BespokeJort
Footballguy
In my dynasty league I proposed a trade that got accepted, where the other owner had to drop someone to get under the roster limit. He didn't do so within the waiting period (2 days), and the trade was rejected for this reason. I did post on the league board within an hour of the trade being accepted reminding the other owner that he had to drop someone, and he posted at the board after that. In any case, he didn't get it done, and the trade was nullified. In the meantime, I get another offer that's significantly better. The first guy still wants to do it. Am I obligated to reoffer the original trade?
On the one hand, the trade was agreed to before being nullified on a technicality, and thus still has value as an agreement between the two parties. On the other hand, if this were the NFL and you don't get the paperwork done, the other team would likely gleefully go the other way in this situation. I don't believe I've acted in bad faith, as I made every effort to remind the guy to get his roster under the limit. But now that it happened, part of me says that my only responsibility (in a pretty competitive league) is to better my team as much as possible within the rules.
Please vote and reply with any relevant reasoning.
On the one hand, the trade was agreed to before being nullified on a technicality, and thus still has value as an agreement between the two parties. On the other hand, if this were the NFL and you don't get the paperwork done, the other team would likely gleefully go the other way in this situation. I don't believe I've acted in bad faith, as I made every effort to remind the guy to get his roster under the limit. But now that it happened, part of me says that my only responsibility (in a pretty competitive league) is to better my team as much as possible within the rules.
Please vote and reply with any relevant reasoning.
Last edited by a moderator: