WR who's a rookie isn't even listed?Josh Gordon is on pace for 52/900/6 on fewer than 95 targets.....as a rookie with a rookie QB! That's better than the rookie season of Calvin, Jennings, and a load of others...and pretty comparable to Larry Fitz' or Bowe's rookie year when everyone immediately had them in their top 20 for dynasty.

Fitz >>>> Bowe >>> Gordon, even in their rookie years that was obvious. That's why.

I'm not arguing that point, and I agree with you. Just saying that he's a top 30 WR THIS YEAR as a rookie, why wouldn't be at least be a top 30 dynasty WR? Fitz and Bowe were much better in their rookie years, and both went onto have top 5 seasons. No reason Gordon can't go on to have a top 15 season or two, maybe more.

 

[SSOG]

David Wilson, Owen Daniels and Tony Moeaki stand out to me. What do you like about each to rank them that high?

David WilsonAbsolutely love his situation, o - line, his talent, if he can control the ball and pass protect he'll be amazingO Daniels and Moeaki both seem to me if they could just stay healthy then great would follow

I know it was only one game. However David Wilson reassured me that he will be a stud!

One game against the worst defense in the league. Just saying.

 

[loose circuits]

Owen Daniels at TE3, bold