I guess my point is this: Whenever Brady has been called on, he has always done great(see his game winning drives vs Oakland, St Louis, and Carolina), so why wouldn't you think that if they called on him like that all game long, that he wouldn't be just as successful??
See 2002. Brady was called upon to win games ala Trent Green and Peyton Manning, and he couldn't take his team to the playoffs. Unless "whenever" means "usually", you're off base here.
He took his team to a winning record, led the league in TDs along the way, and was in first place in the division when they finished their last game of the season, which they won despite him having a separated shoulder for the last couple games, and a sieve of a run D that had bothered them all season. Remember when Manning broke his jaw and Edge was hurt? He missed the playoffs that year. Therefore, he's not a hall of famer if his career ends today. Right?