Keeper Advice - Possibly the Hardest Choice Ever (1 Viewer)

[Clifton]

Points league H2H - Pretty standard scoring except K's are not penalized, saves are worth 10 and IPs go for a whole point. I ended up overloaded from my sick drafting skills over the years. I can keep 8 guys and 15 next year. Trading is allowed and I could package two or 3 guys up and go after someone but I'm pretty loaded. Hate to throw so many studs back into the pool. I've only listed guys who are possible keepers here. Oh we can also start more than one player per position. Just looking for some feedback.

1B

R. Howard

2B

Kinsler

A Ramirez

SS

H Ramirez

3B

Longoria

OF/U

R Braun

J Hamilton

B Upton

Ellsbury

McLouth

M Kemp

J Bruce

SP

Hamels

Webb

Lester

CL

Nathan

Lidge

As of now I am leaning towards:

Howard

Hanley

Kinsler

Braun

Hamilton

Upton

Hamels

Webb

Dropping Longoria doesn't feel right. I would have been able to let go of Upton but he just showed too much in the playoffs.

Please Advice

Will answer your provided you link it in your response

 

[The Ghost of Common]

d00d. Where tf you been?

 

[Clifton]

d00d. Where tf you been?

Any input Frank?

 

[Oh Yes!]

Howard

Hanley

Kinsler

Braun

Hamilton

Upton

Hamels

Webb or Longoria id go with longoria

 

[Bobcat10]

Braun isn't in your original listing in the OF. Does he replace somebody there or he should just be added to that group?

Assuming he's on your team:

Howard

Kinsler

Hanley

Longoria

Braun

Hamilton

Upton

Hamels

Not sure how many batters you start, but your lineup is virtually done. That's a good thing as now you'll just draft alot of pitching with hitters mixed in here and there.

 

[Clifton]

Braun isn't in your original listing in the OF. Does he replace somebody there or he should just be added to that group?Assuming he's on your team:HowardKinslerHanleyLongoriaBraunHamiltonUptonHamelsNot sure how many batters you start, but your lineup is virtually done. That's a good thing as now you'll just draft alot of pitching with hitters mixed in here and there.

Yes I left Braun out. I could take things a step further and keep no pitching and hang onto the Cuban Missile or Matt Kemp.

 

[Oh Yes!]

Braun isn't in your original listing in the OF. Does he replace somebody there or he should just be added to that group?Assuming he's on your team:HowardKinslerHanleyLongoriaBraunHamiltonUptonHamelsNot sure how many batters you start, but your lineup is virtually done. That's a good thing as now you'll just draft alot of pitching with hitters mixed in here and there.

Yes I left Braun out. I could take things a step further and keep no pitching and hang onto the Cuban Missile or Matt Kemp.

nope

 

[Wrigley]

not to be rude, but how many teams are in this league?.........I only ask because you have an all-star team.

here is who I would keep

Howard

Kinsler

Hanley

Longoria

Braun

Hamilton

Upton

Hamels

 

[Clifton]

not to be rude, but how many teams are in this league?.........I only ask because you have an all-star team.here is who I would keepHowardKinslerHanleyLongoriaBraunHamiltonUptonHamels

10 Team keeper league. We kept 3 after the first season and we keep 8 after last year and we'll keep 15 next year. I drafted very well the past couple years. Those are only the guys I chose to post as potential keepers.Thanks for the advice

 

[pettifogger]

Points league H2H - Pretty standard scoring except K's are not penalized, saves are worth 10 and IPs go for a whole point. I ended up overloaded from my sick drafting skills over the years. I can keep 8 guys and 15 next year. Trading is allowed and I could package two or 3 guys up and go after someone but I'm pretty loaded. Hate to throw so many studs back into the pool. I've only listed guys who are possible keepers here. Oh we can also start more than one player per position. Just looking for some feedback.

1B

R. Howard

2B

Kinsler

A Ramirez

SS

H Ramirez

3B

Longoria

OF/U

R Braun

J Hamilton

B Upton

Ellsbury

McLouth

M Kemp

J Bruce

SP

Hamels

Webb

Lester

CL

Nathan

Lidge

As of now I am leaning towards:

Howard

Hanley

Kinsler

Braun

Hamilton

Upton

Hamels

Webb

Dropping Longoria doesn't feel right. I would have been able to let go of Upton but he just showed too much in the playoffs.

Please Advice

Will answer your provided you link it in your response

My picks, to me the hardest choice was Longoria vs. Upton.