Give Robinsons to get a Golladay? (1 Viewer)

[iamkoza]

Earlier this week i thought Golladay was in for a huge year. He was a top 5 WR in my 0.5ppr format on only 110 tragets and despite poor QB play hampering his production in the second half of last season. he was bouyed by 11 td's but i felt at worst he'd be top 5 again.

i offered allen robinson and james robinson to the golladay owner who said it was close but turned it down.... well now that golladay has a hammy and is out this week that same owner wants to do the deal (shocking). I question how much better ARob can get (had almost 150 targets, 98 catches and 7 scores). it seems like best case he can repeat the year or worse he isnt as productive.

Do i take the offer? I have excellent WR depth (arob, lockett, hollywood, gallup, preston williams, reagor) so i think i could get by without gollday for a couple of weeks, i just dont know what this injury means going froward if it is a short term speed bump or a sign of rough year ahead.

 

[Gally]

Earlier this week i thought Golladay was in for a huge year. He was a top 5 WR in my 0.5ppr format on only 110 tragets and despite poor QB play hampering his production in the second half of last season. he was bouyed by 11 td's but i felt at worst he'd be top 5 again.

i offered allen robinson and james robinson to the golladay owner who said it was close but turned it down.... well now that golladay has a hammy and is out this week that same owner wants to do the deal (shocking). I question how much better ARob can get (had almost 150 targets, 98 catches and 7 scores). it seems like best case he can repeat the year or worse he isnt as productive.

Do i take the offer? I have excellent WR depth (arob, lockett, hollywood, gallup, preston williams, reagor) so i think i could get by without gollday for a couple of weeks, i just dont know what this injury means going froward if it is a short term speed bump or a sign of rough year ahead.

I actually think last year was A-Rob's floor (barring injury).  The QB last year for him was terrible and he was still able to put up those numbers.  I actually expect his numbers to go up this year however I do think Golladay is a top 5 WR.  The hammie is a big concern for this year.  Is this is a dynasty or redraft?  If it's a dynasty I pull the trigger.  If it's redraft I don't. 

 

[DaBearsTN]

I would Keep the Robinson's

 

[socrates]

I'd rather have Golladay in dynasty. Redraft, take AR15. I own Golladay in dynasty FYI

Agreed.  Redraft, the difference at WR is perhaps negligible, so keep the healthy Robinson and his RB counterpart.