McCaffrey Dynasty Value (1 Viewer)

[Gally]

I have pick 1.06 in a my dynasty league.  We keep 15 players on a salary cap with contracts.  McCaffrey is currently $10/2019.  He was the RB17 in our scoring system (non-PPR but 4 pt bonus at 50 yds rushing and/or 50 yds receiving) this year.  I may be able to trade 1.06 for him but I wonder if that is worth doing.  Will whoever I can get at 1.06 be just as good (or better) than McCaffrey.  The bonus for keeping the 1.06 is I will get that player for 3 yrs at $10 however they are completely unproven at the NFL level. 

Has McCaffrey shown enough to warrant giving up the extra year of contract control on whatever RB/WR that falls to be at pick 1.06? 

 

[Travieso]

Tough decision   If ppr I go cmc easy.   I think this is a slight lean to cmc due to the risk of the unknown at 1.6. Cmc already has a rb2 year in your league.  GL

 

[Gawain]

I'm starting to come around in him (perhaps clouded by that run and catch in the WC game).
We lose rounds for keeping guys and I'm starting to think that I'd prefer to lose a 2nd round pick for CMC than a 1st round pick for Fournette. (Fournette finished 8th in total points, CMC 12th in my non-ppr, PPG-Fournette 5th, CMC 14th)

I think I'd move the 1.06 for McCaffrey.

 

[Gally]

I'm starting to come around in him (perhaps clouded by that run and catch in the WC game).
We lose rounds for keeping guys and I'm starting to think that I'd prefer to lose a 2nd round pick for CMC than a 1st round pick for Fournette. (Fournette finished 8th in total points, CMC 12th in my non-ppr, PPG-Fournette 5th, CMC 14th)

I think I'd move the 1.06 for Fournette.

Did you mean McCaffrey here?  I don't have a chance at Fournette

 

[Gawain]

Did you mean McCaffrey here?  I don't have a chance at Fournette

I did. 1.06<McCaffrey