Mike Williams and Treadwell value (1 Viewer)

[brn0906]

10 team dynasty PPR. QB and OP slot. 3wr, 2 Rb, rb/wr, TE.

My team:

Qbs: Rodgers, BB, Mariota (we can only have 3...its stupid)

Rbs: Ware, Crowell, Martin, Woodhead, Kamara, Forte, C. Michael, Gallman

Wrs: OBJ, Evans, Cooper, Fitz, Mike Williams, Treadwell, Juju, Reynolds, Dorsett, Carroo

TEs: Rudolph, Njoku, Pitta, Allen
Looking to move a young receiver to some teams that are rebuilding for some more established players.

Was wondering what people are thinking about Mike Williams and Treadwell. I'm considering shopping Mike Williams and keeping Treadwell. My thoughts are that Treadwells value is so low because of his bad rookie season that I won't be able to get much for him without some hard selling. But, it seems like he is having a great off season, there are reports that he was never fully healthy last season, and that Mike Zimmer has a history of playing it slow with his rookies.

Mike Williams on the other hand landed in a crowded WR group and is already hurt and allegedly "falling behind." He is also likely to have a lot more value because he is a rookie and people love their shiny new toys.

One team in the league is pretty bad off but has Lesean McCoy and Dez.

Id appreciate anyone's thoughts or potential trades (or telling me to stay put and don't trade just to trade).

Thanks! 

 

[Gally]

You should always inquire about trades and look to find value.  I think you are correct regarding Treadwell.  I just don't see anyone giving up anything to get him and because of that there is probably more value to you to just keep him.

For Williams, you may find someone that really wanted him and would be willing to go after him but I don't think he would net you any piece that would make a difference for you this year.  Based on that I would hold tight because the best you could possibly due would be to roll a top 6 pick asset (Williams) for a mid first round pick next year.  That is essentially a wash so you might as well see if Williams is worthwhile.

I stay put unless someone dazzles me with an offer. 

 

[travdogg]

I think you have the right idea looking to deal some WR depth, I'd try to package a non big 3 WR with Doug Martin for a better RB. 

I like Mike Williams a ton, but your top-3 WRs are set for years to come. You probably aren't getting squat for Treadwell, but if somebody is willing to make a move, its always worth listening.