What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Is Guns N' Roses a top 10 US band all-time? (1 Viewer)

Yes or No

  • Yes

    Votes: 47 28.5%
  • No

    Votes: 109 66.1%
  • Shuked

    Votes: 9 5.5%

  • Total voters
    165
Oh

yes

you

are

For every one you put put up as drek I can put up 10. All bands have lame songs and putting them up is cherry picking from a massively successful catalog.
Sorry mate, I find just about everything Aerosmith released from the late 80s forward to be pretty terrible.  To be honest, I never really dug into old Aerosmith either, so maybe I'm missing out?  I don't like "Back in the Saddle" and I burned out on "Sweet Emotion" and "Dream On" in high school.  What should I target as a rediscovery?

 
Just hearing their cover of Knocking On Heaven's Door should be enough to end any top 10 talk.

Possibly the worst cover in rock history.  :X

 
Mr. Mojo said:
Just hearing their cover of Knocking On Heaven's Door should be enough to end any top 10 talk.

Possibly the worst cover in rock history.  :X
Disagree.  Live and Let Die is worse.

 
yeah, I hear you.  I'm stuck driving a 2004 car with a busted CD changer and when I'm not listening to sports or NPR, I turn to the FM dials and scroll through the stations.  Hard to believe that classic rock is STILL "Getting the LED out".

I listen to Pandora or Spotify at home or when I'm walking where I can thumbs down an overplayed classic.  Pretty awesome feature.
On Amazon, you can get a FM transmitter that plugs into a cigarette lighter and will allow you to play your phone (or IPOD) through an FM channel. That's what I use now for music and and it's only about $20.

 
Mr. Mojo said:
Just hearing their cover of Knocking On Heaven's Door should be enough to end any top 10 talk.

Possibly the worst cover in rock history.  :X
I submit Eddie Vedder's god-awful, caterwauling "Last Kiss" as a worthy opponent to your choice. Who thought that was a good idea?

 
On Amazon, you can get a FM transmitter that plugs into a cigarette lighter and will allow you to play your phone (or IPOD) through an FM channel. That's what I use now for music and and it's only about $20.
I had that with my iPod and the sound quality sucked, but this was 8 years ago....imagine it's gotten better?  Have you tried one of these?

 
I submit Eddie Vedder's god-awful, caterwauling "Last Kiss" as a worthy opponent to your choice. Who thought that was a good idea?
Pearl Jam fan is very quick to defend that one as some sort of schtick song that took off because radio fans are unwashed.  Suuuuuuuuurrrrrrrrrrre.....

 
Pearl Jam fan is very quick to defend that one as some sort of schtick song that took off because radio fans are unwashed.  Suuuuuuuuurrrrrrrrrrre.....
:shrug:  Was recorded to be part of a charity album, and sent as the fan club single.  Some radio station started to play it and it took off.

The fact that it is the only Pearl Jam song to hit top ten in Billboards Hot 100 seems to support this.  It's a pop song, and Pearl Jam generally doesn't make pop songs.

When it was released as a single the bands proceeds were donated to charity.  I have a great idea, let's rip Pearl Jam for this one.  :rolleyes:

 
:shrug:  Was recorded to be part of a charity album, and sent as the fan club single.  Some radio station started to play it and it took off.

The fact that it is the only Pearl Jam song to hit top ten in Billboards Hot 100 seems to support this.  It's a pop song, and Pearl Jam generally doesn't make pop songs.

When it was released as a single the bands proceeds were donated to charity.  I have a great idea, let's rip Pearl Jam for this one.  :rolleyes:
I'm not denigrating them for their charity work - all props to them and I hope that raised a billion dollars.

But that is just a horrible performance. Not a good match of song and performer. 

 
I had that with my iPod and the sound quality sucked, but this was 8 years ago....imagine it's gotten better?  Have you tried one of these?
I have an old vehicle, too, GM - one that doesn't have bluetooth. I got one of the devices described above. It sounds just like the regular radio through my car speakers to me, though my ears have long been wrecked. But I'd rather have bad sound (if that's really the case) and good, diverse music than have to listen to commercial FM, no matter how good that it may sound

 
I'm not denigrating them for their charity work - all props to them and I hope that raised a billion dollars.

But that is just a horrible performance. Not a good match of song and performer. 
It was recorded as a sound check.  It wasn't a song in their regular rotation, they had played it four times over the previous six months on their tour (never before).  If you want to knock them for the performance, expectations need to be realistic.

If you don't like the match of song to band, that's your personal taste.  Many PJ fans enjoy the fact they never know what they might get at a concert, unlike many rock bands that play the same 10-15 songs every night.  Some things hit, and some don't.  I actually like their take and find it interesting when bands go out of their comfort zone.

These GnR covers are just rock bands covering rock songs and failing to do so.

 
General Malaise said:
I had that with my iPod and the sound quality sucked, but this was 8 years ago....imagine it's gotten better?  Have you tried one of these?
I use one now. It's decent as long as you select the right FM channel. You have to get one that is wide open without any other stations next to it. I didn't buy the absolute cheapest one but I didn't get the most expensive one either. Just read the reviews and they will help guide you to a decent one.

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top