Keep A. Luck or C. Davis? (1 Viewer)

[TedyBruschi]

12 team 0.5 PPR

6 points per passing TD

Can retain:

A. Luck in 9th round

C. Davis 10th round

I will also be keeping L. Bell in the first round - 9th overall pick. 

Thoughts?  QBs go early in my league - but I think Davis is better value.  Both have injury concerns. 

Thanks!

 

[fightingillini]

You can always get a QB.  I would keep Davis.  I am not convinced that Luck will ever be his old self.

 

[snoochieboochies]

Davis. You can always try and grab Luck in the draft. Davis would be much harder to reacquire. 

 

[beerbuff]

Luck is still fairly cheap in most drafts, that will change over time as I expect him to move up if he stays healthy. Right now I'd keep Davis but that could change as time goes by.

 

[Avery]

Even though you get 6pts for TD, I just don't see the value in keeping a QB so I'd keep Davis if you don't have any better options.

Could you give your thoughts on my keeper league question?  Thanks! 

 

[msudaisy26]

Luck is still fairly cheap in most drafts, that will change over time as I expect him to move up if he stays healthy. Right now I'd keep Davis but that could change as time goes by.

I like this thought process if your draft is soon. Davis costs more than Luck right now. If Luck passes him by time you have to declare or draft then switch. 

 

[Gally]

Even though you get 6pts for TD, I just don't see the value in keeping a QB so I'd keep Davis if you don't have any better options.

Could you give your thoughts on my keeper league question?  Thanks! 

The 6 pts per TD for QB's is not really a factor in almost all cases.  The only thing that does is minimize the value of running QB's with respect to other QB's.  It doesn't make QB's more valuable because they all get increases in pts so in relative value to each other they stay the same.