26.
Lady's Choice
Album: Most of the world: non-album A-side (1970); Canada: Canadian version of Fanny (1970)
Writers: Jean Millington and June Millington
Lead vocals: Jean Millington with June Millington
Lady's Choice was the first Fanny song released to the world. It was the A-side of the first of two non-album singles Reprise put out in 1970 in advance of the self-titled debut album. And it was a heck of an entrance.
The melodic guitar lines and smooth unison singing from the Millington sisters that open the song suggest that this is a "girl group" that happens to also play their own instruments, but the track soon reveals itself to be much more than that.
When Jean sings "I could CRY like a baby" about 1 minute in, the prettiness starts to turn grittier. The "I don't ever want to look in your eyes and find a mystery" part of the bridge suggests a sense of worry that wasn't there before, and the post-bridge vocals have an enunciation to them that recalls the intensity of Grace Slick. As with many Fanny songs, the best part is saved for the coda; starting at 2:05, Jean wails on vocals and June wails on guitar.
The single did not chart and was probably not heard or collected much back in the day, even by people who had some or all of the Fanny albums. Listeners in most of the world could not obtain it on album until the release of the First Time in a Long Time box set in 2002.
So what's with all that random detail in the "Album" field?
By accident, there are two versions of Fanny's self-titled debut album. The version released in the US and most of the rest of the world was completed in late 1970 and reflects what the label and the band wanted to be put out (even if the band didn't like Richard Perry's production on some tracks). But the version released in Canada was markedly different. Whoever was responsible for the release there used the wrong master tapes, which may have reflected an earlier version of the track list and running order.
The process of putting together the debut album occurred over various sessions across almost the entire 1970 calendar year, in part due to Nickey Barclay decamping for Joe Cocker's Mad Dogs and Englishmen tour for 3 months in the spring and her reticence about returning to the band after that. The difference in track listing, particularly the three Barclay credits on the Canadian version vs. the six on the "official" version, suggests that in exchange for returning, she extracted a promise to have more of her songs represented on the debut than was originally planned. (I have no idea if this is in fact the case.) The four songs of Barclay's that appear on the "official" version but not the Canadian version sound less like the material on the Canadian version (both the holdover songs and the replaced ones) and more gruff and rootsy. The songs on the Canadian version include the four songs, including Lady's Choice, that Reprise decided to release as the A- and B-sides of the aforementioned two non-album singles. The Canadian version is not on Spotify as an entity, though all its tracks appear on the box set, which is there. However, it can be found on YouTube as a single entity, though not on an official band or label channel:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GEoEbshO2Es&t=29s.
Here's how radical the differences between the two versions of the debut album were:
US (and everywhere else except Canada) version:
Side 1:
Come and Hold Me (Millington/Millington)
I Just Realized (Barclay/June Millington)
Candelighter Man (Millington/Millington)
Conversation with a Cop (Barclay)
Badge (Clapton/Harrison; Cream cover)
Side 2:
Changing Horses (Barclay)
Bitter Wine (Barclay)
Take a Message to the Captain (Barclay)
It Takes a Lot of Good Lovin' (Isbell/Jones; Judy Clay cover)
Shade Me (Barclay)
Seven Roads [First Version] (Millington/Millington/de Buhr)
Canadian version:
Side 1:
Charity Ball [First Version] (Millington/Millington/de Buhr)*
Place in the Country [First Version] (Barclay)*
Changes (June Millington)**
One Step at a Time (Armstead/Ashford/Simpson; Maxine Brown cover)***
Conversation with a Cop (Barclay)
Nowhere to Run (Holland/Dozier/Holland; Martha and the Vandellas cover)****
Side 2:
Seven Roads [Second Version] (Millington/Millington/de Buhr)
Take a Message to the Captain (Barclay)
Come and Hold Me (Millington/Millington)
Lady's Choice (Millington/Millington)*****
New Day (Millington/Millington)******
* - different versions were released the following year on Charity Ball
** - unreleased outside of Canada until the box set in 2002
*** - B-side of second US non-album single
**** - A-side of second US non-album single
***** - A-side of first US non-album single
****** - B-side of first US non-album single
If this song was ever played live, there is no surviving evidence of it.
At #25, Patti Quatro's best contribution to Fanny.