Gronk/Barber/Carson for Ertz/Thielen (1 Viewer)

[BigJonE300]

I have an offer of P. Barber, Carson and Gronk in exchange for Ertz and Thielen in an 18-team PPR dynasty league.  We start 1-QB, 1-RB, 2-WR, 1-TE and 2-Flex in addition to 7 - IDPs.  We keep 5 on offense and 3 IDPs, no more than 2 at any single position.  Am I giving up too much strength at WR?  I feel that Ertz for Gronk is perhaps an even swap, Gronk being better short term with Ertz better dynasty value.  I almost did a knee-jerk accept on this trade, but I'm starting to think I'm giving up too much for uncertainties at RB.  I don't like my RB situation at all and I'm not sure this trade provides me a long term fix for that either.  I won two years ago with Bortles, OBJ, McCoy and Miller.  I don't even remember who my second WR was.  I feel like there is going to be an offensive explosion this season and the WRs are going to be the beneficiaries.  Right now my team is as follows.

• QB -D.Watson
  
• QB - Bortles
  
• RB - McCoy
  
• RB - J. Wilkins
  
• RB -Ware
  
• WR - OBJ
  
• WR - Thielen
  
• WR - Samuel
  
• WR - C. Kirk
  
• TE - Ertz
  
• IDP's - JJ Watt, Hunter, Wagner, L. David, Van Noy, S. Davis, M. Hyde, Mo Hurst, J.Jones, V. Burfict (start 2-DL, 3-LB, 2-DB)
  
• Redshirts - J. Jackson, D. Cain, L. Vander Esch
  

 

[djmich]

I'd stand pat, think Thielen is undervalued, particularly in ppr.   He's clearly your #2 WR.

And while your RB's are terrible for dynasty, Carson and Barber are long shots that they are the answer.

 

[Survivor7700]

Thielen racks up a ton of catches. I think you might have something in P. Barber as well. I stick with what you have.