This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
Chris Johnson down?
Care to elaborate?
How do you justify Addia ahead of Barber? I can't agree with FWP ahead of Barber either.
Let's see how consistent he is first
Im gonna go out on a limb and say he'll be in your top 5 next week.
I thought he looked very good when he touched the ball and he was the only one I can say that about. I would feel very comfortable in saying he will be among the top of touches again for rb's and he has shown the consistency in the past to trust for him to finish there again. Zorn will have Portis touch it 25 to 30 this week.....book it.
If you were drafting this week how many RB's would you take ahead of him?
I'm worried about touches for Barber. I still thik his td #'s will be high but I think he's gonna start sharing it with Felix alot more quickly.Addai is in a high power offense and will be fine once the rust gets off Peyton. Chicago has a good d, I'm not getting down onhim after ne bad week. Saturday's coming back soon also.
looks about right to me, but of course, this is assuming everyone stays healthy. I would move Barber way up if you're not factoring in the injury prone factor, and I would also move Jacobs up, while moving Portis down to about 10 and FWP around 10 also. Chris Johnson should hover around but not yet...
You can definetly make an arguement for him. I just don't trust him or Martz but yo could make very good cases for him
Good question - mabey 6 or 7.
The title say week 1, not from here on out.
Wow, 1 game gets him into the mid 1st. I like what I see from him, but think that is too big of a jump.
You guys realize the Felix Jones will be cutting into his workload a little bit?
If he stays healthy, I think he's a lock for top 10 this year. His situation is perfect and he's obvisouly got the talent.
So now Chris Johnson is gonna have a better year than Addai? Are you guys insane?
Not really. Don't you know that half of the consensus top 10 at the beginning of the year won't finish there?I'm not saying he'll finish ahead of anyone, but what I'm saying is he's got a great shot at top 10 if he stays healthy.
we'll see how much next week
If liking Johnson over Addai this year makes me insane, then yes, i am insane. I didnt like Addai before the season started, nothing that happened in the first week changed my mind. I will be sure to bump your post in 4-5 weeks when my insanity turns to genius.
No kidding, people are talking about Chris Johnson as a top 7-8 guy but Turner is nowhere to be seen? Willie Parker ahead of Turner? I don't get it.Ryan Grant is another guy that isn't getting the proper respect. Hell, I'd take Grant over Portis, Bush and...maybe its easier if I do a top-10.1.LT2.Westbrook3.Peterson4.Addai5.Barber6.Lynch7.Grant8.Turner9.Gore10.JacksonWhere's Michael Turner
Pretty good list . . .No kidding, people are talking about Chris Johnson as a top 7-8 guy but Turner is nowhere to be seen? Willie Parker ahead of Turner? I don't get it.Ryan Grant is another guy that isn't getting the proper respect. Hell, I'd take Grant over Portis, Bush and...maybe its easier if I do a top-10.1.LT2.Westbrook3.Peterson4.Addai5.Barber6.Lynch7.Grant8.Turner9.Gore10.JacksonWhere's Michael Turner
We get it. Chris Johnson is your boyfriend. Go talk about him somewhere else, he is not even close to a first round pick yet.
Not for guppies.
plus the questions I had about him had to do with durability and he is already dinged up in week 1It's from after seeing them play for a week and the how they are involved in the offense. Also in Steven Jackson's case as well as some others how the offense they plan on looks.
Why would you have those 2 on here. GB showed they want to get other people the ball. Also I don't care how talented Jackson is, which I think he is, his offense is horrible. As for Turner, I don't believe in ATL for the whole year. I will be shocked that after another week (in Tampa) he'll have as good of a showing but he could.No kidding, people are talking about Chris Johnson as a top 7-8 guy but Turner is nowhere to be seen? Willie Parker ahead of Turner? I don't get it.Ryan Grant is another guy that isn't getting the proper respect. Hell, I'd take Grant over Portis, Bush and...maybe its easier if I do a top-10.Where's Michael Turner
1.LT
2.Westbrook
3.Peterson
4.Addai
5.Barber
6.Lynch
7.Grant
8.Turner
9.Gore
10.Jackson
Where's Michael Turner
The guy rolls for 220 and he doesn't even make a top 10 list. Damn.
Relax toolbox. And please continue to pick off of your magazine top 10 each year, guys like myself need guys like you in our leagues.
LT didn't have a great game....would you knock him out?Portis looked good and I still believe that team can run due to a great o line. I'm a Rams fan living in STL and I'm here to tell you he is in for a long season, probably a coach getting fired mid season and Pace already injured. It is going to be a long season for Jackson owners'. Like I've said earlier Turner could be the surprise of this year but if I were drafting right now I wouldn't take him over the other people I have listed.LJ just plains sucks
I'll be sold on Turner when he plays like that against an NFL defense.Where's Michael Turner
Me too I guess. I also think Turner needs to be on the list.
Just remember it was against Detroit who has a very bad defense and it was a very big first game for them at home. I could be wrong but I don't see him in the top ten.Where's Michael Turner
Was in a hurry last night so I didn't get to list explanations that helped make my descion making on these players. However since you are so quick to criticize me for my unprofessionalism I'd love to see your list with reasoning at each pick
is this going to be a weekly thing?
you missed the boat on a lot of RB's.Forte was MUCH better than Addai. FWP bested his TD totals from 2007, he's probably done scoring for the rest of the 2008 season 
How is Bush ranked ahead of Barber, Forte, C. Johnson?no Gore? 
