*HYPOTHETICAL* - NFL Trade - Leftwich for Jerry Porter (1 Viewer)

[Bossman]

I just can't see JAX holding onto both Leftwich and Garrard.

 

[Cannon Fodder]

I just can't see JAX holding onto both Leftwich and Garrard.

Some people might have a problem with the title of this.

 

[Jeff Pasquino]

I just can't see JAX holding onto both Leftwich and Garrard.

Some people might have a problem with the title of this.

Misleading title. I changed it.Don't make Dynasty owners have a heart attack, please.

 

[(HULK)]

I don't think this trade makes any sense at all for Jacksonville.

If they want to get rid of Lefty, they can get a lot more than problem child Jerry Porter.

 

[Bossman]

I just can't see JAX holding onto both Leftwich and Garrard.

Some people might have a problem with the title of this.

Misleading title. I changed it.Don't make Dynasty owners have a heart attack, please.

good point. I assumed since the trade deadline was long past that "Hypothetical" was implied.

 

[Bossman]

I don't think this trade makes any sense at all for Jacksonville.If they want to get rid of Lefty, they can get a lot more than problem child Jerry Porter.

Then the same trade for Moss?

 

[BigRed]

I don't think it makes sense as Leftwich isn't the most reliable QB in the whole wide world (and JAX has their share of WRs, granted none proven to Porter's talent level), but it sounds like the kind of stop-gap QB think OAK would do. Course why would JAX would a problem child butthole like Porter?

 

[saintfool]

I don't think it makes sense as Leftwich isn't the most reliable QB in the whole wide world (and JAX has their share of WRs, granted none proven to Porter's talent level), but it sounds like the kind of stop-gap QB think OAK would do. Course why would JAX would a problem child butthole like Porter?

also, QB>WR in terms of value too. Teams recognize that Leftwich, although oft injured, is still a starting QB and that's more valuable than most WR's. I don't see the Oakland o-line protecting Leftwich well enough to keep him healthy for 16 games either. Leftwich to Minnesota, Detroit or Cleveland makes more sense somehow.

 

[Bri]

Jags have good young WRs, they don't need any WRs. They might need a better coach for the WRs or trainer re injuries or some such but they don't need another WR IMO

 

[AB in DC]

Isn't Leftwich going into the final year of his contract?

 

[Foosball God]

QB is much more valuable in the NFL than a WR, especially for a WR that's only "good" at best.

 

[-OZ-]

Leftwich to Minnesota, Detroit or Cleveland makes more sense somehow.

I'd prefer Leftwich for Mike Williams and a mid level pick. Jacksonville might too.