Keep Gurley, Mixon, or Chubb (1 Viewer)

[Bc380]

Can only keep one of these RBs. I’m torn between Gurley and Mixon.

Gurley Mixon or Chubb

League is a PPR Format. Have to keep 1.  No rd value or auction $ in this equation.  I will have the option to keep whoever I select for 2020 season as well, but not any further. 

Thanks in advance for the insight.

 

[curvelo13]

With 2020 being an option also. I would keep Chubb over Mixon. Gurley is questionable cause of his injury.

 

[beerbuff]

Mixon is actually the safest bet. Gurley is shaky with his arthritis and Chubb will have Kareem Hunt to deal with later in the year and maybe next year.

 

[Gally]

I would go with Chubb.  I don't see Hunt as a threat to his value and I don't trust Gurley's knee.  Mixon's O-line is in trouble. 

 

[travdogg]

I'd keep Mixon. he's got the least competition for touches, and the best track record health wise. Not worried about his o-line too much(its didn't stop him last year) and the PPR format hurts Chubb.

Gurley is somewhat tempting(more than Chubb in my eyes) but too much uncertainty. 

The more I think about this, I think Mixon is actually both the best call this year, and next.

 

[BucksFan02]

I prefer Mixon of the 3.  I would go with Gurley but the way last year ended, and his injury unknowns, I'm just not sure on him.   Chubb could be great as well but I am just worried about Hunt cutting into the workload when he's back from suspension.   Overall I have less concerns about Mixon this year, and I believe he's going to have a big year. 

 

[fightingillini]

I prefer Mixon, but it's close over Chubb.  I don't trust Gurley.

 

[Jayded]

Mixon > Chubb > Gurley

Slight lean to Mixon for two reasons: Chubb has both Hunt & Johnson around. Mixon just added a coach who'll lean on him more than the previous regime. It's close, but he's who I'd favor.

WOuld appreciate thoughts: https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/777626-keeper-startup-who-to-draft-next/