What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Highest draft pick not to make team (1 Viewer)

flranger

Footballguy
This group is great at finding interesting topics. With training camp started I wondered.......

What draft pick was so bad that they were not even able to make the squad for the team that drafted them that season?

First response: Maurice Clarett (101st overall) 3rd round Denver 2005

I'm sure there are even higher picks that didn't make it first year, I'd be curious to see the list.

Please don't include the guys who never showed up....(Bo Jackson pick 1 of 1st round to Tampa for instance).

 
Last edited by a moderator:
This group is great at finding interesting topics. With training camp started I wondered.......What draft pick was so bad that they were not even able to make the squad for the team that drafted them that season?First response: Maurice Clarett (101st overall) 3rd round Denver 2005I'm sure there are even higher picks that didn't make it first year, I'd be curious to see the list.Please don't include the guys who never showed up....(Bo Jackson pick 1 of 1st round to Tampa for instance).
I think Skylar Green was the Cowboys 3rd rounder last year and didnt make the team?
 
Bo Jackson is the obvious choice since he never did play with TB and they didn't receive any compensation for him in 1986.

Dimitrius Underwood for the Vikings back in 1999 was a pretty horrible choice as well. Never did play a down in the NFL....

 
Bo Jackson is the obvious choice since he never did play with TB and they didn't receive any compensation for him in 1986.

Dimitrius Underwood for the Vikings back in 1999 was a pretty horrible choice as well. Never did play a down in the NFL....
Xfrom wiki

He later signed with the Dallas Cowboys with a two-year contract. During the 2000-2001 seasons, Underwood had 21 tackles and 4 sacks in 19 games.

 
I don't see Bo qualifying here as he certainly would've made the squad if they could've signed him.

A bit off topic, but gotta give a shout to the CFL team that drafted someone who was deceased.

-QG

 
I don't know for sure if Huey Richardson qualifies, but I know he gives the Steelers Heartburn... 15th Pick in 1991 Ejected a Year later after three teams and 16 games. Here is a link to a story form a couple of years ago...Huey :cry:

 
These two made the team, but not for very long. Colts drafted DT Ken Novak (Purdue) and WR Randy Burke (Ky) in the 1st rd in the late 70s.. Both were horrible. The Colts based their analysis of Burke only on his Senior Bowl performance. Scouting sure has improved over the years.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Siran Stacy (PHI, drafted #48 overall in 1992) who never had a single rush in the NFL and is credited with only 1 game played. He ended up playing in the CFL and in the WLAF/NFLEurope.

 
The Saints 1987 first-rounder, DT Shawn Knight, was straight-up cut after the last preseason game. Not crazy, or in legal trouble, or hurt, or anything ... just couldn't play.

 
This group is great at finding interesting topics. With training camp started I wondered.......What draft pick was so bad that they were not even able to make the squad for the team that drafted them that season?First response: Maurice Clarett (101st overall) 3rd round Denver 2005I'm sure there are even higher picks that didn't make it first year, I'd be curious to see the list.Please don't include the guys who never showed up....(Bo Jackson pick 1 of 1st round to Tampa for instance).
For all the talk about what a colossal bust Clarett was, he wasn't even the highest-drafted player to not make the team IN HIS OWN DRAFT- and unlike the other players who got cut, he didn't have a dime of guaranteed money. There were far worse picks in that particular draft than Clarett, you just didn't hear about them because none of them were as much of a trainwreck.
 
The Redskins traded up (with the hated Cowboys!) into the end of the first round in 1996 to draft OT Andre Johnson, Penn State at 1.31. He didn't make it through camp. :unsure:

 
SSOG said:
flranger said:
This group is great at finding interesting topics. With training camp started I wondered.......What draft pick was so bad that they were not even able to make the squad for the team that drafted them that season?First response: Maurice Clarett (101st overall) 3rd round Denver 2005I'm sure there are even higher picks that didn't make it first year, I'd be curious to see the list.Please don't include the guys who never showed up....(Bo Jackson pick 1 of 1st round to Tampa for instance).
For all the talk about what a colossal bust Clarett was, he wasn't even the highest-drafted player to not make the team IN HIS OWN DRAFT- and unlike the other players who got cut, he didn't have a dime of guaranteed money. There were far worse picks in that particular draft than Clarett, you just didn't hear about them because none of them were as much of a trainwreck.
Yeah, but he's the only one who "got his Goose on" during practices. :stalker:
 
Ministry of Pain said:
1991...With the 23rd pick in the NFL draft the Miami Dolphins select Randal Hill, WR from the University of Miami.
And upon hearing those words in 1991, I singlehandedly destroyed several shelves worth of shoe boxes in the back room of the FootLocker in the Omni Mall in Miami.Thanks for the memories. :goodposting:

 
And upon hearing those words in 1991, I singlehandedly destroyed several shelves worth of shoe boxes in the back room of the FootLocker in the Omni Mall in Miami.
I thought I was the only one that vented anger in that way. Those guys that work at Foot Locker sure hate to see me coming.
 
Ministry of Pain said:
1991...With the 23rd pick in the NFL draft the Miami Dolphins select Randal Hill, WR from the University of Miami.
And upon hearing those words in 1991, I singlehandedly destroyed several shelves worth of shoe boxes in the back room of the FootLocker in the Omni Mall in Miami.Thanks for the memories. ;)
Oooooh, then you guys will love this:
1991: Fast wideout Hill can stay in Miami

By CRAIG BARNES

Sun-Sentinel

Posted April 22 1991

MIAMI -- In the quarterback draft of 1983, the Dolphins got Dan Marino. In the wide receiver draft of 1991, they got Randal Hill.

The scenarios are similar, and the Dolphins must be hoping the results will be the same.

Marino was chosen No. 27 in the first round, after John Elway, Todd Blackledge, Jim Kelly, Ken O`Brien and Tony Eason. It was said that he mysteriously had slipped. Marino said he had something to prove, and he has -- for eight years.

When Miami`s No. 23 selection came Sunday, Raghib Ismail had taken millions and fled to Canada, and Herman Moore, Alvin Harper and Mike Pritchard were already gone.

It left Miami to choose Hill, the hometown favorite and former Hurricane star. It`s being said that he slipped because he lacks courage, runs out of bounds, can`t catch and can`t take a hit.

Hill and the Dolphins are glad he slipped. His agent, Drew Rosenhaus, said that the teams that let him go will be sorry.

``Thanks to his detractors,`` Rosenhaus said. ``They will regret it. Dan Marino-to-Randal Hill will make the teams who bypassed him regret it. It will happen so fast that they might not feel the sting. The Dolphins made his dream become a reality.``

Like Marino in 1983, Hill believes he has something to prove, and he`s looking forward to having the opportunity with the Dolphins.

``I enjoy proving people wrong,`` said the 5-10, 177-pound Hill, who had 107 catches for 1,643 yards and 11 touchdowns at UM. ``When I came out of high school, they said I couldn`t play wide receiver. They were wrong then, and they`ll be wrong again.``

Miami wanted Hill, a Killian High School graduate, because he fills a need at receiver and was the fastest player in the draft.

``When you have a quarterback like Dan Marino, the greatest dropback passer that the game has seen, you have to get him some weapons to utilize,`` Dolphins coach Don Shula said.

``Hill ran the fastest 40 (4.3) that we`ve timed out here. He had a good workout, and in the practices at the Senior Bowl, he put on a clinic against the top defensive backs in the country.``

So far it has been speed over power, the opposite of a year ago when Miami selected offensive linemen Richmond Webb and Keith Sims in the opening rounds. Only Ismail was regarded as faster than Hill, and Shula said, ``It would be a good race.``

In the third round Miami, using a selection obtained from Atlanta for cornerback Tim McKyer, drafted Aaron Craver of Fresno State, a 5-11, 214-pound running back with 4.4 speed.

The Dolphins have nine selections today, including a No. 12 in the McKyer deal, to address their defensive needs, primarily a down lineman or outside linebacker with the ability to rush the passer.

``In Craver we drafted by far the best athlete as opposed to drafting a need,`` said Tom Heckert, Miami`s director of college scouting.

Wide receiver was a concern: Mark Duper is 32 and Mark Clayton 30.

Duper had a good season, but injuries hampered Clayton.

``Some teams draft track guys who play football,`` Heckert said. ``We drafted a football player who happens to be fast.

``I think we`re extremely fortunate to have a guy of his caliber available to us in the 23rd pick. I was surprised that he slid down. I thought a number of teams ahead of that were looking for a speed receiver and might take him.``

Hill was a little upset when he was passed twice by Dallas and his former coach, Jimmy Johnson.

``I had mixed emotions about it,`` he said. ``Maybe he just didn`t have enough faith in me.``

It`s hard not to have faith in a guy who can rattle off the 40 in 4.29, 4.22 and 4.27 clockings.

``The things people have said about me are things I can`t stop,`` Hill said. ``All I can do is play and show them.

``I can`t express in words how I feel about being able to stay home. It`s something I always dreamed about. I want to come in and contribute right away. I won`t be a holdout. I don`t believe in it.

``It`s hard to imagine just catching a pass from Dan Marino in practice. He`s going to the Hall of Fame. I`ll also have a chance to learn from Mark Duper and Mark Clayton. They`ve been to the playoffs and Super Bowl. They know.``

Perhaps the overriding question about Hill is his end-zone celebrations.

``It`ll have to be confined up here,`` he said. ``You`re playing for money, not just for fun, and you have to be more respectful of your opponents.``
 
It left Miami to choose Hill, the hometown favorite and former Hurricane star. It`s being said that he slipped because he lacks courage, runs out of bounds, can`t catch and can`t take a hit.
What can you say? Sometimes the prognosticators get it right.Oh, and for mentioning Drew Rosenhaus and Randall in the same article: :ph34r: :unsure: :banned: :eek:

 
It left Miami to choose Hill, the hometown favorite and former Hurricane star. It`s being said that he slipped because he lacks courage, runs out of bounds, can`t catch and can`t take a hit.
What can you say? Sometimes the prognosticators get it right.Oh, and for mentioning Drew Rosenhaus and Randall in the same article: :confused: :unsure: :unsure: :confused:
It also reminds you of another Miami draft pick, no? Undersized, fast, questions about suitability to play in the NFL, in a deep WR draft . . .
 
Tom Cousineau

:billsfan: = :goodposting:
From Wiki:
Cousineau was drafted first overall in the 1979 NFL Draft by the Buffalo Bills, but never played a game with the Bills after Cousineau thought that the Bills were rude to him. He instead signed with the Canadian Football League Montreal Alouettes where they offered double the money that the Bills originally offered. Cousineau became a star there, becoming the Grey Cup Most Valuable Player in the 1979 season. Cousineau wanted to return to the NFL, and in 1982 the Houston Oilers attempted to sign him, but the Bills (who still held Cousineau's NFL rights) matched the offer. He was then traded from the Bills to the Cleveland Browns for a first round draft choice (14th overall) in the 1983 NFL Draft[3]. That pick was used on future Hall of Fame quarterback Jim Kelly.
What's the problem here? :goodposting:
 
These two made the team, but not for very long. Colts drafted DT Ken Novak (Purdue) and WR Randy Burke (Ky) in the 1st rd in the late 70s.. Both were horrible. The Colts based their analysis of Burke only on his Senior Bowl performance. Scouting sure has improved over the years.
I hate you for bringing up those drafts. :confused: 77 and 78 Colt drafts: 2 of the worst ever.
 
The Redskins traded up (with the hated Cowboys!) into the end of the first round in 1996 to draft OT Andre Johnson, Penn State at 1.31. He didn't make it through camp. :confused:
I think we have a winner.Really guys affected by injuries/etc shouldn't "count" in this. Like others I was thinking those who busted due to simply sucking.
 
Dave Wannstedt drafted Bob "the Beast" Sapp in the third round in '97. 69th pick overall.

He didn't make it out of training camp - he didn't know left from right.

He was pretty good in Elektra though.

 
I think the Chargers would have been better off if Ryan Leaf didn't make the team in the first place.

 
1991...With the 23rd pick in the NFL draft the Miami Dolphins select Randal Hill, WR from the University of Miami.
That pick worked out for Miami when they traded Hill to the Cardinals for a 1992 1st rounder that becameTroy Vincent. Plus,Hill played 1 game for Miami before being traded,so he made the team and wouldnt qualify for this thread.

 
So has anyone actually got an answer to the original question of what is the highest draft pick to not make it to the final roster in their first season?
1988 first round, Denver Broncos select DT Ted Gregory out of Syracuse with the 26th pick of the first round.Funny follow up. Someone had mentioned Shawn Knight the DT who the Saints had drafted with the 11th pick in the first round of the 1987 draft that sucked. TRUE he did suck! The funny part was that Ted Gregory sucked soooo bad that Dan Reeses traded him for Shawn Knight before the last preseason game of the 1988 season. So Shawn Knight actually made the Saints final roster in 1987 but Ted Gregory DID NOT make the Broncos final roster in 1988, THE YEAR HE WAS DRAFTED! Can you IMAGINE your team drafting a guy IN THE FIRST ROUND and then CUTTING his ### in PRESEASON????Hysterical!But, wait for it, their is more to the story which is a scream.The Broncos played the Saints in preseason that year and Ted Gregory got to face the Broncos. In his one shining moment of glory in the NFL, he busted through the line and sacked John Elway in front of a packed house at Mile High. I busted a gut laughing my ### off. Not just a BUST of epic proportions but probably the most humilating bust in NFL history.
 
It left Miami to choose Hill, the hometown favorite and former Hurricane star. It`s being said that he slipped because he lacks courage, runs out of bounds, can`t catch and can`t take a hit.
What can you say? Sometimes the prognosticators get it right.Oh, and for mentioning Drew Rosenhaus and Randall in the same article: :cry: :confused: :banned: :hot:
It also reminds you of another Miami draft pick, no? Undersized, fast, questions about suitability to play in the NFL, in a deep WR draft . . .
You forgot the obligatory Desmond Howard comparison.I'm scared. I hear a LOT of good things about this kid, and he looks like an absolute freak of nature on film, but I hope he ends up being more like Steve Smith than Howard.

Time will tell.

 
The Goat said:
It left Miami to choose Hill, the hometown favorite and former Hurricane star. It`s being said that he slipped because he lacks courage, runs out of bounds, can`t catch and can`t take a hit.
What can you say? Sometimes the prognosticators get it right.Oh, and for mentioning Drew Rosenhaus and Randall in the same article: :yes: :sarcasm: :unsure: :thumbdown:
It also reminds you of another Miami draft pick, no? Undersized, fast, questions about suitability to play in the NFL, in a deep WR draft . . .
You forgot the obligatory Desmond Howard comparison.I'm scared. I hear a LOT of good things about this kid, and he looks like an absolute freak of nature on film, but I hope he ends up being more like Steve Smith than Howard.

Time will tell.
No doubt. The 'Skins got a little spoiled with their "Smurfs", especially Gary Clark, over the years and may not have been as critical in evaluating Howard as they should have been. :unsure:
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top