What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Most Overrated NFL Player Today (1 Viewer)

Brownsfan07

Footballguy
I say Tom Brady. It might be crazy, but belichick most likely cheated during tom's career, ruining it. Tom Brady without the cheater belichick, would not be in this category. i believe belichick cheated in all of those super bowl until sb 42.

 
I say Tom Brady. It might be crazy, but belichick most likely cheated during tom's career, ruining it. Tom Brady without the cheater belichick, would not be in this category. i believe belichick cheated in all of those super bowl until sb 42.
Have you watched him play? I say without him Belichick would suffer greatly.
 
I say Tom Brady. It might be crazy, but belichick most likely cheated during tom's career, ruining it. Tom Brady without the cheater belichick, would not be in this category. i believe belichick cheated in all of those super bowl until sb 42.
Have you watched him play? I say without him Belichick would suffer greatly.
again, belichick cheated for years. He was a sixth-round pick, and we all know how they usually play. I hate the patriots for cheating, and i still think he'd cheat. Tom Brady needs to get away from that cheater.
 
good insight here.

I kinda think Randy Moss is overrated. Call me crazy but the only reason Moss had 23 TDS last year is because of spygate. I also think Peyton Manning is overrated... By the way who is better Manning or Brady???

 
Offense - Chad JohnsonDefense - Darren Sharper
Ocho Sucko is a good pick as he usually has 2 big games a year and then a lot of hot air. But I gotta go Reggie Bush on offense, just eaking out a victory over Vince Young.For D, I'll go Roy Williams, DAL.
 
good insight here. I kinda think Randy Moss is overrated. Call me crazy but the only reason Moss had 23 TDS last year is because of spygate. I also think Peyton Manning is overrated... By the way who is better Manning or Brady???
Randy Moss= a hall of fame lock, but only if he gets a ringbased on rings - tom bradybased on actual performance and health - peyton manning
 
good insight here. I kinda think Randy Moss is overrated. Call me crazy but the only reason Moss had 23 TDS last year is because of spygate. I also think Peyton Manning is overrated... By the way who is better Manning or Brady???
Eli according to his SuperBowl win over Brady. :goodposting: :lmao: :D
 
good insight here. I kinda think Randy Moss is overrated. Call me crazy but the only reason Moss had 23 TDS last year is because of spygate. I also think Peyton Manning is overrated... By the way who is better Manning or Brady???
Eli according to his SuperBowl win over Brady. :popcorn: :) :)
Remember though? how the expert thought he was garbage?look what he did! Tom Brady was 3-0 in Super Bowls before losing to a manning. I thought this match, unlike what the point spread thought, was going to be extremely close. the giants win it on a heroic joe montana style drive by eli manning, who is in his mid 20's
 
Hmmm...... not sure.

The answer a couple years ago was Shaun Alexander .... but that's more than obvious now.

I'll go out on a limb and piss people off and say -

Marvin Harrison

he is definetly the benefactor of Manning more than vice-versa.

he does little after the catch and the way he just falls down is borderline pathetic.....

and the way he portrayed in the media as opposed to more bostrious WR's is horrible.... they make him seem like a great guy , but after meeting him a couple (once for a few hours) he is a grade one a- hole

 
Hmmm...... not sure.

The answer a couple years ago was Shaun Alexander .... but that's more than obvious now.

I'll go out on a limb and piss people off and say -

Marvin Harrison

he is definetly the benefactor of Manning more than vice-versa.

he does little after the catch and the way he just falls down is borderline pathetic.....

and the way he portrayed in the media as opposed to more bostrious WR's is horrible.... they make him seem like a great guy , but after meeting him a couple (once for a few hours) he is a grade one a- hole
I've heard he is a total #####, yet he's always portrayed as a quiet, nice guy.Overrated

Offense: Vince Young/Vincent Jackson

Defense: Roy Williams

 
Hmmm...... not sure.

The answer a couple years ago was Shaun Alexander .... but that's more than obvious now.

I'll go out on a limb and piss people off and say -

Marvin Harrison

he is definetly the benefactor of Manning more than vice-versa.

he does little after the catch and the way he just falls down is borderline pathetic.....

and the way he portrayed in the media as opposed to more bostrious WR's is horrible.... they make him seem like a great guy , but after meeting him a couple (once for a few hours) he is a grade one a- hole
I wouldn't say he's ever been over-rated. He's old and frail now so he totally avoids contact. But that time he fell down and the Broncos defenders never went over to touch him. THat was classic when he got up and strolled into the endzone. He's a great route runner and hard worker. He would not be where he is without Manning but he's a great WR. Or was. So many times he totally smoked a DB. Anotehr classic was when an overmatched Deion Sanders tried to cover Harrison and Harrison made him look so bad that Sanders had to grab his hammy as he watched a double move Harrison school him.
 
good insight here. I kinda think Randy Moss is overrated. Call me crazy but the only reason Moss had 23 TDS last year is because of spygate. I also think Peyton Manning is overrated... By the way who is better Manning or Brady???
Randy Moss= a hall of fame lock, but only if he gets a ringbased on rings - tom bradybased on actual performance and health - peyton manning
But the only reason Brady has all his rings is because of the stupid tuck rule, remember..
 
good insight here. I kinda think Randy Moss is overrated. Call me crazy but the only reason Moss had 23 TDS last year is because of spygate. I also think Peyton Manning is overrated... By the way who is better Manning or Brady???
Randy Moss= a hall of fame lock, but only if he gets a ringbased on rings - tom bradybased on actual performance and health - peyton manning
But the only reason Brady has all his rings is because of the stupid tuck rule, remember..
tuck rule my ###, it is because of bill belicheat.
 
good insight here. I kinda think Randy Moss is overrated. Call me crazy but the only reason Moss had 23 TDS last year is because of spygate. I also think Peyton Manning is overrated... By the way who is better Manning or Brady???
Randy Moss= a hall of fame lock, but only if he gets a ringbased on rings - tom bradybased on actual performance and health - peyton manning
But the only reason Brady has all his rings is because of the stupid tuck rule, remember..
tuck rule my ###, it is because of bill belicheat.
We get it. Move along.J
 
good insight here. I kinda think Randy Moss is overrated. Call me crazy but the only reason Moss had 23 TDS last year is because of spygate. I also think Peyton Manning is overrated... By the way who is better Manning or Brady???
Randy Moss= a hall of fame lock, but only if he gets a ringbased on rings - tom bradybased on actual performance and health - peyton manning
But the only reason Brady has all his rings is because of the stupid tuck rule, remember..
tuck rule my ###, it is because of bill belicheat.
We get it. Move along.J
maybe it worked for one year? what about the other two rings? exactly. they cheated, and goodell has the evidence.
 
RB- Reggie Bush (Was Caddalac few years until he finally fell)

WR- Randy Moss His huge year last year set it up for this year!

(Playoff production was the writeing on the wall for me)

TE- Gates (Hats off for being the top TE 3 or 4 years ruinning but

time to unload as his crown has came to an end)

QB- Palmer (He's still going off boardS 3RD OR 4TH QB. Even with Chad last year

he couldn;t get it done! He certainly won;t be getting it done this year!)

 
I agree with many that have posted, but one that gets me every Sunday is Vince Young.

This guy does not impress me at all as a QB. Then again if you loved Michael Vick then you probably love this guy. I understand that you can use him as a QB and a runner, but his passing ability is sub par IMO.

 
I agree with many that have posted, but one that gets me every Sunday is Vince Young. This guy does not impress me at all as a QB. Then again if you loved Michael Vick then you probably love this guy. I understand that you can use him as a QB and a runner, but his passing ability is sub par IMO.
The Titans' roster filled with Pro Bowl receivers have helped VY look good.
 
I agree with many that have posted, but one that gets me every Sunday is Vince Young. This guy does not impress me at all as a QB. Then again if you loved Michael Vick then you probably love this guy. I understand that you can use him as a QB and a runner, but his passing ability is sub par IMO.
The Titans' roster filled with Pro Bowl receivers have helped VY look good.
So just because he is on a poor roster you can just assume what he could do in a Colts offense? No way can you predict that, you have to look at what the guy is in the situation he is in. Or better yet, don't be bragging the guy up like he is the next great thing. For god's sake man, he only threw for 17 TD's last year. David Garrard threw for 18 TD's and missed 4 games last year. But you don't hear his name being spread around like Youngs. And frankly, I don't think JAX WR's are any better than the Titans. I'll give them slight edge, but not much.
 
I agree with many that have posted, but one that gets me every Sunday is Vince Young. This guy does not impress me at all as a QB. Then again if you loved Michael Vick then you probably love this guy. I understand that you can use him as a QB and a runner, but his passing ability is sub par IMO.
The Titans' roster filled with Pro Bowl receivers have helped VY look good.
So just because he is on a poor roster you can just assume what he could do in a Colts offense? No way can you predict that, you have to look at what the guy is in the situation he is in. Or better yet, don't be bragging the guy up like he is the next great thing. For god's sake man, he only threw for 17 TD's last year. David Garrard threw for 18 TD's and missed 4 games last year. But you don't hear his name being spread around like Youngs. And frankly, I don't think JAX WR's are any better than the Titans. I'll give them slight edge, but not much.
Qb are judged by team wins and losses. VY led the Titans to a 10-6 record last yr while playing in the same division as the Colts. That is impressive and sure Young needs to continue to improve, but the Titans are not doing him any favors by drafting rbs early in every draft instead of some wr help. Vince Young is a natural born leader and winner. I'll let you stat geeks worry about his numbers. Titans and their fans only care about W-L.
 
I agree with many that have posted, but one that gets me every Sunday is Vince Young. This guy does not impress me at all as a QB. Then again if you loved Michael Vick then you probably love this guy. I understand that you can use him as a QB and a runner, but his passing ability is sub par IMO.
The Titans' roster filled with Pro Bowl receivers have helped VY look good.
So just because he is on a poor roster you can just assume what he could do in a Colts offense? No way can you predict that, you have to look at what the guy is in the situation he is in. Or better yet, don't be bragging the guy up like he is the next great thing. For god's sake man, he only threw for 17 TD's last year. David Garrard threw for 18 TD's and missed 4 games last year. But you don't hear his name being spread around like Youngs. And frankly, I don't think JAX WR's are any better than the Titans. I'll give them slight edge, but not much.
Qb are judged by team wins and losses. VY led the Titans to a 10-6 record last yr while playing in the same division as the Colts. That is impressive and sure Young needs to continue to improve, but the Titans are not doing him any favors by drafting rbs early in every draft instead of some wr help. Vince Young is a natural born leader and winner. I'll let you stat geeks worry about his numbers. Titans and their fans only care about W-L.
So essentially then we agree. We can call him the next Brad Johnson. He can manage a game and get you a W, but it isn't going to be stat "wow'ing" numbers. Therefor the title of this tread is the most overrated player, and I think he has to be up there as when was the last time you heard of Brad Johnson spoke of in the same context that people talk about Vince Young.
 
I agree with many that have posted, but one that gets me every Sunday is Vince Young.

This guy does not impress me at all as a QB. Then again if you loved Michael Vick then you probably love this guy. I understand that you can use him as a QB and a runner, but his passing ability is sub par IMO.
The Titans' roster filled with Pro Bowl receivers have helped VY look good.
So just because he is on a poor roster you can just assume what he could do in a Colts offense? No way can you predict that, you have to look at what the guy is in the situation he is in. Or better yet, don't be bragging the guy up like he is the next great thing. For god's sake man, he only threw for 17 TD's last year. David Garrard threw for 18 TD's and missed 4 games last year. But you don't hear his name being spread around like Youngs. And frankly, I don't think JAX WR's are any better than the Titans. I'll give them slight edge, but not much.
Actually, he only threw 9 TDs. 17 was the number of INTs.But in any case, yes, Vince Young is junk. I get so tired of hearing how great he is, or is supposed to be, or if he had receivers, or if he had more time to develop and learn the game, or...

Well, you get the idea. He's terrible. Just watching him play, or try to play, is painful.

 
I agree with many that have posted, but one that gets me every Sunday is Vince Young.

This guy does not impress me at all as a QB. Then again if you loved Michael Vick then you probably love this guy. I understand that you can use him as a QB and a runner, but his passing ability is sub par IMO.
The Titans' roster filled with Pro Bowl receivers have helped VY look good.
So just because he is on a poor roster you can just assume what he could do in a Colts offense? No way can you predict that, you have to look at what the guy is in the situation he is in. Or better yet, don't be bragging the guy up like he is the next great thing. For god's sake man, he only threw for 17 TD's last year. David Garrard threw for 18 TD's and missed 4 games last year. But you don't hear his name being spread around like Youngs. And frankly, I don't think JAX WR's are any better than the Titans. I'll give them slight edge, but not much.
Actually, he only threw 9 TDs. 17 was the number of INTs.But in any case, yes, Vince Young is junk. I get so tired of hearing how great he is, or is supposed to be, or if he had receivers, or if he had more time to develop and learn the game, or...

Well, you get the idea. He's terrible. Just watching him play, or try to play, is painful.
:) How could of I missed that spectacular number. I was just saw 17 and thought a man of this caliber had to have at least 17 TD's. 9...are you kidding me. How can you honestly make an argument for a guy who can't even throw double digit TD's?
 
I agree with many that have posted, but one that gets me every Sunday is Vince Young.

This guy does not impress me at all as a QB. Then again if you loved Michael Vick then you probably love this guy. I understand that you can use him as a QB and a runner, but his passing ability is sub par IMO.
The Titans' roster filled with Pro Bowl receivers have helped VY look good.
So just because he is on a poor roster you can just assume what he could do in a Colts offense? No way can you predict that, you have to look at what the guy is in the situation he is in. Or better yet, don't be bragging the guy up like he is the next great thing. For god's sake man, he only threw for 17 TD's last year. David Garrard threw for 18 TD's and missed 4 games last year. But you don't hear his name being spread around like Youngs. And frankly, I don't think JAX WR's are any better than the Titans. I'll give them slight edge, but not much.
Actually, he only threw 9 TDs. 17 was the number of INTs.But in any case, yes, Vince Young is junk. I get so tired of hearing how great he is, or is supposed to be, or if he had receivers, or if he had more time to develop and learn the game, or...

Well, you get the idea. He's terrible. Just watching him play, or try to play, is painful.
:thumbup: How could of I missed that spectacular number. I was just saw 17 and thought a man of this caliber had to have at least 17 TD's. 9...are you kidding me. How can you honestly make an argument for a guy who can't even throw double digit TD's?
Yes, "9", but at least that's higher than his Wonderlic score was!!
 
For those that say Reggie Bush:

Don't you have to be pretty highly rated to be considered overrated? These days, I don't think most people would rate him very high.

Honestly, I've been hearing so much negativity about Reggie lately, I'm beginning to think he's a bit UNDERrated. Seems like most people have given up on the guy after just two years.

 
I'll vote for Vilma. Sure, he made lots of tackles in his first couple of years, but they were all in the backfield and he got dragged 4 to 5 yards on every play. He averaged 1.5 ints per year, but less than one sack. Even as a Jets fan, I never bought the hype.

 
brady2moss said:
good insight here. I kinda think Randy Moss is overrated. Call me crazy but the only reason Moss had 23 TDS last year is because of spygate. I also think Peyton Manning is overrated... By the way who is better Manning or Brady???
Peyton Manning is not overrated. You give him any receiver in the league (superior or just decent), and he makes them a better player. You cant teach that.
 
brady2moss said:
good insight here. I kinda think Randy Moss is overrated. Call me crazy but the only reason Moss had 23 TDS last year is because of spygate. I also think Peyton Manning is overrated... By the way who is better Manning or Brady???
Peyton Manning is not overrated. You give him any receiver in the league (superior or just decent), and he makes them a better player. You cant teach that.
I'll go along with that.
 
FF_Guru said:
Irish said:
FF_Guru said:
Irish said:
FF_Guru said:
I agree with many that have posted, but one that gets me every Sunday is Vince Young. This guy does not impress me at all as a QB. Then again if you loved Michael Vick then you probably love this guy. I understand that you can use him as a QB and a runner, but his passing ability is sub par IMO.
The Titans' roster filled with Pro Bowl receivers have helped VY look good.
So just because he is on a poor roster you can just assume what he could do in a Colts offense? No way can you predict that, you have to look at what the guy is in the situation he is in. Or better yet, don't be bragging the guy up like he is the next great thing. For god's sake man, he only threw for 17 TD's last year. David Garrard threw for 18 TD's and missed 4 games last year. But you don't hear his name being spread around like Youngs. And frankly, I don't think JAX WR's are any better than the Titans. I'll give them slight edge, but not much.
Qb are judged by team wins and losses. VY led the Titans to a 10-6 record last yr while playing in the same division as the Colts. That is impressive and sure Young needs to continue to improve, but the Titans are not doing him any favors by drafting rbs early in every draft instead of some wr help. Vince Young is a natural born leader and winner. I'll let you stat geeks worry about his numbers. Titans and their fans only care about W-L.
So essentially then we agree. We can call him the next Brad Johnson. He can manage a game and get you a W, but it isn't going to be stat "wow'ing" numbers. Therefor the title of this tread is the most overrated player, and I think he has to be up there as when was the last time you heard of Brad Johnson spoke of in the same context that people talk about Vince Young.
Well after Young has played 14-16 yrs in the league like Johnson and he still has not progressed then by all means you can bump this thread.
 
FF_Guru said:
I agree with many that have posted, but one that gets me every Sunday is Vince Young. This guy does not impress me at all as a QB. Then again if you loved Michael Vick then you probably love this guy. I understand that you can use him as a QB and a runner, but his passing ability is sub par IMO.
Yeah, this Qb hasn't produced too many wins with his arm, but he has took the game and won it with his legs a few times- I couldn't believe it. After this draft, I think a lot of people will agree with you that the Titans wont match up offensively with any of their division rivals; Garrard has looked much better than Vince.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top