Keeper Decision (Mahomes, Gurley, McCaffrey) (1 Viewer)

[Huntsman]

Need to decide by tonight 7PM EST but can't make up my mind!

TD+Performance scoring system, no PPR.

I can only keep ONE franchise player of these three: Mahomes, Gurley, McCaffrey (yes, I kicked butt last season... also had Kelce and D.Adams, lol).

I am leaning heavily toward McCaffrey so please either confirm or refute! Thanks, I'll do yours

 

[jmble]

The only thing that concerns me with McCaffrey in non-ppr is that the Panthers have said that they plan on not using him in as many goal line situations this year.  Having said that, the same reports I read pretty much said that's BS.  I'm not down on him at all in a ppr league, but it's just something to think about.  I'd still probably keep him over the other two.  Not that it wouldn't be great to have Mahomes as well.

 

[Huntsman]

Thanks for the input. It's hard to toss Mahomes back into the mix knowing his potential and that I'll have to play against him (he will go before my pick) OTOH, I'm a big RB guy and feel like I need to secure a solid #1. Tough decision...

 

[Gally]

CMC is the easy choice.  Consensus top 3 player in any format.  Take him and enjoy.