As I was looking back at Joe Gibbs’ career playoff record, it dawned on me what vivid and visceral memories I have of each of these 22 games. So, because I am going crazy waiting for Saturday, have gone ahead and rated each of Gibbs' career playoff games, from worst to best. Yes, I did this from memory, and yes, I have a problem.
#22
1983 - Lost to Raiders in Super Bowl
What a debacle. The 1981 Redskins were 14-2, set the all-time points record, had NFL MVP Joe Theismann as QB, and had beaten Oakland in the regular season. In the instant before Jack Squirek’s INT made the score 21-3, I said to my friend, “OK, if they take a knee here, they’ll come out and score after the opening kickoff of the second half and it will be 14-10.” In fact, the Skins did score on the opening drive of the second half, but missed the extra point and never scored again in the 38-9 loss. I still wonder what might have happened if they had closed the gap to 14-10.
#21
1984 - Lost to Chicago in home divisional round shocker
This was the end of the first Redskins Super Bowl era, marked by Theismann, Riggins and the Smurfs. It was also the coming out party for the Bears defense, which nobody knew was about to become legendary but played incredibly that day in shocking the Redskins for the only home playoff loss of Gibbs’ career.
#20
1990 – lost to SF 28-10 in Divisional playoff
This game exposed Rypien as not quite ready for prime time. The 49ers were going for their third straight Super Bowl and dominated the Redskins, with the came being capped by 400-pound Kevin Carter picking up a fumble after a sack and running 50 yards (in about 20 seconds) for the clinching TD.
#19
1992 - Lost to SF 20-13
The Redskins’ final title defense fizzled in SF, as the 49ers scored on their opening drive and never quite let the Skins back in the game. We didn’t know it at the time, but we wouldn’t see Gibbs again for 12 years following this game.
#18
1986 - Lost NFC Championship at Giants 17-0
This is the highest-rated of Gibbs’ playoff losses and might even rate ahead of some of the wins if only this overachieving Redskins team hadn’t been shut out. Played in a howling gale in the Meadowlands, Gary Clark dropped a long TD pass in the first half that might have changed the game’s complexion. Redskins played tough, but my enduring memory is of Jay Schroeder getting knocked silly on the rock-hard turf in the final minutes as the Giants immortalized the Gatorade shtick on the way to their first Super Bowl.
#17
1992 - Won Wild Card game at Minnesota
Defending champs back-doored into a Wild Card spot despite losing in the season’s final week and then posted an insignificant victory over the Sean Salisbury-led Vikings.
#16
1983 – outlasted SF in NFC Championship, 24-21
Should have been a huge warning sign that the 1983 team was losing its edge. Skins jumped to a 21-0 lead, then held on as Mosley missed three FGs and a shaky pass interference call bailed the team out late in the fourth quarter by giving him one more chance.
#15
1986 - Beat Rams 19-7 in Wild Card
Another fairly non-descript game. Only highlight I remember was Darrell Green coming from across the field to pull Eric Dickerson down from behind on a breakaway. And my brother got lost on the way back to the RFK parking lot where he was supposed to meet us after the game and we got home three hours late.
#14
1982 – Beat Detroit in first round
Strike year, so all playoff teams were seeded 1 through 8 and everyone had to win three games to reach the Super Bowl, even the top-seeded Redskins. Detroit marched down the field on its opening drive until Jeris White picked off a pass and ran it back 95 yards for a TD and the 31-7 rout was on. This Lions team (with a record of 4-5) never should have been in the post-season.
#13
1991 - Beat Atlanta in divisional round
This was a non-descript, workman-like divisional round victory over Deion and the “Too Legit to Quit Falcons” who featured MC Hammer on the sideline. Played in a driving rainstorm, this game’s most distinguishing feature was the thousands of giveaway seat cushions thrown onto the field following the Redskins’ score of the clinching TD.
#12
1983 - Killed Rams 51-7 in divisional game
This was the high water mark of the original Skins champions. Rookie Darrell Green capped the slaughter with an INT return for a TD and everyone thought this game was the launching pad for a second straight Super Bowl and a dynasty. Instead, they struggled the next week vs. SF and then got killed in the Super Bowl by Oakland. We also got our first VCR for Christmas this year, making this the first game that I attended in person and then came home and immediately watched on tape.
#11
2005 – Beat TB in Wild Card game
An ugly game, but the Gibbs magic returns.
#10
1982 - Beat Minnesota in second round, 21-7
A fairly workmanlike victory, made notable by Riggins’ 185 yards rushing and the curtain call/bow he took at midfield as he was taken out of the game in the final minutes. This was probably the height of Riggo-mania as hundreds, maybe thousands, of fans smuggled in horns and blew them constantly in honor of “The Diesel.”
#9
1990 – Beat Eagles at Philly in Wild Card
Revenge for that season’s earlier infamous “Body Bag Game.” The game turned on a key replay challenge when Byner coughed up a fumble that the Eagles’ D returned 90 yards for a TD. Replay gave the ball back to Washington who went in for a TD.
#8
1986 – Divisional win at Chicago
McMahon was out with injury, but the Bears were still 14-2 and considered themselves a budding dynasty until Art Monk got loose for a couple of long TD catches in the fourth quarter and the heavily favored Bears were stunned, 27-13, missing out on a classic confrontation with the 1986 Giants defense.
#7
1991 – Killed Detroit in NFC Championship
One of my personal favorites, since it’s the only Redskins NFC Championship game I attended, Washington totally dominated Barry Sanders and Erik Kramer, 41-10. The party started before halftime and peaked with Darrell Green’s INT return for a TD. I’m still thankful to this day that the Lions somehow beat Dallas in the divisional round, because that Cowboys team was the only one that could compete with the 91 Redskins.
#6
1987 - Beat Minnesota in NFC championship
Kind of a blah game, really. Skins scored on their opening possession when Williams hit Kelvin Bryant deep out of the backfield, and then they kind of struggled the rest of the game. The 7-point victory wasn’t secure until Darrell Green defended a fourth down goalline pass that hit RB Darrin Nelson in the hands but fell away.
#5
1991 - Won Super Bowl vs. Bills
The first half of this game was a comedy of errors for the Bills. It was hard to get too excited about watching a team so clearly beat itself. Game was over when Kurt Gouveia intercepted the first pass of the second half and ran it down to the goalline to set up a 21-3 lead.
#4
1987 - Won Super Bowl vs. Broncos
Boy, did this start ugly. After falling behind 10-0, the Redskins almost lost the ensuing kickoff inside their own 20 and Doug Williams got knocked out of the game. Still can’t believe they then scored 35 points in the second quarter. Man, the AFC really sucked in the 80s.
#3
1987 – Won at Chicago in divisional round
When #1 seed SF shockingly lost on Saturday of divisional weekend, this game was suddenly being played for the right to host the Wild Card Vikings the following week in the NFC Championship. The Bears had McMahon back and jumped to a 14-0 lead, but the game turned on an astonishing Darrell Green punt return for a TD in the third quarter and ended when Payton was stuffed on fourth-and-inches on the final carry of his career. A team that had looked dead in early December was suddenly one home game away from the Super Bowl.
#2
1982 – Won NFC Championship vs. Dallas
Dexter Manley knocks Danny White out, then later swats a Gary Hogeboom pass to DT Darryl Grant who rumbles in for a TD and the Redskins have beaten Dallas. What a great game. Weirdly, I still remember it was played on Saturday and then we had to wait until Sunday for the Jets-Dolphins game to see who the opponent was going to be.
#1
1982 – Won Super Bowl vs. Miami
The Dolphins scored two fluke TDs and held the lead into the fourth quarter until Riggins took the fourth-and-one carry 43 yards for the go-ahead TD. I still remember the elation and disbelief that the Redskins had won the Super Bowl.