My last keeper - I'm on the fence (1 Viewer)

[Finless]

H2H - Points league

Narrowed it down to Hamilton, Beckham, Bruce, Span and Nolasco

I'm pretty deep at CI/3rd with Longoria, A-Rod, Sandoval and Howard

OF consist of Braun, Werth, Kemp, BJ Upton and Adam Jones

Kept pitchers - Josh Johnson, Kershaw, Slowey, and Strasburg

My team is stacked and I can afford to miss going for high risk high reward. Was leaning Hamilton.

 

[canuckchieffan]

It's tough to go wrong but looking at your current depth. I'd maybe steer away from an OF. Personally I'd consider Beckham. He'll have 2B eligibility soon enough. There aren't many 20 HR 2B types out there. And Beckham will be just that for years to come.

 

[Mentos]

H2H - Points leagueNarrowed it down to Hamilton, Beckham, Bruce, Span and NolascoI'm pretty deep at CI/3rd with Longoria, A-Rod, Sandoval and HowardOF consist of Braun, Werth, Kemp, BJ Upton and Adam JonesKept pitchers - Josh Johnson, Kershaw, Slowey, and StrasburgMy team is stacked and I can afford to miss going for high risk high reward. Was leaning Hamilton.

Since you feel your team is stacked, you may want to roll the dice and keep Beckham in hopes that he becomes really good. Hamilton is risky. Will he play anywhere close to 150 games this year? Beckham has added value because he should qualify at 3B and 2B this year.I am looking to start a keeper league this year. The draft would be next weekend. I have a week to devise some sort of constitution. I don't want anything too extravagant. I am curious as to how many keepers your league allows and how do you handle the draft?

 

[Finless]

H2H - Points leagueNarrowed it down to Hamilton, Beckham, Bruce, Span and NolascoI'm pretty deep at CI/3rd with Longoria, A-Rod, Sandoval and HowardOF consist of Braun, Werth, Kemp, BJ Upton and Adam JonesKept pitchers - Josh Johnson, Kershaw, Slowey, and StrasburgMy team is stacked and I can afford to miss going for high risk high reward. Was leaning Hamilton.

Since you feel your team is stacked, you may want to roll the dice and keep Beckham in hopes that he becomes really good. Hamilton is risky. Will he play anywhere close to 150 games this year? Beckham has added value because he should qualify at 3B and 2B this year.I am looking to start a keeper league this year. The draft would be next weekend. I have a week to devise some sort of constitution. I don't want anything too extravagant. I am curious as to how many keepers your league allows and how do you handle the draft?

This is our 4th season. I forget exactly how it went but we kept less the first few season. This season we keep 15 and next we keep 25. Kind of unorthodox but it was laid out and voted on at the end of the 1st season.

 

[Finless]

Completely overlooked Beckham's eligibility at 2nd base. I do not have a 2nd baseman. Shipped Kinsler and Andrus for A-Rod in the offseason.

Beckham it is.

 

[Finless]

I've also got Ian Stewart