Keeper Help (1 Viewer)

[Alech44]

I need help deciding between these two options for keepers.

Both of these pics would occupy my first and second round. Here they are.

Mcaff/Gibbs
Mcaff/AJBrown

I think the first option would have me loaded at RB. But leave me a little short at wide receiver in the later rounds

 

[Pigskin Fanatic]

I might lean Gibbs in PPR, but in no-PPR and just in generall I would say Brown. Admittedly I'm a Eagles fan though and I own several Brown jerseys, so take this with a grain of salt lol.

Gibbs is being drafted at his ceiling imo and i think there is some risk there of him finishing in the top 10 RB list for the season. I happen to be a Montgomery believer and though I think Gibbs will absolutely get more touches this year than last, I just can't see Monty getting completely relegated. It's possible i guess. Brown is unquestionably in the top ten receivers category and belong in the first two rounds of the draft.

 

[Alech44]

I might lean Gibbs in PPR, but in no-PPR and just in generall I would say Brown. Admittedly I'm a Eagles fan though and I own several Brown jerseys, so take this with a grain of salt lol.

Gibbs is being drafted at his ceiling imo and i think there is some risk there of him finishing in the top 10 RB list for the season. I happen to be a Montgomery believer and though I think Gibbs will absolutely get more touches this year than last, I just can't see Monty getting completely relegated. It's possible i guess. Brown is unquestionably in the top ten receivers category and belong in the first two rounds of the draft.

It’s half ppr and yeah that’s where I’m at too. I think Gibbs is def a 2nd round pick and both Brown and Gibbs would be fine it’s just such a hard decision picking one.

 

[Gally]

What are your starting requirements? That may swing it one way or another for some people. For me I would just keep CMC and Brown. Gibbs with a slight hammy already just pushes it towards Brown for me.

 

[Alech44]

What are your starting requirements? That may swing it one way or another for some people. For me I would just keep CMC and Brown. Gibbs with a slight hammy already just pushes it towards Brown for me.

2 RB, 2WR and a flex. Thanks for the advice I’m slowly leaning away from Gibbs

 

[Jaruby]

CMC and Brown no question.

(I love Gibbs it’s nothing against him. You are getting 2 consensus 1st rd picks with cmc/brown).

Depending on where you pick you have a good shot at Gibbs or better. Odds are you’re not getting Brown.