JMatt or Sterling Shepard (1 Viewer)

[Matt's Eagles]

Who would you take? And what is difference between them? PPR dynasty?

 

[fruity pebbles]

Very close, very similar in that their value has taken a bit of a hit due to signings. Id still take Jordan, think he has more upside.

 

[Gally]

Shepard started out looking like he was going to be a solid contributer but really slumped as the year went along.  I think neither is anything more than a WR3/4 based on the current rosters.  I think I would lean towards Mathews because I don't think Torrey Smith will cut too much into Mathews load as much as Marshall will hurt Shepard.  

 

[Matt's Eagles]

Offer was

Team A gets J Matthews, plus 3 4th rounders

Team B gets Shepard, pick 2.2, 3.2

 

[Warhogs]

It's close enough for me that I would take Shepard and get another really good rookie at 2.2

 

[Gally]

I probably lean towards the Shepard side because of the pick bonus. 

 

[squistion]

Offer was

Team A gets J Matthews, plus 3 4th rounders

Team B gets Shepard, pick 2.2, 3.2

4th rounders are superfluous. 3.02 adds some value but not much, so...

This is essentially Shepard and the 2.02 or Matthews...

Shepard's short term value killed by Marshall, don't see Matthews negatively impacted much by Jeffery or Smith.

If you are not looking beyond 2018, go with Marshall unless you think you can get a difference maker at 2.02 - if so then go with Shepard.