How would you rank Judkins, Marks, and Tracy ROS? WHIR (1 Viewer)

[mharaguc]

Full PPR. I might end up trading one or two of these guys so I'm trying to figure out who to keep and who to trade. Judkins seems like the universal top option but the injury does factor in. Marks and Tracy both have bad strength of schedule but catch passes so they still matter even when the offenses struggle so I don't know what to make of them. How would you rank these RBs ROS?

Marks
Judkins
Tracy

 

[ukblue35]

Judkins, Marks and Tracy for me.

 

[brainee]

I'll say Judkins, Tracy, Marks. Judkins is clear #1 (bad game last time notwithstanding)

 

[Gally]

I don't think you should limit your trade to one guy. By that I mean shop all of them and see what offers make the most sense or improve you the most. Sometimes when you try and move one particular player you limit your upside and return. Be open to moving any of them and see where the best options happen.

 

[mharaguc]

I don't think you should limit your trade to one guy. By that I mean shop all of them and see what offers make the most sense or improve you the most. Sometimes when you try and move one particular player you limit your upside and return. Be open to moving any of them and see where the best options happen.

I'm not but the current situation is such that I wouldn't be getting a RB in return because the other guy doesn't have any RBs I want. There's basically only one guy in the league that's willing to trade anything remotely reasonable. People kept trying to get me to give them Gibbs for Harrison and stuff like that. Other than those three, my RBs are Gibbs, Irving, Montgomery, White, and Vidal so not trading all of them would be nice since I wouldn't be getting a RB in return.

 

[skh502]

I’d rank them Judkins, Tracy, Marks…. But relative to their current trade value (how they are perceived by most people), I’d say Tracy, Marks, Judkins; especially in PPR. Hold Tracy, sell Judkins high bc people want him.

 

[Gally]

I don't think you should limit your trade to one guy. By that I mean shop all of them and see what offers make the most sense or improve you the most. Sometimes when you try and move one particular player you limit your upside and return. Be open to moving any of them and see where the best options happen.

I'm not but the current situation is such that I wouldn't be getting a RB in return because the other guy doesn't have any RBs I want. There's basically only one guy in the league that's willing to trade anything remotely reasonable. People kept trying to get me to give them Gibbs for Harrison and stuff like that. Other than those three, my RBs are Gibbs, Irving, Montgomery, White, and Vidal so not trading all of them would be nice since I wouldn't be getting a RB in return.

I don't mean trade all three RB's. I mean trade whichever RB gets you the best haul.

 

[mharaguc]

I don't think you should limit your trade to one guy. By that I mean shop all of them and see what offers make the most sense or improve you the most. Sometimes when you try and move one particular player you limit your upside and return. Be open to moving any of them and see where the best options happen.

I'm not but the current situation is such that I wouldn't be getting a RB in return because the other guy doesn't have any RBs I want. There's basically only one guy in the league that's willing to trade anything remotely reasonable. People kept trying to get me to give them Gibbs for Harrison and stuff like that. Other than those three, my RBs are Gibbs, Irving, Montgomery, White, and Vidal so not trading all of them would be nice since I wouldn't be getting a RB in return.

I don't mean trade all three RB's. I mean trade whichever RB gets you the best haul.

The guy doesn't have a ton that I'd want to trade for, at least for what I'd have to give up. I'm basically trying to trade for Egbuka and that's about it. I guess I could go after Dowdle, Franklin, or Hunter as well. I did try to get Hunter off waivers but he got him instead. I can list if you want to see. My team is good enough that there's not much I could get that would improve my roster from what I can see but I'm definitely open to suggestions.

 

[Gally]

I don't think you should limit your trade to one guy. By that I mean shop all of them and see what offers make the most sense or improve you the most. Sometimes when you try and move one particular player you limit your upside and return. Be open to moving any of them and see where the best options happen.

I'm not but the current situation is such that I wouldn't be getting a RB in return because the other guy doesn't have any RBs I want. There's basically only one guy in the league that's willing to trade anything remotely reasonable. People kept trying to get me to give them Gibbs for Harrison and stuff like that. Other than those three, my RBs are Gibbs, Irving, Montgomery, White, and Vidal so not trading all of them would be nice since I wouldn't be getting a RB in return.

I don't mean trade all three RB's. I mean trade whichever RB gets you the best haul.

The guy doesn't have a ton that I'd want to trade for, at least for what I'd have to give up. I'm basically trying to trade for Egbuka and that's about it. I guess I could go after Dowdle, Franklin, or Hunter as well. I did try to get Hunter off waivers but he got him instead. I can list if you want to see. My team is good enough that there's not much I could get that would improve my roster from what I can see but I'm definitely open to suggestions.

So look at a different team. I am confused why you are stuck with only one trade partner. Maybe I am misunderstanding your question. Are you looking to trade one of the RB's listed and aren't sure which one to trade?

 

[mharaguc]

I don't think you should limit your trade to one guy. By that I mean shop all of them and see what offers make the most sense or improve you the most. Sometimes when you try and move one particular player you limit your upside and return. Be open to moving any of them and see where the best options happen.

I'm not but the current situation is such that I wouldn't be getting a RB in return because the other guy doesn't have any RBs I want. There's basically only one guy in the league that's willing to trade anything remotely reasonable. People kept trying to get me to give them Gibbs for Harrison and stuff like that. Other than those three, my RBs are Gibbs, Irving, Montgomery, White, and Vidal so not trading all of them would be nice since I wouldn't be getting a RB in return.

I don't mean trade all three RB's. I mean trade whichever RB gets you the best haul.

The guy doesn't have a ton that I'd want to trade for, at least for what I'd have to give up. I'm basically trying to trade for Egbuka and that's about it. I guess I could go after Dowdle, Franklin, or Hunter as well. I did try to get Hunter off waivers but he got him instead. I can list if you want to see. My team is good enough that there's not much I could get that would improve my roster from what I can see but I'm definitely open to suggestions.

So look at a different team. I am confused why you are stuck with only one trade partner. Maybe I am misunderstanding your question. Are you looking to trade one of the RB's listed and aren't sure which one to trade

Like I said, the people in this league don't trade except for the one guy. It's an ESPN public league, which my experience with those has been very meh in terms of interaction. When I've tried to trade with the people in this league, they tend to want me to give them Gibbs or Lamb for Harrison or Kincaid or something like that and they don't negotiate. They just expect that or they won't trade so I just gave up. I'm asking for people to rank them to figure out how I want to try to keep but it will also help me figure out which one or two I'd prefer to trade away if I can manage to come up with something that works. I just don't know how to value them so I'm asking everybody else to give thoughts so I can decide what to do.