Keeper question QB heavy league (1 Viewer)

[DBrown2134]

I am in a keeper league that gives QB's 1 point for every 10 yards passing, 6 points TD's, and also yardage bonuses. When a QB has a good week, he can score 60-75 points and on a bad week he can score between 25-35 points.  The running QB's aren't as appealing in this format but the QB's that put up large passing yardage numbers can win you a weekly matchup.  This is not a salary cap league and there is no penalty for a player being kept

In this format, does it make sense to keep Aaron Rodgers as one of my 4 keepers (along with Gurley, Tyreek HIll, and Travis Kelce) even though that doesnt align anywhere close with the current ADP or should I take the industry advice ans still wait on QB?  Other keeper options include Antonio Brown (he hates helmets), Aj Green (ughh), and Aaron Jones.  Guys that would be available would be Wentz, Ryan, Brees, Rivers, Brady types?  There is still time to trade Rodgers for an RB or WR but not sure what the best play is here. 

Any advice would be appreciated! Thanks!  

 

[Gally]

The scoring for QB's being elevated doesn't really change the relative value of the position.  It does move some guys up or down but overall the relative difference is similar.  You didn't mention there being any costs associated with keeping a player (round lost, salary cap, etc) so it is tough to compare options.

 

[DBrown2134]

Thanks for the help, I see your point.  I did forget to add that there isn't a cost associated with keeping a player.  Everyone keeps 4 with no penalty 

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

I’d keep Aaron Jones & roll the dice at QB. ARod is feeling like he’s a hit or two away from irrelevance as he ages. He turns 36 this year & doesn’t seem to bounce up off the ground like he once did. 

Not saying I’m predicting an injury, but the risk is there & you have a sightly better option in a top 10 RB in Jones.