Keepers (1 Viewer)

[kyrand]

I have the 10th pick in a league that your keeper is where you drafted them the previous year. Chase was drafted in the first round and Nabers was drafted in the third round. Which one would you keep? Leaning to Chase as he is the consensus #1 overall pick.

Thanks in advance!

 

[Gally]

With only one keeper I will generally keep the best guy. Having 10th pick makes it easier. Chase and it's not close.

 

[BLOCKED_PUNT]

what a crazy thing to say, Gally.

 

[Gally]

what a crazy thing to say, Gally.

Thanks. i am a wild and crazy guy


ETA: In a serious comment, i see many people in one keeper leagues worry so much about value that they tend to go away from the best player and go with the best value. I think that is a bad decision. One guy isn't going to make or break you no matter what. Which is why I typically just go with the best player regardless of value. In this particular case say the guy had first pick. That means you can get Chase (if you wanted him anyway) so might as well keep someone else. But barring this case just keep the best guy.

 

[kyrand]

what a crazy thing to say, Gally.

Thanks. i am a wild and crazy guy


ETA: In a serious comment, i see many people in one keeper leagues worry so much about value that they tend to go away from the best player and go with the best value. I think that is a bad decision. One guy isn't going to make or break you no matter what. Which is why I typically just go with the best player regardless of value. In this particular case say the guy had first pick. That means you can get Chase (if you wanted him anyway) so might as well keep someone else. But barring this case just keep the best guy.

I should have also said that it is a 2 keeper league. My other keeper will be McBride in the 8th round. TBH, I was leaning to keeping Chase just wanted to get other opinions. Thanks!