Help evaluating a trade please. (1 Viewer)

[Hurl Bruce]

Redraft, 12 tm 1pt ppr.

Guy offered me Tre Tucker and Aaron Jones for my Wandale Robinson. I know these are all middling players, but still. How do you feel about this trade? If he wants Robinson, is there a different trade to be had? I sent back a counter of Breece Hall, Mason, and Wandale for Achane and Tucker. No response yet, but he'll probably decline. Is there a fair trade to be had? Here are our rosters:

Quarterbacks L. Jackson J. Dart Running Backs B. Hall Q. Judkins W. Marks T. Spears J. Mason D. Singletary Wide Receivers J. Smith-Njigba J. Chase T. Franklin W. Robinson J. Coker Tight Ends T. Warren D. Kincaid Team Defense Seahawks

Quarterbacks D. Prescott M. Stafford Running Backs J. Jacobs D. Achane T. Etienne Jr. A. Jones Sr. K. Vidal Wide Receivers D. Adams A. Pierce T. Tucker J. Jennings T. McLaurin Tight Ends D. Goedert T. Johnson Team Defense Patriots Jaguars

 

[Gally]

I would take that first trade offer assuming you don't have to drop someone of consequence. Pairing up Jones/Mason is nice in case one gets injured and definitely doesn't hurt you. I like Tucker better than Wandale moving forward with Meyers out of town.

Like you said its secondary player but I think the upside of Tucker is higher than Wandale due to the change of situation after the trade deadline.

Not sure what to think of the other offer (Hall/Achane). Both terrible offenses and have no idea whether Breece goes scorched earth to show what he can do or gives up and does nothing to show his displeasure. Also, if they bench Tua does Achane go down the tubes. Not sure what to do with either of those situations.

 

[brainee]

I mean yeah ... the first offer is fine. And as mentioned it locks up the Vikings backfield, and Tucker's role in the post-trade offense has yet to be seen. The players are so mid it doesn't look to make an impact on the strength of your team.

I do like the second trade you offered, which legit improves your starters. Although I agree it probably wouldn't be accepted. Wandale is a steep price for downgrading from Achane to Hall, although Hall had that huge last game so that could help.