Chaos Commish
Footballguy
nfl.com link
Things I like in the top 10.
Houston and Carriker in the top ten. I've been a fan of Houston all along, but a Nebraska fan had to sell me on Carriker. Since then Carriker has been steadily rising in my opinion. A week or so ago, I told Andy Carriker was a top 10 stud. He is DE1 in my rankings.
Things I don't like in the top 10.
I don't have Quinn in my top 10, but then I don't have him as the #2 QB either. I am the outlier on that one. I gave up criticizing Okoye long ago, but I still don't think he deserves this high of a rating (#10).
Things I like in the rest.
I like Ginn as the 2nd WR and pushing the top 10. He would be in mine along with PWillis, so I think Willis is too low. Man, Mayock has Beason ahead of Willis now.
I like Revis pushing the top 10 with Houston in it. They are the two elite CBs in this draft and Hall is properly ranked a healthy drop behind them. I drop Hall a bit further.
I like where he has Meriweather (20), but I think character issues kill him on draft day. Levi Brown seems about right to me. I don't get all the "real early" talk. He's got Reggie Nelson lower than most, which concurs with what I think I might have seen. Nelson is probably the toughest player for me to comfortably rank.
Things I don't like in the rest.
Willis, as mentioned, is too low.
I think Mayock, and just about everyone else, is way too low on the WRs. They are the quality of this class and it is a mediocre class at the other positions. Last year we had great depth at OL and they fell, but the entire class was very strong. Mostly, I'm just interested to see where the WRs are drafted at this point. If they fall they fall, but there's going to be some serious bargains. I give up any efforts to convince people how good they are. Jarrett as the 46th ranked player in the draft is silly to me.
Defensive lineman rank differently for different schemes, but we have extremely different rankings. Oddly, if he just scrunched them together more, I wouldn't be too bothered with different rankings. I sure don't see a huge drop off between Jarvis Moss and Tim Crowder. I could pick any of his top DEs and say the same about him and one of Mayock's bottom DEs. They are difficult to rank and quite similar so spreading them out so much doesn't work for me.
That's very little complaining for me, and as usual, I like Mayock's work and opinions more than anyone else's in the mainstream.
Things I like in the top 10.
Houston and Carriker in the top ten. I've been a fan of Houston all along, but a Nebraska fan had to sell me on Carriker. Since then Carriker has been steadily rising in my opinion. A week or so ago, I told Andy Carriker was a top 10 stud. He is DE1 in my rankings.
Things I don't like in the top 10.
I don't have Quinn in my top 10, but then I don't have him as the #2 QB either. I am the outlier on that one. I gave up criticizing Okoye long ago, but I still don't think he deserves this high of a rating (#10).
Things I like in the rest.
I like Ginn as the 2nd WR and pushing the top 10. He would be in mine along with PWillis, so I think Willis is too low. Man, Mayock has Beason ahead of Willis now.
I like Revis pushing the top 10 with Houston in it. They are the two elite CBs in this draft and Hall is properly ranked a healthy drop behind them. I drop Hall a bit further.
I like where he has Meriweather (20), but I think character issues kill him on draft day. Levi Brown seems about right to me. I don't get all the "real early" talk. He's got Reggie Nelson lower than most, which concurs with what I think I might have seen. Nelson is probably the toughest player for me to comfortably rank.
Things I don't like in the rest.
Willis, as mentioned, is too low.
I think Mayock, and just about everyone else, is way too low on the WRs. They are the quality of this class and it is a mediocre class at the other positions. Last year we had great depth at OL and they fell, but the entire class was very strong. Mostly, I'm just interested to see where the WRs are drafted at this point. If they fall they fall, but there's going to be some serious bargains. I give up any efforts to convince people how good they are. Jarrett as the 46th ranked player in the draft is silly to me.
Defensive lineman rank differently for different schemes, but we have extremely different rankings. Oddly, if he just scrunched them together more, I wouldn't be too bothered with different rankings. I sure don't see a huge drop off between Jarvis Moss and Tim Crowder. I could pick any of his top DEs and say the same about him and one of Mayock's bottom DEs. They are difficult to rank and quite similar so spreading them out so much doesn't work for me.
That's very little complaining for me, and as usual, I like Mayock's work and opinions more than anyone else's in the mainstream.
i don't get that at all.beason above willis raised an eyebrow too.
i don't get that at all.beason above willis raised an eyebrow too.
