Is this colusion? (1 Viewer)

[hotboyz]

Owner A trades Braylon edwars,Portis and Cowboys def to owner B for Bush,Greg Jennings and Chargers D

So now Owner B will have Torry holt,Fitzgerald,S.Moss and Braylon Edwards and rb Ronnie Brown, Clinton Portis and Shaun Alexander with Warner and Brees at QB

Owner A will have Garrard and Pennington at QB Sammy Morris Reggie bush and Rudi Johnson at rb with Chad johnson wes welker shaun Mcdonald and Greg jennings at wr

This trade seems very lopsided Team A is 2-3 and struggling team B is 3-2 and has won 3 games in a row. These two guys work together I think this smells of colusion what do you guys think would you let this trade go thru

 

[thebestupsman]

looks fair to me

 

[mad sweeney]

Owner A trades Braylon edwars,Portis and Cowboys def to owner B for Bush,Greg Jennings and Chargers DSo now Owner B will have Torry holt,Fitzgerald,S.Moss and Braylon Edwards and rb Ronnie Brown, Clinton Portis and Shaun Alexander with Warner and Brees at QBOwner A will have Garrard and Pennington at QB Sammy Morris Reggie bush and Rudi Johnson at rb with Chad johnson wes welker shaun Mcdonald and Greg jennings at wrThis trade seems very lopsided Team A is 2-3 and struggling team B is 3-2 and has won 3 games in a row. These two guys work together I think this smells of colusion what do you guys think would you let this trade go thru

Who else is on their team doesn't matter. Perfectly fine trade. One team making out better than the other doesn;t make it collusion.

 

[cobalt_27]

Owner A trades Braylon edwars,Portis and Cowboys def to owner B for Bush,Greg Jennings and Chargers D

So now Owner B will have Torry holt,Fitzgerald,S.Moss and Braylon Edwards and rb Ronnie Brown, Clinton Portis and Shaun Alexander with Warner and Brees at QB

Owner A will have Garrard and Pennington at QB Sammy Morris Reggie bush and Rudi Johnson at rb with Chad johnson wes welker shaun Mcdonald and Greg jennings at wr

This trade seems very lopsided Team A is 2-3 and struggling team B is 3-2 and has won 3 games in a row. These two guys work together I think this smells of colusion what do you guys think would you let this trade go thru

Even if it were spelled colusion with one "L" you'd need to build a case that Owner B was tanking by somehow nabbing, arguably, the better RB and DST options.And, I don't think you'd have much of a case.

 

[daveR]

I'm beginning to think we should relegate collusion threads to the Assistant Coach forum.

 

[bradf35]

I'm beginning to think we should relegate collusion threads to the Assistant Coach forum.

 

[rotorooter]

fair.

bush over portis

edwards over jennings

dal and sd pretty even

 

[BusterTBronco]

This trade seems very lopsided Team A is 2-3 and struggling team B is 3-2 and has won 3 games in a row. These two guys work together I think this smells of colusion what do you guys think would you let this trade go thru

Boo hoo hoo. Are these two bad guys working together?

 

[hotboyz]

How can you guys not see how lopsided this trade is for 1 we don't have ppr portis has outscored bush by about 45 pts in my league and Edwards averages about 4.5 more pts a game than Jennings and Edwars is a #1 wr on a team who has to pass so he loses 45 pts at rb 20 pts at wr and gains 4 pts at def/st and this is fair??

 

[Neil Beaufort Zod]

This is ridiculously lopsided. It's clear that owner __ is getting a sweet deal while owner __ is getting garbage. They're obviously colluding to give owner __ an unfair advantage. You can't sit by and let that happen.

(After looking at the trade for a while, I can't figure out which team is supposedly getting an advantage. Just fill in the letters you like and move forward. Thanks.)

 

[Clayton Gray]

How can you guys not see how lopsided this trade is for 1 we don't have ppr portis has outscored bush by about 45 pts in my league and Edwards averages about 4.5 more pts a game than Jennings and Edwars is a #1 wr on a team who has to pass so he loses 45 pts at rb 20 pts at wr and gains 4 pts at def/st and this is fair??

Umm, unless your league has a rule where players are required to continue scoring at the same pace for the remainder of the season, this is a fair trade.Also, I agree with the people above that this really isn't SP material.