Has anyone done a 2007 Fantasy mock rookie draft yet? (1 Viewer)

[Softball 3:16]

1. Marshawn Lynch RB Cal

2. Michael Hart RB MICH

3. Kenny Irons RB AUB

4. Calvin Johnson WR GT

5. Adrian Peterson RB OKLA

6. Brady Quinn QB ND

7. Dwayne Jarrett USC

8. Ted Ginn Jr WR OSU

9. Jeff Samardziga WR ND

10. Brian Brohm QB LOU

11. Sidney Rice WR SCAR

12. Michael Bush RB LOU

Discuss

 

[5Rings]

I think Adrian Peterson at 5 is too low. Definately top 2, IMO.

 

[switz]

I think Adrian Peterson at 5 is too low. Definately top 2, IMO.

Ted Ginn Jr right now reminds me of Peter Warrick.

 

[Blackjacks]

I think Adrian Peterson at 5 is too low. Definately top 2, IMO.

Ted Ginn Jr right now reminds me of Peter Warrick.

On both.From a pure talent standpoint I would definetly put A. Peterson as the #1 running back prospect. Of course, it all depends on where he goes.

 

[ffgiant]

4. Calvin Johnson WR GT5. Adrian Peterson RB OKLADiscuss

Aren't those 2 supposed to be the undisputed top 2 in every draft?

 

[Softball 3:16]

4. Calvin Johnson WR GT5. Adrian Peterson RB OKLADiscuss

Aren't those 2 supposed to be the undisputed top 2 in every draft?

I figured since one has an injury, and the other is a WR (assuming a league where people gobble up running backs first) that they both fall. Who knows though, it's November.

 

[DawnBTVS]

I'd drop Michael Hart a bit. It seems like everytime I watch him, he gets some solid runs and then goes down on first contact easily on other runs.

 

[aposulli]

1. Marshawn Lynch RB Cal2. Michael Hart RB MICH3. Kenny Irons RB AUB4. Calvin Johnson WR GT5. Adrian Peterson RB OKLA6. Brady Quinn QB ND7. Dwayne Jarrett USC8. Ted Ginn Jr WR OSU9. Jeff Samardziga WR ND10. Brian Brohm QB LOU11. Sidney Rice WR SCAR12. Michael Bush RB LOUDiscuss

At least you didn't include ineligible players like in other lists I've seen In all seriousness, it all depends on what teams these guys go to...Adrian Peterson's injury might scare some people off, but he should still be a top 3 pick.Beware of Michigan RBs (and Big 10 backs in general). Mike Hart might look great in college, but in no way is he a top 3 RB in this year's class.Anyone who says Ginn reminds them of Warrick....

 

[lod2005]

Marshawn at #1.

 

[cstu]

1. Marshawn Lynch RB Cal2. Michael Hart RB MICH3. Kenny Irons RB AUB4. Calvin Johnson WR GT5. Adrian Peterson RB OKLA6. Brady Quinn QB ND7. Dwayne Jarrett USC8. Ted Ginn Jr WR OSU9. Jeff Samardziga WR ND10. Brian Brohm QB LOU11. Sidney Rice WR SCAR12. Michael Bush RB LOUDiscuss

1. Adrian Peterson RB OKLA2. Marshawn Lynch RB Cal3. Michael Bush RB LOU (if he goes to the Steelers)4. Calvin Johnson WR GT5. Kenny Irons RB AUB6. Dwayne Jarrett USC7. Michael Hart RB MICH 8. Ted Ginn Jr WR OSU9. Brady Quinn QB ND10. Sidney Rice WR SCAR11. Brian Brohm QB LOU12. Jeff Samardziga WR NDThis is rough since I haven't thought about it much. I don't like taking QB's high and I'm not 100% sold on Quinn or Brohm - they don't strike me as the next Peyton Manning. I need to see more of Bush, Hart and Irons to really gauge them.

 

[MLBrandow]

While it's always fun to read these, without any explanations it's pretty pointless.

I'd like to hear your opinions on why these guys go in this order.

 

[kwhutto]

Depending on who drafts him, Calvin Johnson could be sick. He is putting up great numbers with a BAD QB...

He has size, ability, and a great attitude. Imagine Randy Moss or TO with Marvin Harrison's attitude!

 

[redman]

I think Adrian Peterson at 5 is too low. Definately top 2, IMO.

Ted Ginn Jr right now reminds me of Peter Warrick.

Why? I'm not saying you're wrong, I'm just curious about your reasoning.

 

[King of the Jungle]

Kenny Irons does nothing for me.

Marshawn Lynch RB Cal

Calvin Johnson WR GT

Adrian Peterson RB OKLA

Ted Ginn Jr WR OSU

Michael Bush RB LOU

Brady Quinn QB ND

Dwayne Jarrett USC

Brian Brohm QB LOU

Michael Hart RB MICH

Jeff Samardziga WR ND

Sidney Rice WR SCAR

Kenny Irons RB AUB

 

[JayJay328]

Depending on who drafts him, Calvin Johnson could be sick. He is putting up great numbers with a BAD QB... He has size, ability, and a great attitude. Imagine Randy Moss or TO with Marvin Harrison's attitude!

That would be Marvin Harrison!!!!! Do not disrespect greatness, same draft class for T.O. and Marvin, check their carrers and then get back to me because you sir, do not have a clue.Calvin Johnson has everythng that you want in a great WR, Height, Athletic Ability, Hands, Attitude, just like Marvin.

 

[The Man Who Met Andy Griffith]

Depending on who drafts him, Calvin Johnson could be sick. He is putting up great numbers with a BAD QB... He has size, ability, and a great attitude. Imagine Randy Moss or TO with Marvin Harrison's attitude!

That would be Marvin Harrison!!!!! Do not disrespect greatness, same draft class for T.O. and Marvin, check their carrers and then get back to me because you sir, do not have a clue.Calvin Johnson has everythng that you want in a great WR, Height, Athletic Ability, Hands, Attitude, just like Marvin.

Yes, it is a grave insult to suggest that Marvin Harrison is shorter than Randy Moss...

 

[johnnyfb]

YEAH MARSHAWN!

... except he isn't going pro. Not after losing to USC, Tenn, and Arizona. Not after proving he can't play on the road. I don't even think he's a solid first round pick yet - hasn't shown he can really pull a team through in the clutch. He's pure athleticism though.

(caveat: Go Bears!)

 

[redman]

YEAH MARSHAWN!... except he isn't going pro. Not after losing to USC, Tenn, and Arizona. Not after proving he can't play on the road. I don't even think he's a solid first round pick yet - hasn't shown he can really pull a team through in the clutch. He's pure athleticism though.(caveat: Go Bears!)

Unless you think that he's dead set on winning the Pac-10 title before he leaves school, I'd say he's as good as gone. RB's have short enough careers as it is, and I'd figure that he's in the top half of the first round as it is. I doubt he puts that at risk by playing another year at Cal.

 

[coolnerd]

YEAH MARSHAWN!... except he isn't going pro. Not after losing to USC, Tenn, and Arizona. Not after proving he can't play on the road. I don't even think he's a solid first round pick yet - hasn't shown he can really pull a team through in the clutch. He's pure athleticism though.(caveat: Go Bears!)

Unless you think that he's dead set on winning the Pac-10 title before he leaves school, I'd say he's as good as gone. RB's have short enough careers as it is, and I'd figure that he's in the top half of the first round as it is. I doubt he puts that at risk by playing another year at Cal.

I would have a tough time thinking of a Rb who has been highly productive (and did not go to the university of Texas) and did not leave early. Unless he gets injuried or does something stupid, I think he is a first rounder and will be in this year's draft.

 

[ChampBailey24]

I'd drop Michael Hart a bit. It seems like everytime I watch him, he gets some solid runs and then goes down on first contact easily on other runs.

Are you kidding ? Mike hart definetely needs to take 10-15 more lbs but that guy is as solid as they come. Did you see him against OSU?

 

[B. Nugget]

1. Marshawn Lynch RB Cal2. Michael Hart RB MICH3. Kenny Irons RB AUB4. Calvin Johnson WR GT5. Adrian Peterson RB OKLA6. Brady Quinn QB ND7. Dwayne Jarrett USC8. Ted Ginn Jr WR OSU9. Jeff Samardziga WR ND10. Brian Brohm QB LOU11. Sidney Rice WR SCAR12. Michael Bush RB LOUDiscuss

I hope Michael Bush falls that far! I guess out of sight out of mind?

 

[aposulli]

I hope Michael Bush falls that far! I guess out of sight out of mind?

Clealry this list factors in Peterson's and Bush's durability questions. Though I like both higher.

 

[jeter23]

YEAH MARSHAWN!... except he isn't going pro. Not after losing to USC, Tenn, and Arizona. Not after proving he can't play on the road. I don't even think he's a solid first round pick yet - hasn't shown he can really pull a team through in the clutch. He's pure athleticism though.(caveat: Go Bears!)

Unless you think that he's dead set on winning the Pac-10 title before he leaves school, I'd say he's as good as gone. RB's have short enough careers as it is, and I'd figure that he's in the top half of the first round as it is. I doubt he puts that at risk by playing another year at Cal.

I would have a tough time thinking of a Rb who has been highly productive (and did not go to the university of Texas) and did not leave early. Unless he gets injuried or does something stupid, I think he is a first rounder and will be in this year's draft.

I think Lynch will be a 1st rounder, especially with Bush and Peterson getting hurt. The RB class is just not all that deep.

 

[aposulli]

I think Adrian Peterson at 5 is too low. Definately top 2, IMO.

Ted Ginn Jr right now reminds me of Peter Warrick.

Why? I'm not saying you're wrong, I'm just curious about your reasoning.

Warrick had great quickness, but not great top end speed like Ginn. And he was only great in wide open spaces.When you watch Ginn play you can see he's got great hands and concentration.I've noticed a little trick he employs when catching the deep ball is to react to the ball late so the DB doesn't know it's coming. It may sound silly, but DBs in most cases don't turn for the ball so they defend basde ont eh WRs reaction to the ball. In many cases Ginn can go up and snag the ball before the DB knows it's coming, which is one reason him and Smith connect so often on that play... that and Ginn can burn anyone.Warrick wouldntve been so bad if it weren't for injuries during his career, but I expect that if Ginn stays healthy he will be a far better NFL WR than Warrick could've ever been.Top 5 in this class for sure, and that's saying alot considering the other guys.

 

[DawnBTVS]

I'd drop Michael Hart a bit. It seems like everytime I watch him, he gets some solid runs and then goes down on first contact easily on other runs.

Are you kidding ? Mike hart definetely needs to take 10-15 more lbs but that guy is as solid as they come. Did you see him against OSU?

One game does not a stud make. Like I said, he makes solid runs most of the time (80-85%) but I've also seen him go down on first contact easily. I'm not saying he won't be a great NFL RB but I don't think he warrants being placed as high as he was in the initial post (RB #2 IIRC).I'd have him at RB 4/RB 5 right now.1: Marshawn Lynch2: Adrian Peterson3: Michael Bush4: Mike Hart5: Kenny Irons (could switch to 4 with Hart)

 

[Gandalf]

I think Adrian Peterson at 5 is too low. Definately top 2, IMO.

Ted Ginn Jr right now reminds me of Peter Warrick.

Why? I'm not saying you're wrong, I'm just curious about your reasoning.

Warrick had great quickness, but not great top end speed like Ginn. And he was only great in wide open spaces.When you watch Ginn play you can see he's got great hands and concentration.

I've noticed a little trick he employs when catching the deep ball is to react to the ball late so the DB doesn't know it's coming. It may sound silly, but DBs in most cases don't turn for the ball so they defend basde ont eh WRs reaction to the ball. In many cases Ginn can go up and snag the ball before the DB knows it's coming, which is one reason him and Smith connect so often on that play... that and Ginn can burn anyone.

Warrick wouldntve been so bad if it weren't for injuries during his career, but I expect that if Ginn stays healthy he will be a far better NFL WR than Warrick could've ever been.

Top 5 in this class for sure, and that's saying alot considering the other guys.

The only problem that I find with your assessment is that Tedd Ginn is fast. Sprinter fast. In fact he was a national champion hurdler in high school. He's way faster than Warrick who ran a 4.65 or something at the combine. I think you can question every aspect of Ginn's game, except his speed. And in the games I've watched he looks like he's blowing by DBs consistently. All that said, Calvin Johnson is by far the best WR prospect in this draft, IMO.For those interested, check out Tedd Ginn, Jr. on wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ted_Ginn_Jr.

As far as the list above. Even with the injury Peterson is a top 2 talent. However, I like Marshawn Lynch a lot too and am an owner.

 

[-OZ-]

1. Adrian Peterson RB OKLA2. Marshawn Lynch RB Cal3. Michael Bush RB LOU (if he goes to the Steelers)4. Calvin Johnson WR GT5. Kenny Irons RB AUB6. Dwayne Jarrett USC7. Michael Hart RB MICH 8. Ted Ginn Jr WR OSU9. Brady Quinn QB ND10. Sidney Rice WR SCAR11. Brian Brohm QB LOU12. Jeff Samardziga WR NDThis is rough since I haven't thought about it much. I don't like taking QB's high and I'm not 100% sold on Quinn or Brohm - they don't strike me as the next Peyton Manning. I need to see more of Bush, Hart and Irons to really gauge them.

I like this list, although I'd put Rice above Ginn, maybe above Hart. In my leagues, I'll put Calvin Johnson as an equal to Lynch, but only because the leagues are heavy on WRs. If Lynch lands with the Jets, I'll place him as #2, in Oakland or some other teams, he's #3 or lower (depending on Bush's combine).I don't care about the injury, unless AP doesn't recover by the combine, he's #1 by a fair margin.

 

[aposulli]

While it's always fun to read these, without any explanations it's pretty pointless.I'd like to hear your opinions on why these guys go in this order.

Note: this is the original order of the poster, not my rankings...1. Marshawn Lynch RB Cal (Jr)Could be one of the top 3 RBs if he comes out. His size and speed is ideal for a shifty back. Certainly no J.J. Arrington.2. Michael Hart RB MICH (Jr)I don't think he's going to come out unless maybe Michigan wins the Championship. He's overrated in my book. Plus he's got the Michigan RB curse to deal with. "Solid" will not get it done in the NFL as a feature back.3. Kenny Irons RB AUB (Sn)Could be the best RB in the class. Could be the next Cadillac Williams. Not as quite as quick, but more durable.4. Calvin Johnson WR GT (Jr)AKA Larry Fitzgerald. He looks like a man playing amongst boys.5. Adrian Peterson RB OKLA (Jr)Collarbone worries me. Other than that he is the only eye-popping RB in this class. He's got the whole package and he is motivated.6. Brady Quinn QB ND (Sn)Maybe a bit overrated, but I still think someone (Buffalo) will jump on his early. Good size, not tremendous arm strength, but his awareness is well above average.7. Dwayne Jarrett WR USC (Jr)Could be the next Mike Williams. Or the next Roy Williams. He's gonna need some good coaching to get motivated.8. Ted Ginn Jr WR OSU (Jr)See above post.9. Jeff Samardziga WR ND (Sn)The next Drew Bennett. (just kidding). More athletic than Bennett, though similarly to Bennett, lacks top end speed. Great size, hands, and body control.10. Brian Brohm QB LOU (Jr)Lacks ideal size, but has great accuracy and awareness. Great leader as shown by his ability to flat out win.11. Sidney Rice WR SCAR (So)Get the same feeling with this guy as Calvin, though he seems a bit more immature. He's only a Sophmore but I think there's a better chance of him coming out than some Juniors on this list. Great size and natural ability. Sometimes struggles to separate when he's in double-coverage, which is always the case.12. Michael Bush RB LOU (Sn)Freak athelete. Played QB in High School. Vision (ability to find holes) is the only ?.Afew more:Jason Hill WR WASH ST (Sr)Haven't seem him play and he's not having as good of a year as people thought he would. May be due to inconsistent QB play. Still a top 3 Senior WR according to the experts.Ken Darby RB BAMA (Sr)Very solid. No other Senior RBs stand out besides him after Irons and Bush.Drew Stanton QB MSU (Sr)May be the best QB in the draft, but it's hard to tell since at MSU he's being used as an option QB.

 

[tri-man 47]

I'd drop Michael Hart a bit. It seems like everytime I watch him, he gets some solid runs and then goes down on first contact easily on other runs.

Are you kidding ? Mike hart definetely needs to take 10-15 more lbs but that guy is as solid as they come. Did you see him against OSU?

One game does not a stud make. Like I said, he makes solid runs most of the time (80-85%) but I've also seen him go down on first contact easily.

I've watched Hart a lot and the biggest positive on him, I'd say, is that he does NOT go down on contact. He's very low to the ground and is very hard to bring down. I don't know if his size or lack of speed will hurt him much in the pros - probably so - but the issue is not his ability to keep the legs churning and powering ahead.

 

[aposulli]

I'd drop Michael Hart a bit. It seems like everytime I watch him, he gets some solid runs and then goes down on first contact easily on other runs.

Are you kidding ? Mike hart definetely needs to take 10-15 more lbs but that guy is as solid as they come. Did you see him against OSU?

One game does not a stud make. Like I said, he makes solid runs most of the time (80-85%) but I've also seen him go down on first contact easily.

I've watched Hart a lot and the biggest positive on him, I'd say, is that he does NOT go down on contact. He's very low to the ground and is very hard to bring down. I don't know if his size or lack of speed will hurt him much in the pros - probably so - but the issue is not his ability to keep the legs churning and powering ahead.

Howbout both? He could be a solid, if not unspectacular RB, because at least he's determined like you asid, and he never fumbles.

 

[Hellfire Snail]

I'd drop Michael Hart a bit. It seems like everytime I watch him, he gets some solid runs and then goes down on first contact easily on other runs.

I've watched every Michigan game this year. Hart drives piles. He gains two extra yards when most backs wouldn't. He is the entire package and will be a stud if given any blocking at all.

 

[Alonso de Cordoba]

If you have the #1 pick next year, attempt to deal it for Bush or Maroney. Peterson's pretty much an even swap for DeAngelo Williams. All the rest of the backs are unimpressive. Either take Calvin Johnson at #2 or trade down as far as you feel comfortable with still being able to grab him.

 

[-OZ-]

I'd drop Michael Hart a bit. It seems like everytime I watch him, he gets some solid runs and then goes down on first contact easily on other runs.

I've watched every Michigan game this year. Hart drives piles. He gains two extra yards when most backs wouldn't. He is the entire package and will be a stud if given any blocking at all.

I'd like to share in your optimism. I like the kid's heart and will probably draft him in a league or two, but not ahead of Irons or probably Rice. I see a successful career, but not spectacular. If you want a fair #2 or depth RB, he's your man, I just don't see top flight potential. Unless of course, he's a Steeler and Parker wasn't. He would be a good fit there.

 

[Sigmund Bloom]

Of course I'll be HEAVILY breaking down this class in the offseason, but here'e my quick take, with some assumptions for underclassmen coming out:

1) Adrian Peterson - bruiser with home run ability on any play, used to being a workhorse

2) Marshawn Lynch - looks NFL ready in just about every facet of his game

3) Calvin Johnson - total freak. Wouldnt argue against him #1 overall, only RB scarcity puts him here.

4) Mike Hart - will be sick if a zone blocking team takes him.

5) Kenny Irons - great burst, but cant stay healthy

6) Brady Quinn - doesnt rise to the occasion in big games, but should be a top 5 pick in April

7) Ted Ginn - i want to see more natural WR skills. Still raw if you ask me.

8) Dwayne Jarrett - great frame, but Mike Williams comparison looms.

9) JaMarcus Russell - Culpepper type, a tree with an arm, and he's a fearless runner. Decisions sometimes erratic.

10)Troy Smith - Real tough to slot him. a better big game QB than Quinn. Height issue.

11)Michael Bush - not as tough a runner as his size would suggest.

12)Johnnie Lee Higgins - the best WR you've never heard of.

I project Sidney Rice and Brian Brohm staying, but they would be in the 7-12 range if they come out.

I am completely sold on the top 3. Irons and Hart are both nice RBs, but not on Peterson and Lynch's level, although Hart in Denver would be a fantasy dream come true. I don't really like Quinn, but he'll put up numbers. Think Eli Manning. Im not sold on either Ginn or Jarrett. Russell could be a fantasy force and Smith is very intriguing. Either of them could move up as high as #7 if you need a QB instead of a WR. Bush worries me because of the Eric Shelton debacle. Bush is an even better athlete, but he hasnt been forced to run smashmouth very much. I wonder if the Louisville wide open offense makes these freakish size-speed RBs look better than they really are. Higgins is a personal favorite - really there are tons of guys to consider for that 12 spot, including Samardzija, Tony Hunt, Ken Darby, Drew Stanton, Zach Miller, Greg Olsen. The post draft period is going to shake all this up, except the top 3, which are clearly head and shoulders above the rest.

 

[switz]

I think Adrian Peterson at 5 is too low. Definately top 2, IMO.

Ted Ginn Jr right now reminds me of Peter Warrick.

Why? I'm not saying you're wrong, I'm just curious about your reasoning.

I haven't seen a ton of his games on the whole, which is why I said "right now." My opinion could change as I catch more film, even highlights. Honestly though, Warrick seemed amazing at the college level, but he never seemed to grasp the nuances of his position. Ginn seems the same way. Watch Ginn's routes... they leave a lot to be desired. He doesn't seem to face to much press coverage, which would negate his speed on the pro level. His game is one dimensional.Maybe Raghib Ismail or Desmond Howard would be better comparisons, because they were all speed, like Ginn. But Warrick and Ginn both seem like great kick returners, not so great WRs.

 

[Warpig]

Can we expound on this list for us guys that are in 32 team leagues with IDP's and will have a late pick in the first round?





Thanks.

 

[pgreenfan]

Of course I'll be HEAVILY breaking down this class in the offseason, but here'e my quick take, with some assumptions for underclassmen coming out:1) Adrian Peterson - bruiser with home run ability on any play, used to being a workhorse2) Marshawn Lynch - looks NFL ready in just about every facet of his game3) Calvin Johnson - total freak. Wouldnt argue against him #1 overall, only RB scarcity puts him here.4) Mike Hart - will be sick if a zone blocking team takes him.5) Kenny Irons - great burst, but cant stay healthy6) Brady Quinn - doesnt rise to the occasion in big games, but should be a top 5 pick in April7) Ted Ginn - i want to see more natural WR skills. Still raw if you ask me. 8) Dwayne Jarrett - great frame, but Mike Williams comparison looms.9) JaMarcus Russell - Culpepper type, a tree with an arm, and he's a fearless runner. Decisions sometimes erratic.10)Troy Smith - Real tough to slot him. a better big game QB than Quinn. Height issue.11)Michael Bush - not as tough a runner as his size would suggest.12)Johnnie Lee Higgins - the best WR you've never heard of.I project Sidney Rice and Brian Brohm staying, but they would be in the 7-12 range if they come out.I am completely sold on the top 3. Irons and Hart are both nice RBs, but not on Peterson and Lynch's level, although Hart in Denver would be a fantasy dream come true. I don't really like Quinn, but he'll put up numbers. Think Eli Manning. Im not sold on either Ginn or Jarrett. Russell could be a fantasy force and Smith is very intriguing. Either of them could move up as high as #7 if you need a QB instead of a WR. Bush worries me because of the Eric Shelton debacle. Bush is an even better athlete, but he hasnt been forced to run smashmouth very much. I wonder if the Louisville wide open offense makes these freakish size-speed RBs look better than they really are. Higgins is a personal favorite - really there are tons of guys to consider for that 12 spot, including Samardzija, Tony Hunt, Ken Darby, Drew Stanton, Zach Miller, Greg Olsen. The post draft period is going to shake all this up, except the top 3, which are clearly head and shoulders above the rest.

Bloom any thoughts on the IDP guys in this draft class?

 

[Sigmund Bloom]

Can we expound on this list for us guys that are in 32 team leagues with IDP's and will have a late pick in the first round? Thanks.

Dont worry, the first rookie 100 will come out sometime after underclassmen declare and ill be putting out updated editions after the all star games, combine, pro days, draft, minicamps, and during training camp. We got ya covered.

 

[donkey]

I project Sidney Rice and Brian Brohm staying, but they would be in the 7-12 range if they come out.

Local news reports in SC indicate Rice to be staying for one more year. As a Clemson Alum, I hope he bolts, but I would be very surprised if he did.

 

[The Royal Jack]

I project Sidney Rice and Brian Brohm staying, but they would be in the 7-12 range if they come out.

Local news reports in SC indicate Rice to be staying for one more year. As a Clemson Alum, I hope he bolts, but I would be very surprised if he did.

Spurrier has reported that Rice will stay next season for the Gamecocks.

Ginn seems a little one dimensional, e.g. Troy Williamson?

I like Hart but is his size ideal for the top of the list?

I really like Dallas Baker WR Florida.

 

[aposulli]

I project Sidney Rice and Brian Brohm staying, but they would be in the 7-12 range if they come out.

Local news reports in SC indicate Rice to be staying for one more year. As a Clemson Alum, I hope he bolts, but I would be very surprised if he did.

Spurrier has reported that Rice will stay next season for the Gamecocks.

Ginn seems a little one dimensional, e.g. Troy Williamson?

I like Hart but is his size ideal for the top of the list?

I really like Dallas Baker WR Florida.

Ginn might not be known yet as a great route runner but at least he has good hands unlike butterfingers Williamson.

 

[Warpig]

Can we expound on this list for us guys that are in 32 team leagues with IDP's and will have a late pick in the first round? Thanks.

Dont worry, the first rookie 100 will come out sometime after underclassmen declare and ill be putting out updated editions after the all star games, combine, pro days, draft, minicamps, and during training camp. We got ya covered.

Sweeeeeeeeeeeet. I'm drooling just a little bit.

 

[Otis]

Kenny Irons does nothing for me.Marshawn Lynch RB CalCalvin Johnson WR GTAdrian Peterson RB OKLA

I think these three have to be automatic top 3. I can't figure out the exact order, but I have no problem with the above. And, as always, a lot will changed after the NFL draft (although, regardless of situation, I'd have a hard time moving any of these three down).

 

[SproutDaddy]

I'd drop Michael Hart a bit. It seems like everytime I watch him, he gets some solid runs and then goes down on first contact easily on other runs.

Just my opinion, but Hart seems one of the best RB candidates. He has great patience in letting his blocks develop, and he goes down on first contact about as much as any RB. The guy breaks tackles bottom line, and the stiff arm is nasty.Problem is he is a junior if memory serves me correct. Who said he was coming out?

 

[redman]

What do you guys think of Marcus Monk?

 

[The Man Who Met Andy Griffith]

I'd drop Michael Hart a bit. It seems like everytime I watch him, he gets some solid runs and then goes down on first contact easily on other runs.

Just my opinion, but Hart seems one of the best RB candidates. He has great patience in letting his blocks develop, and he goes down on first contact about as much as any RB. The guy breaks tackles bottom line, and the stiff arm is nasty.Problem is he is a junior if memory serves me correct. Who said he was coming out?

Also has good quickness and acceleration, but not good top end speed.Downside: Jake Long may make him look better than he really is.

 

[Sigmund Bloom]

What do you guys think of Marcus Monk?

Shhh. He's one of many interesting big junior WRs (Limas Sweed, Robert Meachem, Adarius Bowman, Maurice Purify in addition to Jarrett and Calvin Johnson)Soft hands, great ball tracking skills, quick/fast for a long-legged big guy, knows how to use his height/size advantage.Very Colston-esqueAnyone reading this should check him and Darren McFadden (in addition to JaMarcus Russell, Dwayne Bowe and many other top talents) on Friday while they're gorging on leftover turducken (230 EST).

 

[JohnnyU]

I think Adrian Peterson at 5 is too low. Definately top 2, IMO.

Ted Ginn Jr right now reminds me of Peter Warrick.

Maybe to you he does, but to me he looks VERY talented, with both speed and hands. He may be the best WR in the draft, and yes, that includes Mr. Johnson.

 

[SproutDaddy]

I think Adrian Peterson at 5 is too low. Definately top 2, IMO.

Ted Ginn Jr right now reminds me of Peter Warrick.

Maybe to you he does, but to me he looks VERY talented, with both speed and hands. He may be the best WR in the draft, and yes, that includes Mr. Johnson.

Cool, I'll take Johnson.

 

[JohnnyU]

I think Adrian Peterson at 5 is too low. Definately top 2, IMO.

Ted Ginn Jr right now reminds me of Peter Warrick.

Maybe to you he does, but to me he looks VERY talented, with both speed and hands. He may be the best WR in the draft, and yes, that includes Mr. Johnson.

Cool, I'll take Johnson.

Damn, shhh!!! Can't you see I want Johnson to fall to me in my rookie draft?Edited to say, what I said about Ginn is true as far as his talent, speed, and hands. I too prefer Johnson. Like bloom said, he's a freak.