What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.

J.Russell or T.Edwards?...Dynasty League (1 Viewer)

Who is worth more in a Dynasty league?

  • JaMarcus Russell

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Trent Edwards

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    0
Well tuttiface, if you chose Edwards you are soon to be a rich man.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
tough one, I would lean edwards, he seems to be the better passer. Russell has the tools, except his accuracy is horrendous. He can throw the ball far, on one knee,YADYADAYADA......if only he could get the ball in his receivers hands.

 
Russell looks like he's one of those guys that could have a potential weight problem. Plus the Raiders are a mess. My $100 would be on Edwards.

 
How do you know when you win? Who has the most fantasy points this season? Next season? This season and next season combined? I'm not sure that I understand the question.

 
its 75/25 right now, it's almost the same percentage as your Office deal last night :kicksrock: (note the dude sticking out his tongue)

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Edwards has better coaching, better offensive system, better receivers, equal running game, and though he has a weaker arm than Russell, he is much, much smarter and more accurate.

ETA: also Edwards, like Russell, is on a very young team that's likely to be together for 4-5 years (as long as the resign Lee Evans). The Bills are much further along than the Raiders though.

Edwards is the sure bet here.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
How do you know when you win? Who has the most fantasy points this season? Next season? This season and next season combined? I'm not sure that I understand the question.
The bet is related to this poll. So it's solely based on the poll you already voted on (hopefully) :mellow:We're just wondering on who you would take for your Dynasty team if you were to do a draft TODAY.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Edwards maybe short term

Russell maybe long term

You guys should make the BET FANTASY POINTS PER YEAR OR APG.

the Russell owner might just win with Russels scrambling abilty and qb sneaks he loves to do at goal line and the fact Oakland gets a lot of mop up yardage and td's! I JUST LOOKED for you on my MFL league I was on and though all leagues score qb's a little different Edwards only has a 4.2 point lead after 4 games.

STAY TUNED! Russell actually has a chance to pull this out even though Edwards is in the far better offense and far better situation to suceed.

tHEY ARE THE 12 AND 13TH BEST QB IN THE LEAGUE i JUST CHECKED!

Since you bet on this poll only the Russell owner is screwed. FBG sharks have a screwed mind! I voted Russell and in fact would put $$$ on Russell winning most fantasy points this year and in a lifetime! Better weather will help Russell win too in long run! Lots of reasons I can think of!

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Edwards maybe short termRussell maybe long termYou guys should make the BET FANTASY POINTS PER YEAR OR APG. the Russell owner might just win with Russels scrambling abilty and qb sneaks he loves to do at goal line and the fact Oakland gets a lot of mop up yardage and td's! I JUST LOOKED for you on my MFL league I was on and though all leagues score qb's a little different Edwards only has a 4.2 point lead after 4 games. STAY TUNED! Russell actually has a chance to pull this out even though Edwards is in the far better offense and far better situation to suceed. tHEY ARE THE 12 AND 13TH BEST QB IN THE LEAGUE i JUST CHECKED!Since you bet on this poll only the Russell owner is screwed. FBG sharks have a screwed mind! I voted Russell and in fact would put $$$ on Russell winning most fantasy points this year and in a lifetime! Better weather will help Russell win too in long run! Lots of reasons I can think of!
I love your enthusiasm! Good job posting! Although I disagree with it completely!
 
Edwards maybe short term

Russell maybe long term

You guys should make the BET FANTASY POINTS PER YEAR OR APG.

the Russell owner might just win with Russels scrambling abilty and qb sneaks he loves to do at goal line and the fact Oakland gets a lot of mop up yardage and td's! I JUST LOOKED for you on my MFL league I was on and though all leagues score qb's a little different Edwards only has a 4.2 point lead after 4 games.

STAY TUNED! Russell actually has a chance to pull this out even though Edwards is in the far better offense and far better situation to suceed.

tHEY ARE THE 12 AND 13TH BEST QB IN THE LEAGUE i JUST CHECKED!

Since you bet on this poll only the Russell owner is screwed. FBG sharks have a screwed mind! I voted Russell and in fact would put $$$ on Russell winning most fantasy points this year and in a lifetime! Better weather will help Russell win too in long run! Lots of reasons I can think of!
wat?
 
Edwards is probably the best young QB in football, IMO (Cutler included). Might take another year or two before he's a big-time FF producer (Hardy needs to develop), but I believe Edwards is eventually going to be a perennial top-5 QB.

 
How do you know when you win? Who has the most fantasy points this season? Next season? This season and next season combined? I'm not sure that I understand the question.
The bet is related to this poll. So it's solely based on the poll you already voted on (hopefully) :mellow:We're just wondering on who you would take for your Dynasty team if you were to do a draft TODAY.
Is this about race or is it a simple, benign, one vs. one, who's better question? Because I think it's a thinly veiled race-card pullin turd.I voted for Edwards.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
How do you know when you win? Who has the most fantasy points this season? Next season? This season and next season combined? I'm not sure that I understand the question.
The bet is related to this poll. So it's solely based on the poll you already voted on (hopefully) :tinfoilhat:We're just wondering on who you would take for your Dynasty team if you were to do a draft TODAY.
Is this about race or is it a simple, benign, one vs. one, who's better question? Because I think it's a thinly veiled race-card pullin turd.I voted for Edwards.
simple, one vs one. Who do you take if you were drafting a Dynasty team today? Who will have a better career in regards to fantasy points? Who is a more valuable QB? talent/situation/durability/etc...
 
With all of the advantages that most list for Edwards, wouldnt you expect there to be a sizeable advantange in the statistics?

Russell has the same number of TD passes in fewer attempts with bad recievers. He also has less interceptions and 1 more rushing TD than Edwards. IMO Russell has the higher ceiling of the two.

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top