My top ten qb's (1 Viewer)

[Blackjacks]

1) Brees (4)

2) Romo (1)

3) Cutler (2)

4) P.Manning (3)

5) Warner (6)

6) E. Manning (10)

7) McNabb (5)

8) Rivers (7)

9) Favre (same)

10) Rodgers (8)

 

[SeniorVBDStudent]

Rivers has outperformed McNabb; I guess you see the future looking better for McNabb when Curtis joins Brown and Jackson in the receiving corps?

 

[W1cked]

Rogers has two 300+ yard games. Rivers - 1

Rogers 11 Tds 9 air/2 ground - Rivers 11 Tds Air

Rogers 82 yards rushing, Rivers 10.

Rogers 1274 yards passing - Rivers 1183

 

[Blackjacks]

Rivers has outperformed McNabb; I guess you see the future looking better for McNabb when Curtis joins Brown and Jackson in the receiving corps?

Absolutely, I'm not a big believer of Rivers. I will admit I like him as a qb in NFL I just don't like him for fantasy purposes.I much more prefer McNabb especially once they get healthy.

 

[Blackjacks]

Rogers has two 300+ yard games. Rivers - 1Rogers 11 Tds 9 air/2 ground - Rivers 11 Tds AirRogers 82 yards rushing, Rivers 10. Rogers 1274 yards passing - Rivers 1183

He has looked very good so far this year.

 

[Dt's Mules]

favre too low based upon his upcoming schedule.

 

[travdogg]

1) Brees (4)2) Romo (1)3) Cutler (2)4) P.Manning (3)5) Warner (6)6) E. Manning (10)7) McNabb (5)8) Rivers (7)9) Favre (same)10) Rodgers (8)

I love these lists and seeing how they compare to mine. I kinda think Romo and Manning are too high based on their respective track records. I just don't think Romo will be what he was last season and Manning won't be his "elite" self. As of now I'm at:1.Brees2.Cutler3.McNabb, I think he'll be huge once Curtis gets healthy.4.Romo5.Warner, he really impressed me in the Buffalo game.6.Peyton7.Rivers8.Big Ben, I expect more games like the Jags game and less like the Eagles game.9.Eli10.Favre

 

[coachjim]

favre too low based upon his upcoming schedule.

I agree. It looks as soft as you can get. The only three tough games he might have left are 2 with the Bills and Tenn. The others are cake. I can see 30 TD's with ease.

 

[blackjack23]

Mine would be

1. Brees

2. Romo

3. Cutler

4. Warner

5. PManning

6. Rodgers

7. Favre

8. Rivers

9. McNabb

10. EManning

Barely missing the cut Roethlisberger, Schaub, Palmer

 

[Tau837]

Rogers has two 300+ yard games. Rivers - 1Rogers 11 Tds 9 air/2 ground - Rivers 11 Tds AirRogers 82 yards rushing, Rivers 10. Rogers 1274 yards passing - Rivers 1183

Neither has what I would call an easy schedule remaining. And both have been dinged up recently but are playing through it. Rodgers does have to play outdoors in Green Bay and Chicago in December. It's close, but I'd rank Rivers slightly higher, in part because I think he is less likely to miss time due to injury.