My top 10 Qb's (1 Viewer)

[Sir Psycho]

jeez...some of u guys must have gotten burned by Warner in the past or something...lets just say Warner helped me win my league last season with his lights out playing the second half of the year...when he`s on he`s great ...when he`s not he`s average(usually due to an injury)...hard to argue about 300 yards and double digit TD`s on average

can we NOW include Warner in the top 10 QB list for week 3

Let's see...Cutler

Romo

Brees

Rodgers

Manning

McNabb

Warner

Roeth

Favre

Delhomme

Kitna

Yep, Kurt is now the #7 QB going forward, in the all important "my opinion" rankings.

I look for Cassel to have 2.5 TDs against Miami next week, at which point he slides in right after Big Ben to give you the top 12.

Eli ?

 

[Blackjacks]

Warner makes this list? Seriously ? You must have him on your team. AZ puts up a whopping 285 net yards against the mighty SF D on over 37 minutes of possesion and Kurt Warner is Top 10 worthy. WOW !! Not even on Madden '09 does he even make top 15. WOW!

just wondering if you still think this way?

 

[davearm]

Warner makes this list? Seriously ? You must have him on your team. AZ puts up a whopping 285 net yards against the mighty SF D on over 37 minutes of possesion and Kurt Warner is Top 10 worthy. WOW !! Not even on Madden '09 does he even make top 15. WOW!

Thank you for your wonderful opinion

Not opinion my friend, those are actual stats. I notice that the OP is just loaded with statistical information and no opinion at all. Sincerely,

The Kettle

Fact - Warner threw 29 td's without playing a whole season last yearFact - He has 2 ultra studs at wideout

Fact - He doesn't have a stud rb

Fact - He plays a very week schedule

Fact - His defensive isn't dominating by any means which is going to keep him passing all game

Fact - He is driven knowing Leinart could be in at any time due to his screw up

These are all facts

You've got one fact there... you can go look up the 29 TDs and see that it occurred in less than 16 games.The rest are opinions.

The stats don't say Fitz and Boldin are great?Has Edge put up great #'s the last 2 years?

Weak schedule, well I guess that is opinion but a fact is they play in the NFC West where all other three teams got slaughtered this week and they get 5 more games against them.

It can be definetly prooven that there d hasn't been dominating the last few years

I guess it's an opinion that Warner is thriving due to the young 1st round draft pick sitting on the bench making on that money just waiting for him to screw up.

Your original post, and this last reply, are both chock full of subjective terms which, by definition, are opinions. I've highlighted them for you.What constutes a "stud" is purely a matter of opinion. There's no universally-accepted standard. Someone may believe the only "ultra stud" WR in the history of the NFL is Jerry Rice. That would be that person's opinion. Apparently Boldin and Fitzgerald meet your standard. That would be your opinion.

And so on with all the rest... what's the definition of "weak"? What's the definition of "dominating"? etc. All open to interpretation/opinion. That's a fact.

 

[C-Bound]

No Rivers makes sense too.

 

[C-Pod]

If Farve is mention then where the hell is Rodgers? I'm offended by this oversight.

My thoughts exactly. Rodgers has more yards, more TD's, and more wins. Plus a rushing TD. Mind you, the defenses Rodgers has faced aren't the Patriots. Perhaps that's taken into account.

 

[Archie Bunker]

jeez...some of u guys must have gotten burned by Warner in the past or something...lets just say Warner helped me win my league last season with his lights out playing the second half of the year...when he`s on he`s great ...when he`s not he`s average(usually due to an injury)...hard to argue about 300 yards and double digit TD`s on average

can we NOW include Warner in the top 10 QB list for week 3

Let's see...Cutler

Romo

Brees

Rodgers

Manning

McNabb

Warner

Roeth

Favre

Delhomme

Kitna

Yep, Kurt is now the #7 QB going forward, in the all important "my opinion" rankings.

I look for Cassel to have 2.5 TDs against Miami next week, at which point he slides in right after Big Ben to give you the top 12.

I can say with 100% assurance that Cassel will not throw 2.5 TDs next week. Seriously, what has Cassel shown to indicate he should be top 10? He won against KC? Even the Raiders beat up on them. A win against the Jets? Only because the Jets we completely inept in the red zone? 2.5 TDs against the Dolphins? My grandmother could throw 3 tds against the Dolphins and she's been dead for 7 years. You can preach system all you want, but Cassel has been solid, but not above average. He may improve over the course of the season, but if you're counting on him as a starter now, you'll likely be out of the playoff race by the time he begins to pay dividends.

 

[j3r3m3y]

Warner makes this list? Seriously ? You must have him on your team. AZ puts up a whopping 285 net yards against the mighty SF D on over 37 minutes of possesion and Kurt Warner is Top 10 worthy. WOW !! Not even on Madden '09 does he even make top 15. WOW!

just wondering if you still think this way?

I do, but I am coming around.

 

[Archie Bunker]

If Farve is mention then where the hell is Rodgers? I'm offended by this oversight.

My thoughts exactly. Rodgers has more yards, more TD's, and more wins. Plus a rushing TD. Mind you, the defenses Rodgers has faced aren't the Patriots. Perhaps that's taken into account.

I admit to being biased as I did draft Rodgers as one of my QBs, but he has looked really good, even against a good Minnesota defense. One can argue that he has a better supporting cast as well. I think I would take Jennings, Driver, Lee, and Jones vs. Cotchery, Coles, et al. Rodgers has been very accurate, too. He doesn't have that gunslinger mentality of Favre, which I think is more good than bad.

 

[SeniorVBDStudent]

jeez...some of u guys must have gotten burned by Warner in the past or something...lets just say Warner helped me win my league last season with his lights out playing the second half of the year...when he`s on he`s great ...when he`s not he`s average(usually due to an injury)...hard to argue about 300 yards and double digit TD`s on average

can we NOW include Warner in the top 10 QB list for week 3

Let's see...Cutler

Romo

Brees

Rodgers

Manning

McNabb

Warner

Roeth

Favre

Delhomme

Kitna

Yep, Kurt is now the #7 QB going forward, in the all important "my opinion" rankings.

I look for Cassel to have 2.5 TDs against Miami next week, at which point he slides in right after Big Ben to give you the top 12.

I can say with 100% assurance that Cassel will not throw 2.5 TDs next week. Seriously, what has Cassel shown to indicate he should be top 10? He won against KC? Even the Raiders beat up on them. A win against the Jets? Only because the Jets we completely inept in the red zone? 2.5 TDs against the Dolphins? My grandmother could throw 3 tds against the Dolphins and she's been dead for 7 years. You can preach system all you want, but Cassel has been solid, but not above average. He may improve over the course of the season, but if you're counting on him as a starter now, you'll likely be out of the playoff race by the time he begins to pay dividends.

OK. 4 TDs.