Keeper advice (1 Viewer)

[Truebluey]

12 team home league ppr.
1qb, 1 rb, 2 wr, 1 rb/wr, 1 felx, 1 te
6 pts all tds

Should I keep Zay Flowers for 8th Rd pick

Or

Anthony Richardson for 10th round pick?

 

[BassNBrew]

12 team home league ppr.
1qb, 1 rb, 2 wr, 1 rb/wr, 1 felx, 1 te
6 pts all tds

Should I keep Zay Flowers for 8th Rd pick

Or

Anthony Richardson for 10th round pick?

Flowers ADP 53, Richardson 57

I think that Richardson ADP is bumped by 4 pt pass TD leagues and hype. Give me Stroud, Love, Burrow, Dak, Murray 2-4 rounds later anyway.

 

[Jaruby]

Richardson and it’s not even close in this format.

 

[Gally]

Richardson and it’s not even close in this format.

That format actually lowers Richardson's value because he doesn't get a boost for rushing TD's and with the injury risk coupled with no rushing TD benefit he drops quite a bit in the rankings for me.

I am not a particular fan of Flowers but depending on how many QB's are normally kept I would likely still keep Flowers in this format.

 

[Jaruby]

Richardson and it’s not even close in this format.

That format actually lowers Richardson's value because he doesn't get a boost for rushing TD's and with the injury risk coupled with no rushing TD benefit he drops quite a bit in the rankings for me.

I am not a particular fan of Flowers but depending on how many QB's are normally kept I would likely still keep Flowers in this format.

I would not keep Flowers for an 8th. No chance. Richardson for a 10th has value. You are basing your value on his health. Can’t play scared.

Richardsons value does not go down in this format other players like Goff value rises. That’s not the same thing.

 

[Gally]

Richardsons value does not go down in this format other players like Goff value rises. That’s not the same thing.

I lower QB's that have an advantage for rushing TD's but are lower for passing TD's in 6 pt all TD scoring. By moving up guys like Goff/Burrow/Stroud/etc by definition guys like Kyler/Richardson/Lamar/Hurts move down. Their big advantage is 6 pt for a rushing TD vs 4 pt passing TD. That goes away so their value goes down. It is the same thing.

QB's get compared to QB's not really other positions so the value most definitely goes down for rushing TD QB's and pocket passers with higher passing TD's value goes up

You are basing your value on his health. Can’t play scared.

Not playing scared at all. Injury is a factor when evaluating a player and settling on a ranking. It's a piece of the puzzle just like everything else. I am not saying it is a huge piece of the puzzle but it is pertinent.

 

[Jaruby]

Richardsons value does not go down in this format other players like Goff value rises. That’s not the same thing.

I lower QB's that have an advantage for rushing TD's but are lower for passing TD's in 6 pt all TD scoring. By moving up guys like Goff/Burrow/Stroud/etc by definition guys like Kyler/Richardson/Lamar/Hurts move down. Their big advantage is 6 pt for a rushing TD vs 4 pt passing TD. That goes away so their value goes down. It is the same thing.

QB's get compared to QB's not really other positions so the value most definitely goes down for rushing TD QB's and pocket passers with higher passing TD's value goes up

You are basing your value on his health. Can’t play scared.

Not playing scared at all. Injury is a factor when evaluating a player and settling on a ranking. It's a piece of the puzzle just like everything else. I am not saying it is a huge piece of the puzzle but it is pertinent.

Agree to disagree. But back to the posters question….

There is no way he should keep Flowers for ann 8th over Richardson for a 10th.