What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

In this thread I rank my favorite post-Beatles Beatles songs: 291-1. (4 Viewers)

Another one I really enjoyed, although by memory, I think I liked two of the lower (Binky higher)  ones better. For sure the last one.

This one is very sweet. Drifts into schmaltzy Paul, but doesn’t cross the threshold to over-schmaltzy.
 

OH’s “rant” describes Ringo perfectly. I brought it up in my Stones thread, that Charlie Watts is talked about in the same way. The Beatles and Stones will always be linked in music history and one of the many things they had in common was that their drummers were arguably the best musicians in the band (outside of Paul).
I'm glad you enjoyed this one!  It's outside the usual wheelhouse of many of us, but so well done.  I do have one more "very sweet" song from this record to come, though I think that one doesn't get into schmaltz.

I could get on-board with Ringo being the best musician outside of Paul in the Beatles.  I need to listen to more Stones with a focus on Watts.  Any songs in particular you'd recommend to get the best flavor for him (I know you did bring it up in your thread but remember nothing specifically)?

 
65.  John Lennon/Plastic Ono Band – Working Class Hero (John Lennon/Plastic Ono Band, 1970)  Spotify  YouTube

(John #14)

This song took me down a weird rabbit hole when I learned that the station manager of Georgetown-affiliated college radio station WGTB had been threatened with up to a year in prison for playing it unedited, since the song uses the “f” word in a couple of spots.  His response was, “The People of Washington DC are sophisticated enough to accept the occasional four-letter word in context, and not become sexually aroused, offended, or upset,” and the charges were eventually dropped.  But WGTB itself has an absolutely fascinating history, which you can read about in this terribly long article if interested.  

Back to the song!  It’s a folk song of revolutionary bent, just John and his acoustic guitar targeting the class system with criticism of everything from the military to big business to his own upbringing and the striving to become middle class:  “I think it’s a revolutionary song... I think it’s for the people like me who are working class, who are supposed to be processed into the middle classes, or into the machinery. It’s my experience, and I hope it’s just a warning to people...”

John said he wasn’t directly influenced by Bob Dylan in writing this song. Suuuuuuuurrrrrrrrre.

I’m not going to put a lot of my own interpretation onto these lyrics as I’d rather everyone hear it and consider it themselves.  What I love most about the song is the lyrics, though – I think this is one of John’s most effective political statements, delivered with an appropriate amount of anger and sorrow rather than the sugar-coating of “Imagine,” for instance.  I believe that the lyrics are generally sarcastic, and in particular the outro “just follow me” part, based on a related statement from John:  “That’s the choice they allow you – now the outlet is being a pop star, which is really what I’m saying on the song. It’s the same people who have the power, the class system didn’t change one little bit.”

As soon as you're born, they make you feel small
By giving you no time instead of it all
Till the pain is so big you feel nothing at all

A working class hero is something to be
A working class hero is something to be

They hurt you at home, and they hit you at school
They hate you if you're clever, and they despise a fool
Till you're so ####### crazy, you can't follow their rules


A working class hero is something to be
A working class hero is something to be

When they've tortured and scared you for twenty-odd years
Then they expect you to pick a career
When you can't really function, you're so full of fear

A working class hero is something to be
A working class hero is something to be

Keep you doped with religion and sex and TV
And you think you're so clever and classless and free
But you're still ####### peasants as far as I can see


A working class hero is something to be
A working class hero is something to be

There's room at the top they are telling you still
But first you must learn how to smile as you kill
If you want to be like the folks on the hill

A working class hero is something to be
A working class hero is something to be

If you want to be a hero well just follow me
If you want to be a hero well just follow me


&

UP NEXT:  A song inspired by Charlie Chaplin…

 
Last edited by a moderator:
65.  John Lennon/Plastic Ono Band – Working Class Hero (John Lennon/Plastic Ono Band, 1970)  Spotify  YouTube

(John #14)

I’m not going to put a lot of my own interpretation onto these lyrics as I’d rather everyone hear it and consider it themselves.  What I love most about the song is the lyrics, though – I think this is one of John’s most effective political statements, delivered with an appropriate amount of anger and sorrow rather than the sugar-coating of “Imagine,” for instance.  I believe that the lyrics are generally sarcastic, and in particular the outro “just follow me” part, based on a related statement from John:  “That’s the choice they allow you – now the outlet is being a pop star, which is really what I’m saying on the song. It’s the same people who have the power, the class system didn’t change one little bit.”
This is my fifth favorite song on POB - which means that I LOVE it.  :)  And agree the lyrics are especially good.  Only problem I ever had with the song is that I find a few lines to be a bit arrogant - notably the "just follow me" one you noted.  I like your interpretation though - will need to reflect more on that.  When I discovered this album I was at that rebellious period in my life (which is not to say that I was particularly rebellious).  A few years later I recall scrawling some of these lyrics along with a few lines from a Joe Jackson song on a bathroom wall in a half-a$$ed protest of some BS power nonsense the management of the local supermarket was pulling on us teenager part-timers.  Yeah, that was my way of standing up to the man (no pun intended Joe Jackson): anonymously scrawling lyrics to a 20 year old song on the bathroom wall at the local supermarket. FIGHT THE POWER!  

 
This is my fifth favorite song on POB - which means that I LOVE it.  :)  And agree the lyrics are especially good.  Only problem I ever had with the song is that I find a few lines to be a bit arrogant - notably the "just follow me" one you noted.  I like your interpretation though - will need to reflect more on that.  When I discovered this album I was at that rebellious period in my life (which is not to say that I was particularly rebellious).  A few years later I recall scrawling some of these lyrics along with a few lines from a Joe Jackson song on a bathroom wall in a half-a$$ed protest of some BS power nonsense the management of the local supermarket was pulling on us teenager part-timers.  Yeah, that was my way of standing up to the man (no pun intended Joe Jackson): anonymously scrawling lyrics to a 20 year old song on the bathroom wall at the local supermarket. FIGHT THE POWER!  
:lmao:   This.  Is.  Amazing.  Love that story so hard.

I guess this is my fifth favorite as it appears I still have four more to go.  I think we have differences, though, in that I'm pretty sure you had "Mother" lower than this based on a prior post.  I still have that one, "I Found Out," "God," and "Isolation."  Unless I'm missing something, which is possible.

 
:lmao:   This.  Is.  Amazing.  Love that story so hard.

I guess this is my fifth favorite as it appears I still have four more to go.  I think we have differences, though, in that I'm pretty sure you had "Mother" lower than this based on a prior post.  I still have that one, "I Found Out," "God," and "Isolation."  Unless I'm missing something, which is possible.
Ok, I think I need to come clean: while I DO have a Paul 100, I never did get around to formally ranking my John top 25.  I have a list of 35 Lennon songs and will do that tomorrow night as it's just the focused distraction I need to avoid getting sucked into 8 hours of political nonsense.  And not sure what I might have said about Mother to suggest it would be below Working Class Hero, but I can assure you it won't be.  And yes, the others are most definitely the 3 you listed.

On a totally different subject: was glad to see Sing the Changes, so I assume you are done with Electric Arguments, right?  So may I ask what happened to Sun is Shining?  It's in my top 50, so just curious if it was ever in contention for you?

 
On a totally different subject: was glad to see Sing the Changes, so I assume you are done with Electric Arguments, right?  So may I ask what happened to Sun is Shining?  It's in my top 50, so just curious if it was ever in contention for you?
Definitely in contention and made it through two rounds of cuts.  My best note on that:  "Best nah-nah-nahs since Hey Jude." :)  

 
Oh yes, Chaos is one of my top 5 McCartney albums
Right, I know you have seven still on your list despite my only having three still to go.  Figured you'd love this one.  My other two are on your list, too.

You owe some updates on your rankings, for my notes!

 
Definitely in contention and made it through two rounds of cuts.  My best note on that:  "Best nah-nah-nahs since Hey Jude." :)  
Excellent.  the nah nah parts are some of my favorite parts of the song.  and that's saying alot as I like the atmospheric quality of the made-up-on-the-spot lyrics

 
On a totally different subject: was glad to see Sing the Changes, so I assume you are done with Electric Arguments, right?  So may I ask what happened to Sun is Shining?  It's in my top 50, so just curious if it was ever in contention for you?
Definitely in contention and made it through two rounds of cuts.  My best note on that:  "Best nah-nah-nahs since Hey Jude." :)  
To this point, probably my "top 290" isn't a pure reflection of my top 290.  There was some culling based on wanting representation of stuff that might be different or interesting, instead of just re-treading all the songs from a single album.  So when it came to Electric Arguments or Chaos and Creation, for instance, probably a marginal song or two would lose out to having a diversity instead.  SO SUE ME.  :)  

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Right, I know you have seven still on your list despite my only having three still to go.  Figured you'd love this one.  My other two are on your list, too.

You owe some updates on your rankings, for my notes!
Yep, will update your bingo card tomorrow.  You've hit several - not surprising given how high up in your rankings you are - but only Sing the Changes was terribly high.  The others were all in the 60s or lower I believe.  

Also, I believe the lyrics of that song are about his devil wife...back when he believed her BS stories.  

 
To this point, probably my "top 290" isn't a pure reflection of my top 290.  There was some culling based on wanting representation of stuff that might be different or interesting, instead of just re-treading all the songs from a single album.  So when it came to Electric Arguments or Chaos and Creation, for instance, probably a marginal song or two would lose out to having a diversity instead.  SO SUE ME.  :)  
Fair enough...my lawyers will be in touch.  Will you be defending yourself or obtaining competent counsel? 

 
Also, question in case things go sideways tomorrow night: any idea how long one's second suspension would be if they JUST finished serving their first suspension after being a member in very good standing for 20 years?  asking for a friend ;)

and also letting you know in case I am silent for an extended period of time

 
Also, question in case things go sideways tomorrow night: any idea how long one's second suspension would be if they JUST finished serving their first suspension after being a member in very good standing for 20 years?  asking for a friend ;)

and also letting you know in case I am silent for an extended period of time
Please don't.  When did you have a suspension? Who are you?

 
Please don't.  When did you have a suspension? Who are you?
Was put on a two-day suspension this past weekend for a poorly worded remark within a lengthy post that was thoughtful and well-received except by those looking to be offended and to take the worst possible interpretation.  Mods aren't fooling around, which I totally understand given the heightened anxiety and the high-level of civility Joe is looking for here.  Was mainly kidding in my post above as I was quite embarrassed to have received it and took me a few minutes to process what I might have said that was seen as so controversial. Anyway, didn't mean to get political, was mainly mocking myself for my poorly worded post.  As you well know by now, I don't review/edit/spellcheck my posts before hitting submit, so was probably bound to happen.  In any case, back to the post-Fab Four...

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Was put on a two-day suspension this past weekend for a poorly worded remark within a lengthy post that was thoughtful and well-received except by those looking to be offended and to take the worst possible interpretation.  Mods aren't fooling around, which I totally understand given the heightened anxiety and the high-level of civility Joe is looking for here.  Was mainly kidding in my post above as I was quite embarrassed to have received it and took me a few minutes to process what I might have said that was seen as so controversial. Anyway, didn't mean to get political, was mainly mocking myself for my poorly worded post.  As you well know by now, I don't review/edit/spellcheck my posts before hitting submit, so was probably bound to happen.  In any case, back to the post-Fab Four...
Dude, my first (of three) suspensions was because I referenced phone sex, and my second was because I used the ol' FFA trope "sleep with his ______".  I don't care about those, but right now there's no accounting for anything, when good posters are banned and trolls are allowed to run rampant.  What I'm saying is you should feel zero embarrassment.

Btw, my third was when I told a poster to GFY and was well aware I'd be suspended, and it was worth it.  ;)  

 
I have three from Red Rose Speedway

we already discussed Big Barn Bed, and I do have the one-that-shall-not-be-named (sorry Pip, but rest assured it isn't very high on my list), and I have one more that is #35 on my list.  
I have one remaining that just came up on my Spotify mix as I was posting, so it made me think of that.  Not sure we'll have the same one, but I'm hopeful!

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Dude, my first (of three) suspensions was because I referenced phone sex, and my second was because I used the ol' FFA trope "sleep with his ______".  I don't care about those, but right now there's no accounting for anything, when good posters are banned and trolls are allowed to run rampant.  What I'm saying is you should feel zero embarrassment.

Btw, my third was when I told a poster to GFY and was well aware I'd be suspended, and it was worth it.  ;)  
Thanks.  Am trying to be a good citizen and feel bad for the mods these days.  That PSF is a cesspool of trolls with a few interesting perspectives and alot of good links from the handful that are will to criticize their own side (a rarity but necessary).

As for your third suspension, my wife many years ago complained to me that she wished she was clever and could come up with witty ways to put someone in their place and I informed her that "clever is nice, but a well-timed GFY works very well 100% of the time"

 
A few years later I recall scrawling some of these lyrics along with a few lines from a Joe Jackson song on a bathroom wall in a half-a$$ed protest of some BS power nonsense the management of the local supermarket was pulling on us teenager part-timers.  Yeah, that was my way of standing up to the man (no pun intended Joe Jackson): anonymously scrawling lyrics to a 20 year old song on the bathroom wall at the local supermarket. FIGHT THE POWER!  
Though my problems are meaningless
That don't make them go away

&

 
To this point, probably my "top 290" isn't a pure reflection of my top 290.  There was some culling based on wanting representation of stuff that might be different or interesting, instead of just re-treading all the songs from a single album.  So when it came to Electric Arguments or Chaos and Creation, for instance, probably a marginal song or two would lose out to having a diversity instead.  SO SUE ME.  :)  
Or you could have satisfied the OCD of me (and possibly others) and made it a top 300. 🤔

 
I have three from Red Rose Speedway

we already discussed Big Barn Bed, and I do have the one-that-shall-not-be-named (sorry Pip, but rest assured it isn't very high on my list), and I have one more that is #35 on my list.  
Don't ever ask me why
I never say goodbye to my love
It's understood
It's everywhere with my love
My love does it good

&

 
Maybe I'll do that supplemental 10 when I hit the top 50.  As long as it doesn't delay my rankings enough to put us past the release of McCartney III:lol:  

ETA:  I do have a list of "last ones out" similar to the NCAA tourney stuff.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Maybe I'll do that supplemental 10 when I hit the top 50.  As long as it doesn't delay my rankings enough to put us past the release of McCartney III:lol:  
I'm sure Paul will text you a heads-up so you'll know your target date to finish by. 😆

I did a supplemental 103 for the Neil list, so a supplemental 10 should be cake. 😆😆

 
I'm sure Paul will text you a heads-up so you'll know your target date to finish by. 😆

I did a supplemental 103 for the Neil list, so a supplemental 10 should be cake. 😆😆
He did text me a couple of days ago with a video of him carving a pumpkin.

Listening to my Paul mix right now:  "shake it don't break it!"

I have a good idea of at least half of those supplemental songs.

 
George and John have been creeping up on Paul.  Starting with 141 Paul, 71 George, and 49 John, they've come proportionately much closer with now 27 Paul, 21 George, and 13 John remaining.  Will one of them overtake Paul in the final rankings?  WATCH THIS SPACE.

All right, that's dumb.  But still, I find it interesting.  Paul certainly is most prolific in my favorite songs, but the gap is narrowing.

 
krista4 said:
George and John have been creeping up on Paul.  Starting with 141 Paul, 71 George, and 49 John, they've come proportionately much closer with now 27 Paul, 21 George, and 13 John remaining.  Will one of them overtake Paul in the final rankings?  WATCH THIS SPACE.

All right, that's dumb.  But still, I find it interesting.  Paul certainly is most prolific in my favorite songs, but the gap is narrowing.
Paul has the advantage of such a huge catalogue, but he also put out a ton of good music - some of which apparently after I had given up on him.

 
67.  The Fireman - Sing The Changes (Electric Arguments, 2008)  Spotify  YouTube

(Paul #29)

One of the pleasures of this countdown for me has been talking about Paul's work with Youth as the irritatingly-named group, The Fireman, and this is my favorite song off my favorite record from their collaboration.  It's just a big stadium anthem the words to which Paul improvised as a stream of consciousness, but it sounds euphoric and is hypnotizing to me with its full, warm sound awash in all that reverb.  Since I didn't have a listening party for this album with OH, I played him this song later because I was so excited about it.  He made a barfing gesture and compared it to Imagine Dragons.  Can't win 'em all.

UP NEXT:  One of Paul's best songs...  
If in 1980 you told the bass player for Killing Joke that one day he'd be working with Paul McCartney, what kind of reaction would you have gotten? 😆

I totally see the U2 comparison. To me it sounds even more like The Alarm, who by the mid-80s had evolved into a "big-sounding" band that borrowed heavily from U2 and Springsteen. (Fun fact I mentioned in the Neil thread: They were the first major artist to cover Rockin' in the Free World.) 

I guess I can see the Imagine Dragons comparison, though I don't know much about them. What I have heard from them suggests to me that they are diluted Coldplay, which is diluted U2. 

Anyway, unlike OH, I am totally on board with anthemic arena rock when it's done well, and it's done well here. 

 
krista4 said:
66.  Beautiful Night (Flaming Pie, 1997)  Spotify  YouTube

(Paul #28)

I might have made a “mistake” here, because I think this song is perfectly composed, arranged, and performed, so I kept moving it up the ranks.  However, I don’t enjoy it personally as much as the last several below it, and since these are my “favorites,” I should have posted it earlier.  This isn’t scientific.  :(  

Anyway, this song is freaking gorgeous, and there is nothing about it I can criticize; it’s simply not a style of song I enjoy as much as others.  Paul got the band back together for this one, with both George Martin and Ringo making contributions that elevate the song enormously, and Geoff Emerick doing an excellent job of engineering as well.  The melody of this song is so strong that it doesn’t get weighed down by Martin’s heavy – but tasteful and appropriate – orchestration.  My favorite part of the song is when you think it’s going to fade out like a typical ballad, but then suddenly it speeds up and reprises musical ideas from the bridge and the chorus.

And there’s Ringo, just holding it all together in such a loving way.  On songs like this and “In My Life,” that is the word that always comes to me for Ringo’s performance – loving.  This song was actually 10+ years old, but Paul had never been satisfied with any previous recordings of it.  Having just worked with Ringo again on “Real Love” and “Free As A Bird,” Paul asked him to work on a few songs on Flaming Pie, and he even ordered an exact replica of the drum kit Ringo had used on those songs to be delivered for the recording sessions.  I’ve read several accounts from various people at the sessions, including both Paul and Ringo, regarding how lovely they were working together.  One directive from Paul is to listen to the “daft stuff” at the very end:  “l think everyone who makes a record has that option, to leave the daft stuff on at the end. You nearly always fade it out but at the end of ‘Beautiful Night’, it had been such a good take that Ringo started having fun, acting like he was a doorman, throwing people out. I love that so much. lt’s very Beatley. lt’s a very Beatley idea to do that, because we did a bit of that in the group… Beautiful Night actually sounds a bit Beatley too… ln fact, I swear that at the end of Beautiful Night, you can almost hear a sort of very John Lennony voice in there. Listen to it. Check it out.”  Yessir.

Yesterday(?) I referenced the sequencing of Flaming Pie, which I think is outstanding.  This is the penultimate song on the record, which might seem where some people would end the album, but instead, immediately after this huge, grand song, Paul had "Great Day," which you'll remember as a simple, acoustic bit that sounds like a "porch song."  Not only is that a perfect way to follow the musicality here, but I even love the titles, as a "beautiful night" is followed by a "great day."

Even OH was a fan of this song:  “Listen to Ringo go.  Yeah, I like that song a lot.  It’s not my kind of music, obviously, but it’s clearly the kind of music they want to make when they get together, and they did it very very well.  I generally abhor arena rock, I don’t like taking in music in those situations, but that’s how you make arena rock, right there.  That’s big in all the right ways.  All that other stuff, like the horns that came in, it all seemed appropriate, not like an ad hoc decision.  And the drumming at the end was as good as Ringo’s drumming in the Abbey Road medley.  If you don’t have a super-strong drummer…everything he does is so musical and embedded in the song, fully in service of what’s being played.  He’s the perfect player.  When you first start a band, everybody wants to show off or have a thing where they stand out, but it seems like the more talented you are, the more likely you are to want to do that, but what every band needs is somebody who just hits on the one and the three and shuts the #### up.  He just never does more than he should, ever.  I can’t believe Ringo is the most personable one of the Beatles.  I’ve never met a drummer who wasn’t a ####### weirdo.  There’s something about thinking in rhythms or patterns or whatever that does something weird to their brains.  But Ringo’s just like, ‘Hey, want a pint?’”

UP NEXT:  WGTB, one nation underground...
Not as big a mistake as me putting a 1974 song in my 1975 countdown. 😆

In lesser hands this would be irritating, possibly awful. But Paul and co knock it out of the park. Imagine if he had stuff like this in 1983-88 instead of the dreck we got. This is up there with his very best stuff. 

 
krista4 said:
65.  John Lennon/Plastic Ono Band – Working Class Hero (John Lennon/Plastic Ono Band, 1970)  Spotify  YouTube

(John #14)

This song took me down a weird rabbit hole when I learned that the station manager of Georgetown-affiliated college radio station WGTB had been threatened with up to a year in prison for playing it unedited, since the song uses the “f” word in a couple of spots.  His response was, “The People of Washington DC are sophisticated enough to accept the occasional four-letter word in context, and not become sexually aroused, offended, or upset,” and the charges were eventually dropped.  But WGTB itself has an absolutely fascinating history, which you can read about in this terribly long article if interested.  

Back to the song!  It’s a folk song of revolutionary bent, just John and his acoustic guitar targeting the class system with criticism of everything from the military to big business to his own upbringing and the striving to become middle class:  “I think it’s a revolutionary song... I think it’s for the people like me who are working class, who are supposed to be processed into the middle classes, or into the machinery. It’s my experience, and I hope it’s just a warning to people...”

John said he wasn’t directly influenced by Bob Dylan in writing this song. Suuuuuuuurrrrrrrrre.

I’m not going to put a lot of my own interpretation onto these lyrics as I’d rather everyone hear it and consider it themselves.  What I love most about the song is the lyrics, though – I think this is one of John’s most effective political statements, delivered with an appropriate amount of anger and sorrow rather than the sugar-coating of “Imagine,” for instance.  I believe that the lyrics are generally sarcastic, and in particular the outro “just follow me” part, based on a related statement from John:  “That’s the choice they allow you – now the outlet is being a pop star, which is really what I’m saying on the song. It’s the same people who have the power, the class system didn’t change one little bit.”

As soon as you're born, they make you feel small
By giving you no time instead of it all
Till the pain is so big you feel nothing at all

A working class hero is something to be
A working class hero is something to be

They hurt you at home, and they hit you at school
They hate you if you're clever, and they despise a fool
Till you're so ####### crazy, you can't follow their rules


A working class hero is something to be
A working class hero is something to be

When they've tortured and scared you for twenty-odd years
Then they expect you to pick a career
When you can't really function, you're so full of fear

A working class hero is something to be
A working class hero is something to be

Keep you doped with religion and sex and TV
And you think you're so clever and classless and free
But you're still ####### peasants as far as I can see


A working class hero is something to be
A working class hero is something to be

There's room at the top they are telling you still
But first you must learn how to smile as you kill
If you want to be like the folks on the hill

A working class hero is something to be
A working class hero is something to be

If you want to be a hero well just follow me
If you want to be a hero well just follow me


&

UP NEXT:  A song inspired by Charlie Chaplin…
As you may or may not remember, this was the highest-drafted (Binky and Simey: lowest-drafted) solo Beatles song in the Beatles/solo Beatles draft I did that I mentioned at the end of the Beatles countdown thread.

This is indeed John doing Dylan. However, this kind of thing would have been easy to phone in, and he didn't. His vocal is astounding in the way it conveys despair and anger without ever getting mopey. The lyrics have been analyzed squillions of times over so I don't need to pontificate there. 

 
Last edited by a moderator:
As you may or may not remember, this was the highest-drafted (Binky and Simey: lowest-drafted) solo Beatles song in the Beatles/solo Beatles draft I did that I mentioned at the end of the Beatles countdown thread.

This is indeed John doing Dylan. However, this kind of thing would have been easy to phone in, and he didn't. His vocal is astounding in the way it conveys despair and anger without ever getting mopey. The lyrics have been analyzed squillions of times over so I don't need to pontificate there. 
100% agree with the bold.  

I didn't recall this had been drafted so high (or low).  I'm surprised, though I can't argue it's not worthy.

 
64.  Too Much Rain (Chaos And Creation In The Backyard, 2005)  Spotify  YouTube

(Paul #27)

This is another song that just kept moving up up up my rankings.  I don’t know how many times I’ve started to write it up, then begun to play it for analysis and thought, “Damn, this is too good to be posted yet.”  The reason I have so often thought it should be “lower” is what I think are kinda corny lyrics.  But maybe they aren’t…in fact, they were inspired by Charlie Chaplin’s* 1936 song, “Smile,” the instrumental from Modern Times to which lyrics had been added in the 1950s: “Smile, though your heart is aching; Smile, even though it’s breaking...”  The song might have been written to cheer up worst-wife-ever Heather.  Let’s allow Paul to clear this up:  “The actual inspiration…is Charlie Chaplin’s song Smile. Which he wrote: not many people know he wrote it, you normally think of him as a comedian, but I was always amazed to hear he’d written that you know, beautiful song. Good old Charlie wrote it. I think it was for a film, you know Modern Times, or something was it? It’s a great song and the idea of Smile even though your heart is breaking, Smile when your heart is breaking do do. That’s a nick, a direct pinch from that so it’s ‘Laugh when your eyes are burning  Smile when you’re doing this and Sigh when  you’re that’.. So it was really that it was hints for feeling horrible, you know when you’re really down this song could get you up. You know remind you as the Smile song does to just sort of push through it, feel good and it’ll be alright…and you know I’m never that specific I would never say that’s exactly what it’s about and it then widens out and it’s for everyone who’s had just too much in their lives to cope with. And that applies to an awful lot of people. But that was it, it was really just a sort of helpful song.” 

There we go.  Maybe a little less weed before that next interview, Sir Paul.  In any case, it’s a freaking great song.  The structure of it is amazing, with each line melding into the next by coming in just a tad early, giving the song a strong sense of anticipation and “build” that is then resolved through that strong, major-key chorus.  The bass line conversation with the strong piano part is phenomenal.  I love the tiniest touches of this song, like the piano “responses” to the lyrics, or especially that one point ~2:11 where the guitar plays one line of the melody while the vocal is silent.  The abrupt ending is terrific, too.  This is a song where I feel like I notice something new and exciting each time I listen to it, so I’m willing to overlook some hokey lyrics.

Even OH liked this one…I think?:  “I liked that song a lot.  It was very hopeful and sad.  But mostly hopeful.  It seemed like something happened to him.  Like, he lost his wife and now has this crazy person to take care of who is probably going to ruin him.”

*Didn’t write the lyrics, which came 18 years later from Geoffrey Parson and John Turner, who adapted the instrumental into a full-fledged song.**

**Also didn’t really write the instrumental composition itself, which was penned primarily by composer David Raksin.

UP NEXT:  Ringo, John, and George were made honorary members…

 
69.  John Lennon and Yoko Ono – Beautiful Boy (Darling Boy) (Double Fantasy, 1980)  Spotify  YouTube

(John #15)

Beautiful lullaby.  John could do sweet and tender well, as evidenced by “Oh My Love” and this song, which he wrote for Sean.  John hadn’t been much involved in Julian’s upbringing, through a combination of being on the road and lacking in interest or knowledge of how to parent, but he had made a decision that this would be different with Sean.  He took five years off of the music business to be a househusband and heavily participate in bringing Sean up:  “The joy is still there when I see Sean. He didn’t come out of my belly but, by God, I made his bones, because I’ve attended to every meal, and to how he sleeps, and to the fact that he swims like a fish. That’s because I took him to the ‘Y’. I took him to the ocean. I’m so proud of those things.  He is my biggest pride, you see.”

In addition to the lovely lyrics (including the well-known “Life is what happens to you while you’re busy making other plans” line), the production on this song is a highlight, as it sounds so full and warm.  The steel drum seems like an odd touch that wouldn’t work, but somehow it does.  I love the spoken word part at the end:  “Good night Sean.  See you in the morning.  Bright and early.”  This song is a favorite of both Paul and Yoko.  I think if I had kids, I might find it even more wonderful and meaningful.

I mentioned Timothée Chalamet because in 2018 he starred in an overlooked gem of a movie with Steve Carell and Amy Ryan called Beautiful Boy (and the song does feature in the movie).  I’ve never dealt with anyone who suffered from a drug addiction, but if you have, you might find it even more compelling and poignant.  So I wanted to give a little shout-out to that movie and to Chalamet specifically, who I think is the best actor in a couple of generations. 

John songs on the countdown that begin with a Tibetan prayer bell (running total):  1

UP NEXT:  a song with “menace”…
playing catchup again.

a generational song for me, though i still cant help but regret its result. i knew hippies raising their kids to be "free" was gonna be a mess, but i really respected Lennon putting his career away and purposefully raising a son after ignoring the first one. it spoke to his evolution and possibly a hope for the future, though i still fear it's the wrong approach to fatherhood

i fathered a son who will be 50yo next week and was prevented from having anything to do with him (his mother was "married off" before she started to show and, as far as i know, my son still believes his stepfather is his natural dad). the summer before this record came out, i visited my auntie (who NEVER kept a secret except mine) and she told me that Patty and little Stefano were visiting her parents two doors down (how i met the young lady who had cruelly twisted my world). i wandered down when i heard noise in their yard and was introduced to my 9yo son (i'd seen him in passing a coupla times). got close enough to pat him on the head and i can still feel the shape of his skull in my hand forty+ years later. my palm would then fairly glow, as the meteorology of melancholy stormed my heart, at each hearing of this paean when Double Fantasy came out that fall. my beautiful boy chops stolen cars for the mob in his three garages on the South Shore (aah, family tradition!) of Boston. Happy 50th, Stevie...................................................

68.  You Want Her Too (Flowers In The Dirt, 1989)  Spotify  YouTube

(Paul #30)

I love how bizarre this song is, from the off-kilter circus sound (in waltz time!) in the intro, to its re-use and then the sudden appearance of a big-band sound in the outro.  Plus, of course, it features two of my favorite singers both sounding in great voice - Paul in particular really kills the vocal here.   Each song at this point is one that I love, so choosing something to be "up next" is ridiculously difficult, but the reason I chose this one now is a small quibble I have with the song:  Costello sound too menacing for my taste.  The two of them wrote the song in what Paul described as similar to some of his writing with John, where they would shoot sharp lines back and forth at each other, and I think that process made the song sound kind of...angry?  There's an unpleasantness that makes me dock it slightly.  Compare and contrast the softer approach by Costello in the original demo - I believe this style of vocals in the final product would have launched this up my Paul list by 15+ spots.

Paul wasn't originally satisfied with this song and tried to re-record it performing both vocal parts himself, but he decided it didn't work and reinserted Costello's part.  Even if I think Costello's performance is somewhat too snarly, I suspect that was a good choice by Paul, as it seems like it would have sounded strange to have him singing both parts back-and-forth to himself.  

Though a different Flowers In The Dirt song made OH's Paul top five, he was also a huge fan of this one (sorry, this might not have been my best transcription):  "Love the way it begins and ends.  If Elvis Costello had recorded by himself, he could have emphasized the necessary parts – the lyrics, obviously, the drums, because it really swings, which it’s a song about why can’t I say I love her, torn, and therefore rocks very hard, and the organ – those little flourishes that come in and out.  Starts in major key and ends in minor, with circus-y stuff.  Could have been 70s dubplate or early 80s electronic…I could see Beastie Boys making a whole record of that.  Really love it."

UP NEXT:  another Paul collaboration...
I think i would have enjoyed Paul singing an album of his favorite EC songs more than the collaboration. i hear a deference for each Costello flourish and the half-measure results are very frustrating to listen to

krista4 said:
66.  Beautiful Night (Flaming Pie, 1997)  Spotify  YouTube

(Paul #28)

I might have made a “mistake” here, because I think this song is perfectly composed, arranged, and performed, so I kept moving it up the ranks.  However, I don’t enjoy it personally as much as the last several below it, and since these are my “favorites,” I should have posted it earlier.  This isn’t scientific.  :(  

Anyway, this song is freaking gorgeous, and there is nothing about it I can criticize; it’s simply not a style of song I enjoy as much as others.  Paul got the band back together for this one, with both George Martin and Ringo making contributions that elevate the song enormously, and Geoff Emerick doing an excellent job of engineering as well.  The melody of this song is so strong that it doesn’t get weighed down by Martin’s heavy – but tasteful and appropriate – orchestration.  My favorite part of the song is when you think it’s going to fade out like a typical ballad, but then suddenly it speeds up and reprises musical ideas from the bridge and the chorus.

And there’s Ringo, just holding it all together in such a loving way.  On songs like this and “In My Life,” that is the word that always comes to me for Ringo’s performance – loving.  This song was actually 10+ years old, but Paul had never been satisfied with any previous recordings of it.  Having just worked with Ringo again on “Real Love” and “Free As A Bird,” Paul asked him to work on a few songs on Flaming Pie, and he even ordered an exact replica of the drum kit Ringo had used on those songs to be delivered for the recording sessions.  I’ve read several accounts from various people at the sessions, including both Paul and Ringo, regarding how lovely they were working together.  One directive from Paul is to listen to the “daft stuff” at the very end:  “l think everyone who makes a record has that option, to leave the daft stuff on at the end. You nearly always fade it out but at the end of ‘Beautiful Night’, it had been such a good take that Ringo started having fun, acting like he was a doorman, throwing people out. I love that so much. lt’s very Beatley. lt’s a very Beatley idea to do that, because we did a bit of that in the group… Beautiful Night actually sounds a bit Beatley too… ln fact, I swear that at the end of Beautiful Night, you can almost hear a sort of very John Lennony voice in there. Listen to it. Check it out.”  Yessir.

Yesterday(?) I referenced the sequencing of Flaming Pie, which I think is outstanding.  This is the penultimate song on the record, which might seem where some people would end the album, but instead, immediately after this huge, grand song, Paul had "Great Day," which you'll remember as a simple, acoustic bit that sounds like a "porch song."  Not only is that a perfect way to follow the musicality here, but I even love the titles, as a "beautiful night" is followed by a "great day."

Even OH was a fan of this song:  “Listen to Ringo go.  Yeah, I like that song a lot.  It’s not my kind of music, obviously, but it’s clearly the kind of music they want to make when they get together, and they did it very very well.  I generally abhor arena rock, I don’t like taking in music in those situations, but that’s how you make arena rock, right there.  That’s big in all the right ways.  All that other stuff, like the horns that came in, it all seemed appropriate, not like an ad hoc decision.  And the drumming at the end was as good as Ringo’s drumming in the Abbey Road medley.  If you don’t have a super-strong drummer…everything he does is so musical and embedded in the song, fully in service of what’s being played.  He’s the perfect player.  When you first start a band, everybody wants to show off or have a thing where they stand out, but it seems like the more talented you are, the more likely you are to want to do that, but what every band needs is somebody who just hits on the one and the three and shuts the #### up.  He just never does more than he should, ever.  I can’t believe Ringo is the most personable one of the Beatles.  I’ve never met a drummer who wasn’t a ####### weirdo.  There’s something about thinking in rhythms or patterns or whatever that does something weird to their brains.  But Ringo’s just like, ‘Hey, want a pint?’”

UP NEXT:  WGTB, one nation underground...
see what a little intentionality gets you?!?! first listen, BIG fan

two things advanced my music mgmt career - suggesting "tour pharmacies" for my acts and my ability (w the help of my childhood friend and "bodyguard" Wayne) to find vanished drummers in strange towns. there's a connection between Ringo's personal groundedness and his drummeral groundedness and they are equally miraculous

 
Last edited by a moderator:

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top