manny trade (1 Viewer)

[Bill]

i just got offered manny ramirez for

hunter pence and thome

10 team ML 5x5 H2H league

keep 6 players

pence has been lighting it up so far but will he keep it up??

is this a no brianer???

 

[Righetti]

if you are theo epstein.. DON"T DO IT

 

[E-A-G-L-E-S]

Thome will break soon again,, manny is due to catch fire ,

i would not do it

 

[NY/NJMFDIVER]

Wait, you are giving up Manny? Do this before this owner wakes up!!! Pence in that park the rest of the way, man, I'd think about it straight up, and you get Thome and its a keeper league! Lock it up!

 

[harryhood]

Wait, you are giving up Manny? Do this before this owner wakes up!!! Pence in that park the rest of the way, man, I'd think about it straight up, and you get Thome and its a keeper league! Lock it up!

i think he gives up pence and james to get Man-ram. I would hold tight with the pence side. Kid can flat out rake at the plate. He is one of the next "big" things

 

[NY/NJMFDIVER]

Wait, you are giving up Manny? Do this before this owner wakes up!!! Pence in that park the rest of the way, man, I'd think about it straight up, and you get Thome and its a keeper league! Lock it up!

i think he gives up pence and james to get Man-ram. I would hold tight with the pence side. Kid can flat out rake at the plate. He is one of the next "big" things

Most definately, why even entertain this?

 

[shuke]

What are you going to be get to fill your open roster spot if you are giving up 2 for 1? I think this has to part of the analysis.

 

[Bill]

i would be giving up pence and thome

to get-manny

but i am having 2nd thoughts on this.

its a 10 team ML H2H keep 6 players.

currently i'd be keeping:

utley

crawford

a ramirez

thome

konerko

then for my 6th a choice of:

pence--high upside

fran rodriquez-pitchers don't get much love in this league

uggla-not sure about him-has been a pleasnat surprise

so do i ship off thome and pence for manny ramirez

 

[Smack Tripper]

i would be giving up pence and thometo get-mannybut i am having 2nd thoughts on this.its a 10 team ML H2H keep 6 players.currently i'd be keeping:utleycrawforda ramirezthomekonerkothen for my 6th a choice ofence--high upsidefran rodriquez-pitchers don't get much love in this leagueuggla-not sure about him-has been a pleasnat surpriseso do i ship off thome and pence for manny ramirez

Absolutely not, Manny's on the downside of his career and Pence is going to be fun to watch in that park. Not sure I'd do it straight up, but you have to give up Thome too, who's kum-see,kum-saw to me, but still, you shouldn't even entertain the two guys. Manny for Thome sounds more right in my book.