What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Maclin and Charles for Kelvin Benjamin? (1 Viewer)

Nate Cousineau

Footballguy
Full ppr. 12 teams. 

QB Winston (bench palmer) 

WR Jordy, Maclin, Thomas (bench Shepard) 

RB Zek & J Rodgers (bench McKinnon J Charles and A Morris) 

TE Reed (bench brake and Bennett) 

FLEX (one of the bench guys) 

 
I think it's a good trade if you are only looking at the players involved... The thing that would give me pause is that you already don't have great depth at RB...Rodgers is probably going back to the bench at some point...and McKinnon has been terribly inconsistent.  On the other hand it's entirely possible Charles isn't start-worthy for the rest of the season..and keeping him around may never pay off  The good thing is that Zeke and Rodgers have already had their byes so if you can try and just ride those two the rest of the way (and hope that Doug Martin doesn't get healthy)... I guess I personally wouldn't do it unless i had at least one more solid RB on the bench.

Good luck!

 
I would do that in a heart beat.  I don't think Charles has anything left in the tank and is useless.  If you can get anything for him I would take it.  I would also try and pick up some RB depth (is Asiata available?  With McKinnon dinged he could be a nice higher floor guy) off the waivers or in a separate deal. 

 
I think it's a good trade if you are only looking at the players involved... The thing that would give me pause is that you already don't have great depth at RB...Rodgers is probably going back to the bench at some point...and McKinnon has been terribly inconsistent.  On the other hand it's entirely possible Charles isn't start-worthy for the rest of the season..and keeping him around may never pay off  The good thing is that Zeke and Rodgers have already had their byes so if you can try and just ride those two the rest of the way (and hope that Doug Martin doesn't get healthy)... I guess I personally wouldn't do it unless i had at least one more solid RB on the bench.

Good luck!




 
Thanks!

 
I would do that in a heart beat.  I don't think Charles has anything left in the tank and is useless.  If you can get anything for him I would take it.  I would also try and pick up some RB depth (is Asiata available?  With McKinnon dinged he could be a nice higher floor guy) off the waivers or in a separate deal. 




 
Yeah, this is kind of my thinking (although the other owner is now getting cold feet because of Charles). Asiata isn't available, unfortunately. 

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top