Keeper Help - Struggling! (1 Viewer)

[OrchidsOfAsia]

Really having a tough time choosing my Keeper in a .5 PPR. A. St. Brown in the 4th, or Kenneth Walker in the 10th. I'm picking 10th in a 12-Team 1 Keeper league. I want to keep the best player (A-RSB), but the value save with Walker in the 10 is really making it tough. Need advice!

 

[Gally]

It's not tough. Keep the best player. If it is a keep one or two player it is much better to just keep the best player almost regardless of value. One guy is not enough to make a huge difference either way. I only really go to the "value" if the players are so close that the value swings it one way or the other. This comes down to how you feel about Walker. If you have ASRB as a clear superior player then go that way. Don't bank on "value". Its one player. Take the best guy.

 

[Chemical X]

It's not tough. Keep the best player. If it is a keep one or two player it is much better to just keep the best player almost regardless of value. One guy is not enough to make a huge difference either way. I only really go to the "value" if the players are so close that the value swings it one way or the other. This comes down to how you feel about Walker. If you have ASRB as a clear superior player then go that way. Don't bank on "value". Its one player. Take the best guy.

i agree here........take the lion.

 

[Rubi]

The Egyptian God for me and not close AT ALL

 

[jcb41]

Have you seen his jugs game?!?! Amon!!!!

 

[djjosee]

I'm all about value, but man I love St. Brown in the 4th.

 

[Nuttz4Football]

How long can you keep the player and will the round change next year. If you can keep forever and no change in round, then Amon, but if the round changes each year, then I would probably go Walker. Hate to give up the great talent, but truth is there are more WRs available than good RBs

 

[Keith R]

St. Brown in the 4th, not close. Walker could be in a 50/50 situation, despite great success last year. Go with the sure producer; it's worth the higher price.

Please grade these keepers

Non-PPR. Start 1 QB, 1 WR, 1 RB, 1 TE, 2 Flex (not SF), 1 K, 1 D/ST. 1 keeper per team, no player kept in 2023 can be kept in 2024. Sleeping Giants - Trevor Lawrence (8.06) Big Dogs - DeVonta Smith (7.10) Sunday Funnies - Kenneth Walker III (9.05) Mavericks - Odell Beckham Jr. (13.01) PPE -...

forums.footballguys.com